4 ms·
I'd say less the recession and more just a particularly-hard-hitting-in-America trend away from the country's historical industrial base. The 20th century US be
by majormajor 9y ago
I'd say less the recession and more just a particularly-hard-hitting-in-America trend away from the country's historical industrial base. The 20th century US benefited massively from being on the front lines of modern industrialization and mass production, creating a ton of jobs especially in certain regions. And in areas that haven't been able to replace those jobs as the US economy becomes based in different areas and other countries take over in mass production, that's been a particularly rough blow.
The sense of hopelessness in a truly fucked town is particularly brutal. Retraining and education sound nice, but aren't going to be all that appealing in practice for a lot of people, even if the money is there. So now the US suffers the hardest from the loss of this industry, the other side of the coin of getting to benefit the most from the growth of it. Add in a historical lack of awareness around the dangers of new painkiller drugs... and you've got the recipe for a disaster without needing any judgmental conclusions about a society as a whole.
Britain, another even-earlier industrial power, has similar things going on in some regions, but I'd argue never saw quite the same peaks as the US.
It will be interesting to see what a more controlled country like China does if/when all those jobs that first drew money to the country fully evaporate.
- forapurpose 9y agoI'd say it's large reductions in government programs, from health to education to food and welfare programs for the poor. I don't have data, but it's hard to believe that such programs have no effect. Also, the U.S. moved on from being an industrial economy decades ago, long before most people realize. In Detroit, for example, auto industry jobs began declining in the 1950s.
- rayiner 9y agoHas there been a net decrease in these programs since 2008? I think the opposite is true.
- existencebox 9y agoI was curious, so I tried to answer this question. Problem being, detangling the cause/effect and interactions of e.g. employment with food stamps isn't immediately obvious to me. To give some of the examples I was looking at: Overall, social security and disability spending per capita, and overall enrollment, is up. (at a very high rate since the 90s, comparatively to prior).[0] However, out of pocket costs and private insurance costs have been increasing at even higher rates [1] To look at food stamps, SNAP participation has been going down rather significantly in recent years.[2] It's an open question as to the relative contributions of increased employment rates vs. changes to eligibility (often via republican states imposing work requirements), let alone normalizing this against the various unemployment/"workforce participation" measures to find the "real rate" of unemployed, un-protected individuals, which has certainly not recovered since the recession [3]; implying that the SNAP cuts may not be from the "good signal" (employment is found) precondition. Something that's not well captured in the above (chosen because they were a few "notable social programs" I could think about off the cuff) and someone more informed than I could likely tell me what the core metric for this would be; but there's an worrying pattern I keep hearing about regarding schools pushing for a four day school week. (here's an analysis showing the motivation of cost cutting, and the unfortunately lacking results [4]) If the implied need to cut costs is _that severe_, for whatever reason (my assumption would be a combination of state funding and taxbase) one can reasonably see this as another eroding facet of state/social support, if not necessarily intentionally. All in all; I get the feeling that while local benefit cuts (and more importantly aspects such as increased out of pocket costs for healthcare) are probably not helping, it's only one aggravating facet along the side of a core deeper systemic trend(s). [0] https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/chartbooks/disability_trends/sect01.html https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/chartbooks/disability_trends... [1] https://www.usnews.com/news/health-care-index/articles/2015/05/07/us-news-health-care-index-shows-massive-increase-in-consumer-costs https://www.usnews.com/news/health-care-index/articles/2015/... [2] http://www.newsweek.com/people-food-stamps-snap-decline-participation-640500 http://www.newsweek.com/people-food-stamps-snap-decline-part... [3] https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 [4] http://www.ecs.org/clearinghouse/93/69/9369.pdf http://www.ecs.org/clearinghouse/93/69/9369.pdf
- forapurpose 9y agoThe GOP has refused to increase spending and has tried to cut it on principle, and in some places has cut it dramatically (e.g., Kansas). Most importantly, the Budget Control Act of 2011 (the "Sequester") was designed to set spending so low that both parties would be forced to compromise on regular-order spending bills in order to fund what was important to them (generally seen as defense for the GOP, domestic welfare programs for the Democrats). Instead, GOP spending hawks refused to compromise and spending has been locked at an insanely low level since then. That includes a lack of funding that is crippling even the supposed GOP priority, the military.
- jdavis703 9y agoHow is the military being crippled? What non-civilian military programs need more funding and why?
- forapurpose 9y ago> How is the military being crippled? What non-civilian military programs need more funding and why? Speaking generally: Readiness is very low; large amounts of equipment is out of service do to lack of parts, and training is severely cut back, meaning the personnel are not ready to perform their jobs - a major issue when they may die and national security may be harmed; AFAIK training is what has long given the U.S. military its edge. There are not enough personnel, forcing the current ones to work exceptionally long and hard, which is also affecting morale. One recent example are the collisions of navy ships in the Pacific; basic navigation and seamanship training was cut for the officers, they were constantly deployed and exhausted, and they worked 100+ hour weeks. Here's a recent article I saw from a respected defense publication: https://breakingdefense.com/2018/01/2018-forecast-can-the-navy-say-no/ https://breakingdefense.com/2018/01/2018-forecast-can-the-na... Also, the military cannot afford weapons programs it needs to compete with 'near-peer' threats such as China and Russia. Generals/Admirals and Secretaries of Defense, for multiple administrations, have been warning Congress for years that they are unable to fulfill their missions with current funding. That's all off the top of my head; there certainly are more problems I'm not thinking of. Also, I don't understand what you mean by "non-civilian" programs. If you want to keep up on these issues, I'd try these publications; budget is only one issue they cover, but they cover it well and seriously, without much political spin: https://www.defenseone.com/ https://www.defenseone.com/ https://breakingdefense.com/ https://breakingdefense.com/ https://www.defensenews.com/ https://www.defensenews.com/
- rsync 9y ago"I'd say it's large reductions in government programs, from health to education to food and welfare programs for the poor. I don't have data, but it's hard to believe that such programs have no effect." I disagree. I think the population we are discussing has not historically been heavy users of social benefits (although more than they usually know) and it is the change in status to being a potential user of such benefits that causes their desperation. As someone who grew up in an impoverished, semi-rural community, it is my observation that everyone had a life narrative that explained how they "weren't just poor people". It's a big, big blow when it becomes impossible to maintain that narrative.
- ddxxdd 9y agoI'll be more inclined to listen to diatribes about the inevitability of America's economic decline when we no longer have the highest corporate tax rates in the world. Until then, I firmly place the blame of America's economic woes on one political party. Hint: it's the party of higher taxes.
- majormajor 9y agoHuh? America can be economically ascendant - we have a LOT of businesses doing quite well with massive profits and cash holdings, tax rates completely aside - without being dominant in every single industry. Regional drug addiction trends are NOT national economic issues (the national economy has been going up at the same time as the opiod abuse!), but plainly regional ones. What specific parts of the opiod issue do you think a lower corporate tax rate will fix?
- myaso 9y agoThe thing that I don't get about this opioid crisis is I keep hearing about it but I have never really seen the corresponding human misery being captured in photography or film -- I see and hear words but I can't gauge the magnitude of the problem. Is this mainly prescription opiates? That's an issue with with the ethics of medical professionals more than anything else -- if you have a low threshold to prescribe this shit what the hell bdo you expect? Update: found a nice heat map from NY Times; still the issue is there are no absolute numbers or the table that shows how the color gradient in the heat map progresses -- I get tall tales of year over year percentage increases but no absolute numbers to reference against. Is it really that hard to make a decent chart/graphic for this for a org like NYT?
- majormajor 9y agohttps://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/10/30/faces-of-an-epidemic https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/10/30/faces-of-an-ep... will give you some human form Prescription opiates that lead to street drugs like heroin or illicitly-sourced ones after the prescription runs out, is my understanding. I don't know how the numbers break down in terms of initial exposure - how many bored desparate people were seeking a release, how many people got injured and then got hooked, etc...? But when we end up talking about drugs designed for 2,000lb elephants, it doesn't seem purely a problem of doctors/pharmacists, people are getting it from some unofficial sources.