4 ms·
I found, over the years of being on HN, that there's a sort of forceful response that always comes to these types of comments about depression, along with downv
by EGreg 9y ago
I found, over the years of being on HN, that there's a sort of forceful response that always comes to these types of comments about depression, along with downvoting. The responses say basically,
"Don't talk about what you don't know. Many people have real, chemical depression, and your comment that it's a product of life circumstances is not helpful".
I was always a but puzzled about the regularity with which that above formula appeared on HN. Sure, many entrepreneurs and especially developers lead lonely, stressful lives. I am a developer and entrepreneur myself!
But I also felt there is a sort of "groupthink" or "bullying" element to this, because there was hardly much substantive discussion about facts or statistics or science, in effect it was shaming the commenter into shutting up.
This bothers me. I like to see real fact based discussion when there is disagreement. Not just downvoting and vague assertions.
In this case I am sure you were downvoted by that exact same sentiment. Even if you had summarized the article, the content of the summary was enough to trigger the downvote.
- foobarbecue 9y agoOddly, it was upvoted twice /and/ flagged. I guess anyone with enough reputation can bury things just by hitting a "flag" button.
- greenyoda 9y agoIt could have been flagged multiple times (flags are additive). Even articles that have hundreds of upvotes can be killed by flagging if enough people flag them.
- foobarbecue 9y agoIs flagging the same thing as clicking the [-] button? Is this explained somewhere? My flagged comment has +2 points, and my unflagged version of it has -2 points. Very confusing, and if I did something wrong, nobody is telling me what it is. I can't find any documentation for HN, which is a little ironic...
- grzm 9y agoThe [-] collapses your view of the thread. The flag link appears when you have sufficient karma (I don’t recall the threshold). Click on the time stamp for the comment you want to act on. If you have enough karma, the flag link appears between the “parent” and “favorite” links.
- greenyoda 9y agoA couple more points regarding "Don't talk about what you don't know": 1. How would we even know whether the person who posted the comment has no personal experience with depression? They may be agreeing with the author of the article because they've both had long experience with depression, and have both become skeptical about the mainstream views of it. 2. Just because someone has had personal experience with depression does not necessarily make them an authority on that topic. Lots of people on HN express strong opinions about things that they're not personally experienced with: poverty, sexual harassment, etc. (not to mention tons of technical topics). If we stopped talking about everything we have no personal experience with, discussion on HN would dry up pretty quickly.
- rwnspace 9y agoIn my subjective experience, I am much more inclined to respond very negatively to others' discussions on depression, when I am myself depressed. My personal experiences with it are confused by PTSD and ADHD, but I've got a few (too many) years under my belt, and I have hit absolute zero multiple times. The problem with reading online discussions, /I think/, is that it's super easy to end up with a polluted perspective and bipolar esteem/locus of control: everything sucks, catastrophically so, I'm stupid, and it's all entirely my fault; even if it isn't, everyone is stupid & the world has conspired to ruin me. So a description of patterns of thought, of pitfalls hidden as cultural ambitions - patterns socially or environmentally derived - are parsed into "so it's my fault? F___ off -- or it's the fault of society, well I bear that crushing realisation daily, thank you". Our highly individualistic culture poisons perfectly good advice for the people it might benefit, and/or adds to the weight many others can do without. Although "you can change your environment by changing your perception of it" is definitely sound, for so many peoples' valuations it's just another string in the bow of uselessness. There are also, in my experience, two gates that must be open at the same time to allow for slow repair work, or larger positive changes. Unfortunately, they also depend on each other, and when things are truly awful neither are plausible. These are a) a surplus of willpower, no matter how little above the level required to minimally function, and b) a regular sleep pattern. Since depression reduces willpower dramatically, and we are very poor judges of what drains our willpower, the repair process can often feel like Sisyphean whackamole... But eventually, at least for me, I found little willpower exercises I could do every day. At one point, this was quite literally just attempting not to visit my 'stim' websites on first impulse. Eventually I'd still visit them. Didn't matter. That was it. Not even every day. Just every day I could was enough. Until I could do a little more.
- anigbrowl 9y agoProbably because there are many comments along the lines 'it's just life circumstances! Just change those!' without regard for the disabling effects of depression, the difficulty of unilaterally altering said circumstances, or known failures of prior attempts to do so. What's not helpful is to have people with little first hand experience of a situation offer a simplistic causal diagnosis and then treat the problem as solved-by-identification. It's kinda like the conversation where someone is trying to describe a problem with a piece of software or UI trope, and people chime in with unhelpful workarounds rather than addressing the issue itself. substantive discussion about facts or statistics or science Given the subjective nature of consciousness, dismissal of anecdotal responses as counterfactual or invalid is intensely alienating to the depressed subject.