5 ms·
I thought continuity provides an answer: 11:59:59.9999999999 is still AM. 12:00:00.0000000001 is clearly PM. When should the AM switch to PM? My intuition sa
by FabHK 9y ago
I thought continuity provides an answer:
11:59:59.9999999999 is still AM.
12:00:00.0000000001 is clearly PM.
When should the AM switch to PM? My intuition says at the same time that the 11 switches to a 12 (and all the 9's switch to 0's). Thus, noon is pm.
Having said that, in reality the solution is banish the abominable 12 hour clock, and use the 24 hour clock.
That also removes the ambiguity whether "Midnight on January 1st 2017" means 2017-01-01 00:00 or 2017-01-01 24:00 == 2017-01-02 00:00.
- Finnucane 9y agoBut whose 24 hour clock? Should we all be on GMT? That's arbitrary and eurocentric. And let's get rid of those pesky arbitrary time zones too. We should all be able to have our own personal time zones.
- beambot 9y agoEven if you eliminate time zones, you still end up having to do lookups whenever you're communicating across zones. E.g. "If I call my brother now from SFBA, is it normal daytime hours in Switzerland?" Knowing that right now is 15:00 GMT doesn't help answer that question.
- ljm 9y agoMeasuring time over 24 hours rather than 12*2 hours makes it abundantly clear what part of the day you're referring to, no matter what timezone it is. It's not about putting everyone on the same time, but describing it without ambiguity. This is especially important in language, where in some cultures the word 'tonight' actually translates to what you'd call 'last night' in English, for example.
- deadbunny 9y agoWhat? The 24hour clock has nothing to do with timezones. 11:00 is the same as 11am and 21:00 is the same as 9pm whatever your timezone.
- coldtea 9y ago>But whose 24 hour clock? Should we all be on GMT? That's arbitrary and eurocentric. Doesn't matter. Anything would be arbitrary. Just pick one and be done with it, and we already have GMT and UTC.
- function_seven 9y agoSorry if I misinterpreted your response, but do you think doing away with timezones in "normal" life would be a net gain? I think it would add way more confusion than it would eliminate. (e.g. "Let's have dinner Wednesday night" would be very confusing in some parts of the world. "Is that the Wednesday night just after Tuesday night? Or the one just before Thursday night?")
- coldtea 9y ago>Sorry if I misinterpreted your response, but do you think doing away with timezones in "normal" life would be a net gain? I think it would add way more confusion than it would eliminate. It's the exact same information needed both today and after doing away with timezones. If you're in the same place as the other person, there's no confusion at all. If everybody uses GMT, you know e.g. that diner around your parts (e.g. London) is around 19:00 (7pm). If you live in California you know that diner around your parts is around 03:00 (3am). If you're in different countries, e.g. one is in London and the other is in California, "Let's have a Skype at around 11:00" is unambiguous -- it will be 11:00 at both your clocks. Lastly, if you're in different countries and you want to call someone in California, and wonder whether now (11:00 GMT) is a good time, you just have to know the offset number (the sun rises there 8 hours later) which is the same as knowing the timezone. Without timezones, it's only knowing the "part of the day" (whether it's late or dusk or sunrise time etc) in another place that requires knowing an offset (similar to knowing the timezone offset today). All other calculations and coordination is vastly simplified. >(e.g. "Let's have dinner Wednesday night" would be very confusing in some parts of the world. "Is that the Wednesday night just after Tuesday night? Or the one just before Thursday night?") How is that confusing? Assuming we're talking about dinner, it would have to be dinner time in the place those people live. So, e.g. a little before or after sunset time on Wednesday. Whether that corresponds to 7pm or 2am or 12pm, people will know when it's that time where they live.
- Fnoord 9y ago> But whose 24 hour clock? The one from your current timezone, obviously. And if you omit your timezone, you obviously mean your current timezone; the one you're residing in. If you're in Paris and you tell your kid dinner is at 6 PM then you mean local time. If your kid then comes home at 7 PM and says oh I thought you meant UK time then that's obviously your kid being a smartass. Even if you are both from UK. Why? Because it isn't practical to stick to a timezone you're not residing in. Wether we're talking about 6 PM or 18 and 7 PM or 19 makes zero difference to your argument. 24H notation is just simpler and more practical. You don't have to resort to keyboard, it even takes up less space, and most importantly the context is less relevant ie. if AM/PM is omitted you still know what's up. The only reason people stick to 24H notation, or imperial system for that matter, is "because we've always done it like this" ie. an argumentum ad antiquitatem. Not because it is better. Backwards compatibility comes with a price. You should always question whether the price is worth it. I can think of one problem with the 24H system: analogue clocks like watches and churches. They use 12 hours. But when you watch that, that's communication to you as a human instead of human to human. And you know whether it is morning or evening, day or night, unless you're in a truly strange mental state.
- naikrovek 9y agoI believe the actual answer is that there is no 12:00 AM or PM. You're meant to say "twelve noon" or "twelve midnight" rather than AM or PM for this exact reason. "actual answer" is maybe a bit strong - I read it somewhere but I can't remember where. The site or book or wherever it was that I read that did seem quite authoritative on the matter, however!
- mywittyname 9y agoWell, since 9.9999999... = 10 [0], then 50 + 9.999999... = 50 + 10 Given that, to you claim, 11:59.59.99999[...] is still AM, then 11:59:60 is still AM, thus 12:00:00 is still AM. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDtFBSjNmm0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDtFBSjNmm0 /s
- FabHK 9y agoWell, while the numbers of nines is finite, it's still AM. I'm arguing for switching the very moment the number of nines is infinite, or, in other words, they've turned into (an equally infinite number of) zeros.
- jjoonathan 9y agoLimits work from both directions. 12:00:00.1 is PM, 12:00:00.00001 is PM, so 12:00:00 is PM. Contradiction. /s, it's all in good fun :)
- barbs 9y agoEven if you're right, by the time the words come out of your mouth, it's now PM. That's how I remember it anyway :)
- fallingfrog 9y agoThat's true for every hour though. The same argument applies to 10:59:59.99999 and 11:00:00 Pop quiz: How many hours passed between 11am and 12am?
- imustbeevil 9y agoThe point is that a nanosecond after noon is "post meridiem".