2 ms·
> They could also buy any number of things around the world with US dollars earned from selling us stuff. Yes, I said this ("dollar-denominated assets"). > Ch
by cryptonector 9y ago
> They could also buy any number of things around the world with US dollars earned from selling us stuff.
Yes, I said this ("dollar-denominated assets").
> China could just as easily export oil to any country inn the world in exchange for us dollars.
Let's think this through (ignoring the fact that China is a net importer of oil, so they wouldn't export any oil). China sells stuff to Europe for dollars. Whence those dollars? Europe probably had treasuries, sold them, and paid China... except that actually they'd just transfer the treasuries -- why pay extra fees? Whence those treasuries? Well, Europe sold... stuff for dollars and so on.
(Actually, Europe borrows in euros, so euros too are a reserve currency, but let's ignore this. So it's not right for me to use Europe in the example above, but let's pretend for the argument's sake.)
Few things in economics are zero-sum games, but one thing that is a zero-sum game is international trade. If China maintains a trade surplus with the rest of the world, then the rest of the world maintains a trade deficit in the same amount. The U.S. dollar is a reserve currency because there is nothing else now to use as gold used to be used, and the rest of the world insists on maintaining a trade surplus with the U.S., which means they... have to accumulate dollars or dollar-denominated assets.
Because of this, the rest of the world can also trade with each other in treasuries, and so you're absolutely right about that. But new lending of dollars to the U.S. most likely stems from exports to the U.S. Certainly that would be true for any sufficiently large sums: the creditor could not accumulate such sums without exporting to the U.S.
So I stand by the assertion that for China to lend $1trn to the U.S. means to export a similar amount to the U.S. as well.
- phkahler 9y ago>> So I stand by the assertion that for China to lend $1trn to the U.S. means to export a similar amount to the U.S. as well. OK, if I accept that then I'm left with the idea that it's a really bad policy. The stuff we bought from China has a useful lifetime (food gets eaten, products wear out), but the money we owe them does not - barring inflation of course.