3 ms·
> Emerging industries can't work like this - someone has to do the work before the universities catch up Creating something new and teaching people the current
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> Emerging industries can't work like this - someone has to do the work before the universities catch up
Creating something new and teaching people the current state of the art are two separate things. And universities do both of them.
The things invented in Bell Labs in the 1950s are taught in universities today, but the researchers at Bell Labs had college degrees. It's a feedback loop.
> so how do we quantify e.g. how desperate we truly are for programmers?
Median salary is a very strong quantification, especially accounting for sub-specialization. It's possible we need more DBAs but not more web designers.
> I'm sure there's a middle ground between "the risk of training this person and them leaving is small enough compared to the potential return they'd give us since the field is so ripe" and "nah, we're totally good," but how do we find out where in that space we are?
They just don't benefit from it at all.
Suppose you pay $150,000 to train someone with the expectation that you'll pay them $50,000/year for five years and the training will allow them to do the work of an $80,000/year employee, so you'll break even (ignoring time value of money). Except that once they can do the work of an $80,000/year employee, they can immediately quit and get a job paying $80,000/year and you can't retain them by paying $50,000/year.
The alternative is to loan them the money, so if they leave they still have to pay you back for the training. But now you've just reinvented universities and student loans and companies don't get anything out of doing it in house that they wouldn't from hiring graduates from normal schools who borrow money from normal banks.
Companies know that they aren't any better at being a university than a university is and they aren't any better at being a bank than a bank is, so they don't try to be.