5 ms·
I've lost about half my bodyweight, so I feel like my experience qualifies to me to offer my opinion that Keto's supposed anti-hunger effects are broscience cra
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago
I've lost about half my bodyweight, so I feel like my experience qualifies to me to offer my opinion that Keto's supposed anti-hunger effects are broscience crap.
Ephedrine or amphetamines, those work.
- TACIXAT 9y agoOmega-3 fats are known to control hunger. That is probably where the claim that a high fat diet like keto can regulate appetite. https://www.livestrong.com/article/296534-omega-3-as-an-appetite-suppressant/ https://www.livestrong.com/article/296534-omega-3-as-an-appe...
- Jemmeh 9y agoIt's not about that. Here's a good youtube video explaining it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dan8qtgQRi8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dan8qtgQRi8
- QAPereo 9y agoI’ve never actually talked about this online before, but now I’m going to. I used to weigh over 560lbs, and I’ve lost 190 of that, with more going every week. I spent a lot of time on this, tried a lot of diets, tried medication, and ultimately considered surgery. In the end a ferocious commitment to eating less, eating better, and moving around more was what worked, and continues to work. Years ago I went to a medically supervised weight loss program, twice, and met a loooot of people of all ages, all with serious weight problems. A few found success with surgery, and maybe half of those kept it off. Of the half that did, they knew going in that they were ready for the hard work, but they were so big they needed a boost to get moving. The people who used drugs never kept it off. The the people who thought the magic was in some special way of eating never kept it off. The people who committed to lifelong lifestyle change kept it off, and it didn’t seem to matter if it was Keto, Atkins, Paleo, or any permutation of potentially healthy lifestyles. The active ingredient is not the plan, it is the desire to commit to the plan with all of your being... for years, forever. For me at least, it was also a matter of growing the fuck up, really taking responsibility for my negative patterns of thought and behavior, and relentlessly working on them in a positive way. It’s hard, but I went from barely being able to walk, to jogging up stairs. Everyone is a bit different, everyone has different issues with food and exercise, and everyone probably has to use a slightly different approach. Still, some constants for me were the need to ditch fast food completely, and soda is now a very rare treat. More than that however, I had to slowly alter my mental habits about food, and really pay attention to how I felt, especially after an unhealthy meal. I basically tried to form new habits to take the place of old destructive habits. Anyway, enough babble from me, I just wanted to add my own perspective as someone doing the work to live, and live well. Edit: I forgot to mention what actually made me post this in the first place, that I found intermittent fasting genuinely helpful. In particular I tend not to have cravings until after I’ve had my first real meal, so I just start a bit later, and have a defined cut-off. I have something with plenty of fiber in the morning, and then just lay off until lunch. More protein with each meal, less sugar, and plenty of fiber, and normal portions.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoI agree actually. You have to really want to change enough go through all the pain and suffering and to persist indefinitely. I have a lot of difficulty with hunger, to the point I couldn't fight it on will alone and would find myself compulsively eating and unable to stop myself. Rather than kill myself out of frustration over slowly undoing all that I had suffered for I kept trying different things until something worked, and that something was ephedrine.
- naasking 9y agoEveryone responds differently to diet and exercise. For me, intense 30 min cardio makes me not hungry, which is probably counterintuitive for most people. And for any nutrition plan,ensure you get all your macros in your feeding window too. I've totally found that hunger is suppressed by IF though, but only after a week or so of doing it. Even if you did everything right, maybe it's just not for your body.
- magic_beans 9y agoExercise is an appetite suppressant (at least for the first hour or so afterwords).
- taneq 9y ago> The active ingredient is not the plan, it is the desire to commit to the plan with all of your being... for years, forever. All of your post is good but this is the most important bit (IMO). The biggest scam the weight loss industry ever pulled on Western civilisation was the redefinition of "diet" from "what you eat" to "a temporary change in what you eat". To maintain a healthy weight you have to monitor your weight, and what you're eating, and adjust the latter in response to the former, forever. It's not a thing with an end. It's how you have to live.
- QAPereo 9y agoThanks very much, and I agree on all counts; it’s really the only advice I can give that I know to be true. You have to want to lose the weight and keep it off, to change profoundly, more than what you’ve been doing for years. The specifics are going to be different for various people, but the commitment over time is the big thing.
- Jemmeh 9y agoThere's more than one way to lose weight. A lot of people in the keto subreddit have lost a lot of weight too. Anecdotal evidence doesn't prove that keto is broscience. There's plenty of studies on it, even in the very article this thread is based on there is one sourced as linked to longevity. Also here's a good youtube video explaining it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dan8qtgQRi8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dan8qtgQRi8