4 ms·
> The first number is a good thing. We’re overeducated in the US. Is that even possible? It's not as if we're swimming in demand for unskilled labor at a livin
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> The first number is a good thing. We’re overeducated in the US.
Is that even possible? It's not as if we're swimming in demand for unskilled labor at a living wage.
The underlying problem seems to be that college (along with housing and healthcare) are too expensive and people can't afford them.
- majormajor 9y agoWe do have a lot of relatively unskilled jobs that claim to require 4 year degrees, though. Is college too expensive or is it over-required, or both? Even if it was free, that's a pretty substantial 4 year opportunity cost. The other part, a drop in international students is something different, though. To conclude how damaging that is, we'd need to know how much of the cohort that dropped off would've otherwise stayed in the country, etc.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> We do have a lot of relatively unskilled jobs that claim to require 4 year degrees, though. This comes from misalignment of specialization. We have too many English majors and not enough physicians and engineers, and the English majors can't all find skilled employment. That allows the unskilled employers to require a college degree, because the unemployed English majors will take an unskilled job over nothing, so the availability of degree-holding job seekers allows employers to use a degree as a filter to include only people who have demonstrated the ability to follow instructions and stick with something for multiple years. But that doesn't mean we have too much education, it means we need to educate more people in things that are in higher demand rather than lower demand so they don't end up doing unskilled labor (and depriving actually-unskilled people of that work). So we could do with fewer low-demand graduates, but we want all of them and more to instead become high-demand graduates, which means the cost still matters.
- majormajor 9y agoWe could shift the low-demand graduates to high-demand graduates with somewhat decreased cost, in theory, by simply axing two thirds of the low-demand programs, no? But here's where I run into a problem with this theory: why haven't we already, then? If the demand is that imbalanced, why aren't more companies desperate for labor to the point of training workers themselves despite mismatched (or no!) degrees, or why isn't the big pool of under-employeed workers finding massive benefit to individual re-training that should pay off in spades? Even in the most immediately obvious areas, software, a lot of bootcamps have mixed or dubious outcomes, yet in theory it should be easy to do extremely well with that.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> We could shift the low-demand graduates to high-demand graduates with somewhat decreased cost, in theory, by simply axing two thirds of the low-demand programs, no? By what mechanism would you do this? It's not as if there is a centralized bureau of programs for all universities. In theory you could stop offering student loans to students studying low demand subjects, but we haven't actually done that. > If the demand is that imbalanced, why aren't more companies desperate for labor to the point of training workers themselves despite mismatched (or no!) degrees, or why isn't the big pool of under-employeed workers finding massive benefit to individual re-training that should pay off in spades? The reason employers don't train workers is that it's all risk no reward. If the person drops out without finishing, or worse quits the day after you train them, you lose money. It's easier to just pay high salaries to qualified graduates from normal schools, which is what they do. As to why people don't take on the retraining themselves, part of that is the cost. Which includes the opportunity cost. You not only have to pay tuition, you're spending all day studying instead of working. And that can be a deterrent even if it balances in the long term. If you're making $30K/year now but would make $80K/year with a degree that costs $120K in tuition and another $120K in opportunity cost, you break even within a few years after graduating. But only if you have or can get somebody to loan you $240,000 at a low interest rate. Obviously that becomes more attractive if either the tuition is lower, or there is less opportunity cost because the alternative pays less than $30K/year.
- 9y ago
- forapurpose 9y ago> We have too many English majors and not enough physicians and engineers, and the English majors can't all find skilled employment. Can you back that up? As far as I know, it's a myth about employment; generally, the world is run by liberal arts majors and not by engineers (at least outside SV). Also, as I point out in another post, college is not vocational school; it's far more important: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16089866 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16089866
- jghn 9y agoSome of the best coders I’ve ever met were English majors. I’ve worked with a bunch of MDs with undergrad degrees in things like art history. Sure, this is all anecdata but let’s not pretend a liberal arts degree necessarily dooms one to a life of flipping burgers
- rayiner 9y agoThe underlying problem is that college is the wrong thing. College focuses on capital-E “Education.” Book learning, “big ideas,” and “learning to think.” What we need is training—teaching people the concrete skills they need for a job. That’s true even in majors that are ostensibly directed to producing professionals. Engineering school often focuses too much on producing PhD candidates rather than practicing engineers, law school focuses too much on producing law professors than practicing lawyers, etc. College is a monument built by academia in honor of itself, and for the most part is a giant waste of everyone’s time and money.
- skosch 9y agoI really want to disagree and write a scathing rebuke, but I'm afraid you're right on the money. Still it seems that we haven't beaten it into nearly enough peoples' heads that we all live on the same planet, that resources are finite, and that those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it. What, if not education – of the liberal arts kind – to fix that, and quick?
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> The underlying problem is that college is the wrong thing. That's fair, but it doesn't really lead to "less education is a good thing" as a conclusion. We may need to replace college with something more practical, but that doesn't mean it's fine to have less of it without having more of something in its place.
- thriftwy 9y ago> teaching people the concrete skills they need for a job That will be obsolete in ten years? The whole job, I mean. This wasn't a bad line, but today it did lose its luster.
- forapurpose 9y ago> The underlying problem is that college is the wrong thing. College focuses on capital-E “Education.” Book learning, “big ideas,” and “learning to think.” What we need is training—teaching people the concrete skills they need for a job. Can you back this up? It's a big statement. Even if it's commonplace, I don't think it's well thought through. Education is for far more than jobs: People have to be citizens, community members, parents, individuals, and more - they need to be able to understand and reason critically about the world. I'll note that the world's major problems now are not a lack of software and science, it's a lack of critical thinking about the (mis)information they read, and lack of understanding of politics and public affairs. For example, we know about climate change; the science isn't the obstacle. We've developed Facebook; more technology isn't the need.