5 ms·
That plan causes a whole set of other problems when actually executed. First off, two big factors in the price of an apartment are location and amenities of th
by slg 9y ago
That plan causes a whole set of other problems when actually executed. First off, two big factors in the price of an apartment are location and amenities of the building. So you can't really build affordable and luxury units in the same building. What you end up with is luxury units and subsidized units. That is certainly a category of "affordable", but the result is a bunch of people will get angry sharing their building with other residents who are paying a fraction of the price for basically the same apartments.
Also not everyone who needs affordable housing is a working class family that is trying to pull themselves up by their bootstraps. You can get a lot of "less desirable" residents like current and recovering addicts or people with mental illnesses. They obviously deserve affordable housing, but you will find that plenty of people who buy luxury apartments don't want to share the elevator with them.
You can just check the Yelp reviews of any building that has a mix of luxury and subsidized housing to see examples of these issues. Buildings like this always attract bad reviews, suffer from high turnover, and therefore have low occupancy rates among their luxury units.
- pas 9y ago> a whole set of other problems when actually executed And those are at least as worthy of direct attention and some solution. If someone cannot handle themselves, maybe they shouldn't be given a subsidized unit in a fancy expensive city, but maybe society should help them by maximizing the help they get, and that is probably somewhere where simply being costs almost nothing, and where employing caretakers wouldn't cost two arms and a leg per hour, and so on. (And of course this doesn't mean ship all the addicts to Alaska/Wyoming.)
- Clubber 9y ago>If someone cannot handle themselves, maybe they shouldn't be given a subsidized unit in a fancy expensive city If you think about it in another angle, the governments aren't subsidizing to help the tenants as much as they are subsidizing the companies that have to hire people at not executive or programmer wages. I mean you might get a few people who are willing to commute 4 hours a day, but certainly not enough to satisfy SV's needs. I doubt a company would pay their janitorial staff enough to live there without being forced.
- pas 9y agoYou probably misunderstood my comment. I think buildings with both subsidized and market rate units are a great idea. (Segregated subsidized buildings seem to be strictly worse.) But as others mentioned subsidized can mean either "low wage normal folks" or "hardcore bath salts addics living on tree bark with 10 dogs and sold the bathtube for drugs years ago, so they smell worse than their dogs". And they need different kind of help. The former can probably be perfectly happy with their current job thanks to the rent subsidy, whereas the latter category is very likely actively harmful to the community and needs serious (expensive) intervention. Of course we can debate the problem of injecting even more money into a market with already limited supply, and its fairness.
- bostonscott 9y ago"I mean you might get a few people who are willing to commute 4 hours a day, but certainly not enough to satisfy SV's needs. I doubt a company would pay their janitorial staff enough to live there without being forced." Of course they would if they had to --- supply and demand. Do you really think companies would not find a way to solve the "my office is a pig sty" problem?
- Clubber 9y agoPaying living wages for that area is probably the last thing they would consider, after all else failed, including petitioning government.
- linkregister 9y agoIsn’t the minimum wage in SF $15/hr? Even if it were $100/hr that still doesn’t mean the housing supply would be adequate for the demand. The only short-term solution that would give sufficient housing supply to the Bay Area would be a massive loss of jobs.
- Clubber 9y agoOr smart relocation. Does the marketing department really need to be in the same building as the accounting department, etc? Either way, SF is having the issue they are having because SV had the exact same problem 20 years ago. Everyone knew this was going to happen.
- theoh 9y ago> If someone cannot handle themselves, maybe they shouldn't be given a subsidized unit in a fancy expensive city You need to solve the problem with your plan where the person who gets labelled "cannot handle themselves" is diverted into an isolated setting with much less stimulation/opportunity. You did say you weren't proposing to "ship" "addicts" to Alaska/Wyoming but there's a much higher level of responsibility than that -- you mustn't write them off / throw them on the scrap heap / set them up for an isolated dependent life by your own standards. It could be you one day.
- 35bge57dtjku 9y ago> you mustn't write them off... It could be you one day. It's a little discomforting how few people seem to care about that.
- tristor 9y ago> “It could be you one day.” Why? Barring someone forcibly injecting me with opiates repeatedly or the same with crack, it is beyond unlikely I will ever become addicted to either substance. I don’t think addicts are “bad people”, but once they’ve hit a certain point their physical desire for drugs overwhelms their ability to be present in polite society. People should be treated with respect and humanity, but they also should not be given a free pass to do anything without consequence. If you’re shitting in the elevator or passing out with a needle in your arm in the restroom in the building it presents a clear problem with the plan of mixing luxury housing with subsidized housing. I will never be in that situation because I won’t allow myself to be in that situation. I might become poor, I might need to rely on subsidized housing, but I will never be “someone who can not handle themselves” as the GP referenced. I get that you’re trying to evoke empathy, but there’s a sea of difference in behavior and capability of accepting social norms between your average mentally ill substance abuser and your average poorer person who can’t afford housing. These situations are not the same and there does need to be a filter to ensure that the working poor do get affordable housing without reducing them to having to live alongside “people who can’t handle themselves”. It’s not a nice thing to realize, but it’s the hard truth. We, if anything, should start providing state run mental facilities for long-term patients again. There are a lot of people who through circumstance or birth simply are not capable of coexisting with polite society.
- Retric 9y agoYou could have separate entries for each part of the building and not share amenities, but this gets back to the central idea. If you allow people to segregate by price then they will do so. If every building in a city must have some affordable units then the city as a whole is better off, but it's going to feel less exclusive. I can see both sides of the argument, but we need to figure out how to build cities that work or we are in for a lot of chaos.
- boulos 9y agoSeparate entries are often done, but rightly referred to as "the poor door". I don't think there's much sense in half measures to do affordable housing: making a building that is effectively segregated is less efficient and sensible than the current San Francisco "just pay us" system.
- Nomentatus 9y agoBut the poor want half measures a great deal more than they want none. Sometimes a door is just a door, and ya don't need access to the swimming pool, just to your job.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nsnick 9y agoThis was tried in New York. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2015/06/30/nyc-bans-poor-doors-separate-entrances-for-low-income-tenants/?utm_term=.586fed3d9ec2 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2015/06/3...
- Nomentatus 9y agoAnd from that article... "It’s also worth noting that, even before future poor doors in New York were banned, 40 Riverside Blvd. had 88,000 applications for 55 low-income units."