14 ms·
Autistic Prodigies Since “Rain Man”
- sillysaurus3 9y ago[Removed. Sorry, I meant to post this comment in the SpaceX thread.]
- cavanasm 9y agoIt looks like you meant to post this in the thread about SpaceX claiming their rocket worked great.
- msla 9y agoNot a nitpick, just as a point of interest: The man Raymond Babbitt was based off of in Rain Man wasn't autistic: His name was Kim Peek, and he had FG syndrome, which causes a constellation of physical effects including agenesis of the corpus callosum. He was, in fact, quite an amazing man, and a savant, with an amazing memory and a gift for speed-reading out of each eye separately, one for each page. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Peek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kim_Peek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FG_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FG_syndrome Anyway, very good article.
- turingcompeteme 9y agoIt's nice that "Autistic Prodigies" are gaining more attention, and that some of that attention is starting to focus more on the problems these kids face instead of just their abilities. My significant other works in a classroom of kids who are on the spectrum. One of her boys, 6 years old I believe, has the entire transit map (all routes, stop numbers, and stop times) memorized for one of the largest cities in the world. When you meet him he asks what bus or train you take, and then he recites back to you every single stop number on the route and the next 10 arrival times at each stop. It's awe inspiring. But that's on a good day for him. On a bad day he just sits and pretends he is a transit driver, going through the routes in his mind, for 10 or 12 hours at a time. Any type of interruption results in loss of control and mayhem. There is a huge amount of work to do in this area still. Most of these kids with incredible abilities are not receiving the help and support they need in order to ever be in a position where they can join society and use them for good.
- wst_ 9y agoIndeed, it's nice. And yet I can't stop wondering why no one ever write articles about much larger group of autistic people whom fate is much worse, IMHO. I am talking about the kids, but most importantly about adults, who are almost normal, to the point that you wouldn't notice in most cases, unless they do something strange occasionally (HFA, mild Asperger's, mild autism.) About all these creeps, weirdos, nerds and morons without friends, very often in deep depression, sometimes suicidal. Bullied in childhood and very often having good job and being an experts in what they do. Lonely experts usually - creep once, creep forever, you know. These people require attention, too. Attention and social recognition. And so often you can read only about baby cases and savants.
- Nav_Panel 9y ago> And yet I can't stop wondering why no one ever write articles about much larger group of autistic people whom fate is much worse, IMHO Second half of this first: > autistic people whom fate is much worse, IMHO It's astounding to me that you find "creeps, weirdos, nerds and morons without friends" to be a worse fate than "On a bad day he just sits and pretends he is a transit driver, going through the routes in his mind, for 10 or 12 hours at a time". I'm one of those miserable "bullied in childhood" types and I'm still thankful that I'm able to participate in society and pursue my interests. A severely disabled person will never be able to do this. I can think up ethical frameworks that'd result in the judgment that social misfits have it worse than extremely disabled individuals, but they'd be tough to justify on various levels. > no one ever write articles [about nerds] They do, if you know where to look[1][2]... but they're unpopular, for various reasons (cultural zeitgeists, also consider the nature of popularity/zeitgeists and how a "nerd" might fit into that). 1: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2091#comment-326664 https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2091#comment-326664 2: http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/01/01/untitled/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/01/01/untitled/
- Will_Parker 9y ago> It's astounding to me that you find "creeps, weirdos, nerds and morons without friends" to be a worse fate than "On a bad day he just sits and pretends he is a transit driver, going through the routes in his mind, for 10 or 12 hours at a time". On a bad day I spend 10 or 12 hours at a time watching gaming streams on Twitch, I'm not sure it's so fundamentally different. (I'm high functioning enough to succeed in my career and fake it in social situations, but not enough to attract a mate.)
- hunta2097 9y agoMy son has (pretty severe) autism, he can tell you the day of the week for a date... pretty much any date going back to the fifties. We (and his teachers) can't work out how he does it. I think at some point he's sat in front of a PC calendar and memorised it!
- mrdmnd 9y agoHe may just be quick at executing the Doomsday algorithm - neurotypical here, but I enjoyed learning this trick, and you can too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_rule
- corpMaverick 9y agoBut, did he come up with the algorithm himself? That sounds as impressive. I wonder if you can do that with a ML supervised neural net.
- nicoburns 9y agoIt wouldn't surprise me. I'm probably somewhere on the autistic spectrum, and I frequently surprised people with my ability to do some tasks as a child. (equally there were some that I was expected to be able to do that I wasn't very good at).
- hunta2097 9y agoI've tried to get to explain to me how he does it, he can't. He can also recite the US and UK release dates for most kids films (he learns them from Wikipedia)... and then he can subsequently tell you the day of the week!! Most of his tricks are based on his amazing memory, he recites long sections from film and TV shows years after watching them.
- pas 9y ago> I've tried to get to explain to me how he does it, he can't. That doesn't mean his brain haven't developed the same algorithm for it. The brain is exceptional at noticing patterns. Some people's brains are very preoccupied with numbers, and abstract data. (Some people like spotting license plates, some can't even look away.)
- o098310o 9y agoI don't want to comment on the article directly, but be cautious when Treffert is cited. One of his books mentions that 10% of autistic savants have ESP and that reincarnation might account for another savant's abilities. Savant research is not done well, and the media tends to amplify whatever comes from cited experts. For a sample, read the article below, including the sidebar. https://www.khaleejtimes.com/business/mind-reading-sharjah-girl-exceedingly-rare-savant https://www.khaleejtimes.com/business/mind-reading-sharjah-g...
- oaxacaoaxaca 9y agoThank you for sharing this. With a 3yo son on the spectrum, many points here resonated with me. It was nice to see at least one other family doing Floortime--we're thrilled with the results we're seeing and are just surprised how little popularity the program has.