3 ms·
What reason do we have to think that will work, however? Governments have a lot of angles for control and it especially seems to me that it would be personally
by acdha 9y ago
What reason do we have to think that will work, however? Governments have a lot of angles for control and it especially seems to me that it would be personally risky to rely on downloading software, making easily identified network activity, and recording your activity in a public ledger to do anything which is officially banned. Besides being more workable without pervasive internet access, hoarding USD / Euros have the very nice property of not risking retroactive deanonymization.
- viggity 9y agoI agree that bitcoin's public ledger isn't conducive to anonymity (even with address mixers thrown in, and those are totally worthless given the high transaction fess). But that doesn't preclude a new layer on top of bitcoin, or using an alt-coin (monero) that has anonymity baked in. I would say that USD/Euros do have the risk of deanonymization (unlikely as it may be). The government would simply need to say "all bills $20 and over will be worthless in 2 weeks, you need to exchange them for new bills at your bank where your transaction will be recorded". India just did that with not 100 Rupees and higher.
- acdha 9y ago> But that doesn't preclude a new layer on top of bitcoin, or using an alt-coin (monero) that has anonymity baked in. Perhaps, but I'd want that technology to exist and be well peer-reviewed before even considering recommending it in a sensitive context. > I would say that USD/Euros do have the risk of deanonymization (unlikely as it may be). The government would simply need to say "all bills $20 and over will be worthless in 2 weeks, you need to exchange them for new bills at your bank where your transaction will be recorded". India just did that with not 100 Rupees and higher. Note that I was talking about that in the context of a stable currency used in an unstable country, where e.g. the Venezuelan government can't force the US Mint to do anything. However, either way that seems like a much better situation to be in because cash doesn't have a permanent history associated with every bill. Unless they setup the infrastructure to require everyone to record every transaction, all you'd need is one transaction to break the chain — take those new bills and buy dinner and who can link you to the change?