3 ms·
Because the future belongs to fuel cells. Electric cars are undoubtedly the future but batteries, at least in their current form, probably aren't. Huge banks of
by Spivak 9y ago
Because the future belongs to fuel cells. Electric cars are undoubtedly the future but batteries, at least in their current form, probably aren't. Huge banks of batteries are a stop-gap until fuel cell tech matures.
* The practical range of an electric car isn't great. There's no foreseeable story for a <5 minute charge.
* (Compared to fuel cells) Banks of batteries are dangerous in a crash.
I think the Electrek authors are wrong in their take on the situation. Distribution of the hydrogen will have razor thin margins just like gas stations. They're right that the current process for hydrogen isn't exactly efficient today, but that doesn't really sink the tech.
It might not be full fuel cell but a hybrid fuel cell battery car might end up being the best of both worlds.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoWas /s intended? Because electric battery costs are falling faster than solar PV costs fell [1] [2], and there are EV charing stations anywhere there is 120/240 service. There are 39 hydrogen fueling stations in the entire US [3]. There are 8500 Tesla Superchargers alone [4] (not to mention destination chargers, as well as non-Tesla charging stations [5]). [1] https://electrek.co/2017/01/30/electric-vehicle-battery-cost-dropped-80-6-years-227kwh-tesla-190kwh/ https://electrek.co/2017/01/30/electric-vehicle-battery-cost... [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate2564 https://www.nature.com/articles/nclimate2564 [3] https://www.afdc.energy.gov/fuels/hydrogen_locations.html https://www.afdc.energy.gov/fuels/hydrogen_locations.html [4] https://www.tesla.com/supercharger https://www.tesla.com/supercharger [5] https://www.plugshare.com/ https://www.plugshare.com/
- maxerickson 9y agoThere's an argument that running on methanol or ethanol is a requirement for a broad market fuel cell. Just because you can almost drop those directly into the infrastructure used for gasoline. Hydrogen also sucks to store.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI'm unfamiliar with any mass production of methanol as a fuel, and I shudder to think of how much more environmental damage we'd incur attempting to scale up ethanol production (which is already a net negative if you're using corn; there's really nowhere in the US that is conducive to growing sugar beats for production [unlike in South America]). Electricity is the way forward.
- maxerickson 9y agoMethanol is produced at large scale already, using natural gas as a feedstock. Can also use coal. Electricity is probably cleaner.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe real differentiation is charging speed; replacing the reactants is always going to be faster than running the reaction in reverse, so you are never going to get charging a traditional battery to be as fast as refuelling a fuel cell. Even “fast” chargers are going to continue to be slow (a Tesla supercharger takes over an hour for a full charge), making battery cars good for commuting, but bad for long-distance travel. That doesn't mean that battery cars won't have a lasting place in the market: pure commuting cars that can afford long recharge times are likely to be a major chunk of the market. But they are unlikely to be the whole of the market, ever.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Even “fast” chargers are going to continue to be slow (a Tesla supercharger takes over an hour for a full charge) 80% in 30 minutes, which gets you to the next Supercharger. You don't want to fuel to 100% whenever possible, as its slower than pouring electrons into an empty battery.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> 80% in 30 minutes Which is still much longer than 100% fill on a fuel cell (or gas vehicle.)
- toomuchtodo 9y agoAre you taking into account the time savings of only needing to charge on a trip a few times a year (versus a weekly/bi-weekly gas station stop)? The majority of Americans have a 40 mile round trip commute. There are users who drive 250-300+ miles/day, but they are an edge case (EDIT: but will eventually be served as battery production scales up; note the estimated 600 mile range of the Tesla Roadster 2.0)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Are you taking into account the time savings of only needing to charge on a trip a few times a year Yes, that's why I said that cars optimized for different roles are likely to survive in the market rather than only one surviving.
- WorldMaker 9y ago> The practical range of an electric car isn't great. There's no foreseeable story for a <5 minute charge. The range of electric cars already meets the weekly average car usage (most people drive ~230 miles in an average week). You don't need <5 minute charge if you only need to charge once per week. Yes, long trips are a thing, but they are exception, not the rule. Even if they weren't an exception, ~230 miles is nearly four hours of non-stop driving. A ~30 minute break every four hours isn't going to kill anyone, and may even save lives in reduced road rage alone. > (Compared to fuel cells) Banks of batteries are dangerous in a crash. Compared to banks of batteries, gasoline is dangerous in a crash (by a huge margin). Also, while the fuel cells themselves are safer, you still have a risk of hydrogen explosions carting around a hydrogen tank, or refueling at hydrogen stations. Batteries at this point aren't so much more prone to explosion when charging by comparison.