4 ms·
I had giardiasis once, because I drank water straight from a stream. Clearest water I've ever seen outside Yellowstone's hot pools, and it tasted great! A few h
by throwanem 9y ago
I had giardiasis once, because I drank water straight from a stream. Clearest water I've ever seen outside Yellowstone's hot pools, and it tasted great! A few hours later, my entire digestive tract was doing its level best to turn inside out. It's a hell of a thing - at first you feel like you're dying, and then after a while you realize you aren't but start wishing you would.
I really can't recommend it! At least boil the stuff first. Or would that evaporate the magic, too?
- Alex3917 9y agoDrinking untreated water from a stream is idiotic, but that's completely different than drinking well water though, which hundreds of millions of Americans do every year without any negative effects. While most wells do have filters, those are just there to get rid of excess sediments. And you can also get rid of any bacteria with UV light without filtering the water, so I'm not seeing where exactly the danger comes in here.
- djrogers 9y agoThe entire point of ‘raw water’ is that it’s unfiltered and untreated (no UV) and from a spring. I think you may have missed a few details from the article.
- blfr 9y agoIsn't spring just a naturally occurring well? Honest question, I have lived in a city my whole life and I would have boiled or at least purified water from either. OTOH, I drink unpasteurized milk so can't judge.
- wand3r 9y agoI have a well. I am not an authority on them but growing up having one I know it is treated. Our water is "hard" so it goes through a softener which requires a massive amount of salt. There are numerous filters in the basement as well. It isn't pumped from the ground directly to the tap and the system maintainers come and test it periodically when they do maintenance
- flogic 9y agoThat's some wells. When I was growing up, my parents' well was pretty much untreated. The water was a acidic so that first morning drink of water tasted of copper. I suspect most of the safety came from arranging the conditions so the water would be safe by default. There is a minimum depth for the well and it needs to be a certain distance from the septic system.
- ghaff 9y agoPretty much. A spring does imply water coming to the surface naturally. However, in practice, a large bottler is probably pumping water from an underground aquifer in any case. In my experience, people don't routinely treat well water before drinking it.
- ghaff 9y agoI don't know the details of this particular "spring" but generally speaking there's not necessarily anything especially dangerous about water pumped from an underground water source. As the parent noted, it's really no different from the well water that many many people routinely drink without any treatment. Yes, this is a silly trend and I wouldn't personally be inclined to drink untreated water that's gone through unknown to me processing and packaging procedures. But water doesn't inherently need to be treated to be drunk regardless of its source.
- Alex3917 9y ago> The entire point of ‘raw water’ is that it’s unfiltered and untreated Applying UV light wouldn't make the water non-raw, since it's not heated above 104 degrees or whatever raw food people believe is the magic number.
- djrogers 9y agoApplying the UV alight would kill the ‘good’ bacteria and organisms the living water fans are so interested in ingesting.
- throwanem 9y agoTo a decent first approximation, an aquifer is nature's Brita.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rohit2412 9y agoI think the whole concept of "live" water are the "friendly" bacteria. So yeah, boiling kills them
- theptip 9y agoBoiling would probably disrupt the homeopathic memory of the water molecules, causing the water to forget the pristine spring from which it was drawn. </s>
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- namdnay 9y agoIf the spring is safe, there are no risks (kind of tautological, I know). Millions of people drink mineral water (Evian, Volvic, etc) and that's not treated. All you need is quality control.
- throwanem 9y agoI confide Evian's bottlers are very assiduous about ensuring their products contain few or no potentially pathogenic microorganisms. Of Silicon Valley randos I'm not so sure. Perhaps I do them a disservice. It would be very interesting, either way, to see what a pathology lab might find to culture from a bottle of their finest.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]