4 ms·
> If it didn't cost a hundred thousand dollars to get sick then it wouldn't be a problem for people to not be insured against it. This is a dicey one. One of t
by majormajor 9y ago
> If it didn't cost a hundred thousand dollars to get sick then it wouldn't be a problem for people to not be insured against it.
This is a dicey one. One of the things that drives treatment costs up is more advanced technology. Should we go back to 70s/80s-era cancer treatments, HIV treatments, surgical outcomes?
We need a lot more national discussion about where the real opportunities to save money are, and what should and shouldn't be covered, and if there's a one-size-fits-all solution or not, because some of the costs will continue to trend upwards as we become more able to keep more people alive for longer (otherwise a good thing!). Some [surgeries, drugs, treatments] cost tens of thousands of dollars and save lives. Some cost tens of thousands of dollars with dubious outcomes. That's where the meat is.
But we have no hope whatsoever of getting there if we can't even agree that mandated health insurance at at least some minimum level is necessary policy. Insurance needs that much to be able to work at all. Or give me the reverse: if you opt out of health insurance when you're healthy, saying the sick can fend for themselves, then you don't ever get to opt back in. (That's not gonna happen, obviously.)
- make3 9y agothere is no legitimate reason the us should be praying at least an order of magnitude more for the same treatments
- majormajor 9y agoI certainly don't like the US having higher prices than elsewhere in the world, but what I would like to see more discussion of there is "where does the funding for the development of the treatments come from" rather than just comparison of absolute cost. I suspect we're subsidizing (especially at the top of the market) a lot of research that the rest of the world is also benefiting from. This isn't necessarily the worst thing in the world, but I would like to see the numbers and, if it is the case, find out why the burden isn't shared more equally? I worry, a bit, that this is an area where other wealthy countries act in somewhat bad faith through their health services, to keep their own costs down while knowing that a corporation will make the deal since it's still greater total income and profit than not selling for full cost overseas. I fear a race to the bottom where new treatments are impractical to pursue much more than I fear a stratified market where new treatments are only available to the rich at first. Look at how totally we've managed to fuck up the incentives for academic research -- I want to tread lightly, in these areas.
- make3 9y agoafaik the pharmaceutical industry is one of the industries with the highest profit margins. I am skeptical of your claims.
- majormajor 9y agohttp://www.bbc.com/news/business-28212223 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28212223 Profits seem pretty healthy, but R&D spending is also quite high. I'd expect a high-research growth industry to have much higher profit margins than mature things like oil and gas or media. Boggles my mind why banking is comparable, though. :| Believe it or not, I'm not making claims. I'm trying to get people to go deeper on the issue sooner, rather than later, since a lot could change around it in the US in the near future. > And it's not just cancer drugs - between April and June this year, drug company Gilead clocked sales of $3.5bn for its latest blockbuster hepatitis C drug Sovaldi. This sort of thing - breakthrough new drug being ridiculously expensive at first - doesn't seem necessarily bad to me, as long as the price comes down over time and the drugs deliver the goods. We just need to make sure we know the numbers to watch to make sure we don't either bankrupt ourselves, or kill the motivation for research (jacking up the prices of old drugs is a scary recent trend I want us to crack down on). Here's the core thing: "the pharmaceutical industry is one of the industries with the highest profit margins" is not a policy suggestion. "Costs are too high" is not a policy suggestion. They suggest a few possible things - price controls, or higher taxes, come to mind immediately, but don't do anything beyond that. The US is in dire need of useful policy suggestions (even "medicare for all" is pretty thin, and ignores some disadvantages Medicare has compared to a lot of people's current private coverage), and in even more dire need of people who talk about things with more nuance than "socialize it all!" or "individual liberty is the most important thing!"
- hfourm 9y agoHere is more nuance for you: A) Americans need to be more health centric. Half the problem is that a minority of chronic patients account for 50% of the costs. Drive through rural America, fast food is the only option. Grocery shopping at Dollar stores and gas stations. Solving Americas obesity epidemic is step one in fixing US healthcare. B) Big pharma regulations. I like the idea of importing drugs and creating more competition. I also think it should be a national embarrassment that we let drug companies advertise to people. Drug decisions should be between doctors and their patients, not patients and the marketing wing of a big pharma company. C) More access to preventative care. Maybe socializing everything healthcare is way too much to ask right now. But, EVERYONE should have access to regular doctor appointments at least for annual checkups. Earlier recognition of problems will greatly cheapen downstream costs if people aren't waiting till they are having a heart attack to seek care. These are just a few pragmatic approaches imo.
- geomark 9y ago"One of the things that drives treatment costs up is more advanced technology." It's not so much the technology as it is the setting in which the technology is deployed. Compare US costs to costs for the same procedures and technology in top medical tourism destinations. Quality of care and outcomes are much better at a fraction of US costs. It's the big morass of stuff around the US health care environment that adds big multiples to the cost of deploying new technology.
- majormajor 9y agoThis is part of where I don't know where to find the numbers I want to find. :) Are one-off procedures amenable to medical-tourism destinations a major part of US total healthcare costs? Or is it expensive, often-for-rest-of-life, prescriptions and treatment courses for certain conditions? Or just the simple requirements of keeping an ever-larger/ever-older aging population alive through falls/heart attacks/kidney failures/whatever? Pointers to the data would be appreciated, here. :) Or numbers around research budgets: what does the international research profile around, say, lab-grown replacement organs look like compared to the in-US one? What I have found so far is that even within the US, quality of care and outcomes vary wildly (doctors and nurses are only human, too, after all) and you can generally figure out where you should go for what condition, but it's not very easy. And it's problematic at a certain point to say that it should be easier: the best 10% of practicioners for a certain condition likely can't see 100% of the patient load. How do you decide who gets the crappy doctors? (International medical tourism is a slightly different can of worms, but one I understand less because my experience is that most health coverage doesn't give you much internationally, so domestic medical tourism seems much more attractive.)
- geomark 9y agoThose are some good questions. And I don't have pointers to data. You can find plenty of anecdotes about one-off procedures/events that are ruinously expensive in the US but are affordable out-of-pocket cost at medical tourism centers. The question of on-going health care costs would normally be of interest only to expats since most medical tourists plan to go back to their home country after treatment. As an expat I have some anecdotes of my on that subject. In short, they also seem to be a fraction of the cost for better care and service. Full time elder care/nursing home care, for example. When my family researched it in the US it was very expensive and mostly quite depressing conditions. We were able to obtain 24-hour care for about US$1,000 per month in Thailand and the care was quite good. An acquaintance mentioned comparative cost of dialysis - about US$10,000 per year at a Thai private hospital versus US$90,000 in the US (assuming you paid the actual cost). One thing that remains expensive is any specialty medicines that must come from big pharma in the west, although there are more options for sources and not the racket that people experience in the US - think of meds from Canada for example.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThe problem is that we keep trying to pretend that it both is and isn't a market. In theory you can actually have a free market for healthcare. You get cancer, there are multiple competing providers of cancer treatment products and you choose one based on effectiveness and price. A better treatment can charge more, but if it's only 5% better and costs a hundred times as much then most people won't use it. Which will bring the price of the best treatment down to something most people can afford. The alternative to that is that the government imposes prices regulations, sets low prices for everything and then funds medical R&D with tax money instead of having high margins for medical procedures. The main problem with that is that the government may not fund the right things in the right amounts, either failing to fund very effective research or wasting money on ineffective research. What we actually have is a bastardized hybrid that doesn't work at all, because when the insurance is paying for it but there are no price regulations, people will always choose the treatment which is 5% more effective but costs a hundred times as much, and then the provider obviously has no incentive to lower the price. So the price of everything gets completely out of control.
- specialist 9y agoI have no idea what you're talking about about. Don't confuse Freedom Markets™ with incentives.
- specialist 9y ago"We need a lot more national discussion about where the real opportunities to save money are..." No. We don't. 1/3 to 1/2 of our health care costs is overhead (blame shifting, profiteering). Compare and contrast is sufficient. We don't even have to compare USA & Canada. We could just compare Medicare to everything else.