4 ms·
Maybe I'm weirdly old fashioned, but I try to stick to ascii whenever possible - which means whatever character is stuck in the middle of this sentence. Ditto f
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
Maybe I'm weirdly old fashioned, but I try to stick to ascii whenever possible - which means whatever character is stuck in the middle of this sentence. Ditto for the ellipsis, since it's not like three trailing periods at the end of a sentence can be mistaken for anything else...
- pvg 9y agoI think you're just like most everyone else - and it's not really about ASCII. There's only one easily accessible dash on the keyboard. The distinction between hyphens, en- and em- (is there a better indication of the level of minutia involved than the fact the latter two not only look nearly the same but are also pronounced almost identically?) dashes is important for typesetters and typography enthusiasts. Everyone (statistically) else just smacks the thing near the top right of their keyboard and it's fine.
- mikeklaas 9y agoYou might consider using two hyphens if you can't bear to use the unicode character.
- 0xffff2 9y agoI think that makes you decidedly new-fashioned. Typesetting has been done much longer than ASCII has existed after all.
- smacktoward 9y agoWhy? Unicode is (nearly) everywhere these days and offers so much more expressiveness, why stick to ASCII?
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> offers so much more expressiveness I don't know the difference between em-dash and en-dash. But I'd also wager that you don't stumble and come to a grinding halt when you see a - in the middle of a sentence, like a robot trying to parse words as arithmetic. I've never, ever once had anyone complain to me that my meaning was unclear when using a - or ' in an email, but I've seen encodings get jumbled. There's no gain for me to not stick to ascii in 99% of cases.
- pacaro 9y agoThis is a great example of how limiting ASCII is. It doesn’t even contain the full set of punctuation that correct (!) English requires. It supposes that you are satisfied using ' for both ‘ and ’, and " for both “ and ”, and eliminates all the dashes for the hyphen—which has to play double duty as a minus sign. It also eliminate dieresis from the language, naive not naïve, and strips all accents from loan words
- dredmorbius 9y agoQuestion is: how much charactersetting is enough, and how much is too much? I've been kicking around thoughts on Unicode and various codepoints, and which really ought or ought not be used. It is decidedly complex. I've got in mind a simplified coding, though, for common interchange formats. Effectively a glyphic pidgen. Presuming "glyphic" is a word. (1913 Webster says it is. Hurrah!)
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> correct (!) English Ah, a prescriptivist!
- niftich 9y agoI use an old convention for approximating em dashes in ASCII by using two hyphens, set apart from surrounding words by spaces. Typographers might shudder, but I find the meaning clear -- its presence signifies the same sort of rhetorical devices that the article talks about. The surrounding spaces serve to make the deliberateness of the punctuation more obvious. In many rich text generators, an em dash is often made with three hyphens, but for as-is plain text, I find three hyphens excessive. In my opinion, most of the usage of the en dash -- the rival, shorter dash -- occurs in situations where you wish to connect, rather than set apart, so while typing in ASCII for the things you'd use an en dash for, a single unspaced hyphen suffices.