5 ms·
Well, shit. I've had one of these as a stand-in for hopefully eventually getting a Synology NAS, and now I'm paranoid about continuing to use my WD MyCloud. The
by jchw 9y ago
Well, shit. I've had one of these as a stand-in for hopefully eventually getting a Synology NAS, and now I'm paranoid about continuing to use my WD MyCloud. The thing is, I do believe I have a lot of reasons to believe I can trust Synology more, I don't even want to trust anyone. Not Intel or AMD, not WD or Synology. Computers are quickly becoming a source of implicit distrust for me.
- ronnier 9y agoI just build my own with Unraid and I love it. https://lime-technology.com/ https://lime-technology.com/
- mey 9y agoI'm having modest success using an eSATA enclosure on Windows with Storage Spaces. On the Linux side, BTRFS may be suitable but harder to manage (This is part of what Synology/NetGear are providing management around.)
- paulie_a 9y agoIn my experience btrfs is not suitable for anything.
- jchw 9y agoUnfortunately, I've learned this the hard way. Twice. I'm sure it's more stable now than it was when I used it last, but it's frustrating when people say "no, this time it's really stable!" and then you lose data due to a bug. This same thing has never happened to me with ZFS on Linux, which is a shame because the licensing issues make it painful for me to use. I like up to date kernels. I feel like btrfs should be phased out. It was clearly developed in a fashion that did nothing to prevent preventable bugs. This may be the same frustration that's leading RedHat to work on their own competing filesystem...
- mey 9y agoAny suggestions for a dynamically grow-able/shrinkable system of mixed drives for linux? When I last looked (and why I went with Storage Spaces) was that ZFS requires pools to be fixed at initialization, and I wasn't sure what other OSS solutions were mature at the time.
- paulie_a 9y agoI have no suggestions honestly, I have looked into it pretty extensively and would like to go ZFS. But it will cost a decent amount for the setup I am looking for. It seems to be "all or nothing"
- 1over137 9y agoMaybe you'd like FreeNAS.
- vasili111 9y agoYes, you have a choice between using CPU with Meltdown/Spectre bugs or with only Spectre bug. Spectre is not fixed yet.
- beagle3 9y agoSpectre is a non-issue on a home NAS.
- ancarda 9y agoI understand what you’re trying to say, but what's the alternative? Stop using computers? Once Meltdown and Spectre are out of the picture, there will be another crisis. That’ll happen forever, I think. Honestly, the older I get, the more sick of IT I become, but what can we do about this? Im in the market for a NAS right now, so this is perfect timing. I’m more willing to trust FreeNAS than MyCloud but as soon as I write that, I remember lots of Open Source is crap too.
- vasili111 9y agoI am not saying that people should throw out computers and live in caves. I am just describing a current situation which makes me sad.
- ancarda 9y agoOh, I agree with you; the state of computer security is really depressing :(
- nickik 9y agoI highly recommned this: https://www.ixsystems.com/freenas-mini/ https://www.ixsystems.com/freenas-mini/ You get FreeNas on good hardware by people who know what they are doing. I have been running this for years and I have no complaints exept that the 8 slot variant did not exists when I bought mine.
- milofeynman 9y agoIf you don't want to trust anyone go with FreeNAS and build it yourself. It's great, better hardware for cheaper. Just the higher learning curve...
- vasili111 9y agoYou can not build something serious today with CPU that does not have Spectre bug/backdoor.
- tjoff 9y agoNot cheaper though, ECC ram is recommended and chances are your old discarded PC does not have ECC ram.
- oarsinsync 9y agoIf you're upgrading the overall specs, it's going to be more expensive, yep. If you're trying to provide equivalent functionality, you can keep the same equivalent specs (or more likely, get a spec upgrade anyway) and deliver the same quality end result (IE, no ECC RAM) at a lower cost. You're unlikely to suffer a performance or integrity penalty compared to the equivalent off-the-shelf NAS solution. If you want to substantially improve on the off-the-shelf NAS solution, ECC RAM is recommended, and will at that point, probably become more expensive. Then again, if you want 10+ drives, you'll probably still be cheaper doing it yourself.
- tjoff 9y agoYou need to upgrade the specs because ZFS is much more demanding than a normal linux fs that I assume most COTS solutions use (the absolute minimum requirements for freenas is 8 GB of ram, I would guess most of the shelf solutions have no more than 2 GB). The CPUs used in COTS solutions also wouldn't cut it in a freenas system. The big death blow however is the inability to grow a vdev which means you have to pay the for redundancy each time you upgrade. Which isn't cost effective, so the alternative is to buy all drives up front which robs you of taking advantage of falling prices (as you probably don't need all that space on day one but gradually increase the storage used). This forces you to pick smaller drives that are more cost effective today (compared to buying a few larger drives that will become cheaper in the future), which means that you will have to replace the drives sooner when you run out of room in your chassi (or get tired of noise / power consumption). I love freenas, in my opinion it is the best solution for the home NAS. I use it myself, but I do consider it to be quite costly (whether it is worth it is up to you). The end results all things considering is easily more than double that of a COTS solution that you can easily grow or a more regular linux+mdadm setup. And you also need to buy more of that up front rather than spreading it out over the years. But it does depend on what your needs are and how much data you use.
- kogepathic 9y ago> Well, shit. I've had one of these as a stand-in for hopefully eventually getting a Synology NAS, and now I'm paranoid about continuing to use my WD MyCloud. The hardware is still fine. You can put Debian on it! There is a very active forum of people replacing the WD firmware with Debian on various models (EX2 Ultra, EX2100, EX4100): https://forum.doozan.com/list.php?2 https://forum.doozan.com/list.php?2
- vasili111 9y ago> The hardware is still fine. But if the software is with built-in backdoor there is no reason to trust the hardware.
- mynewtb 9y agoEven if you don't like apples, you might like oranges.
- dmannorreys 9y agoMaybe, but I wouldn't eat them if they came from the same, infested, farm :)
- fulafel 9y agoSadly homebrew Debian variants aren't very safe either. Usually they lack timely OS updates, ship pregenerated ssh host keys in the images, stuff like that. Even Raspbian is pretty bad at this though better than many smaller ones.
- zmix 9y agoAlso: https://community.wd.com/t/clean-os-debian-openmediavault-and-other-firmwares/ https://community.wd.com/t/clean-os-debian-openmediavault-an...
- guiambros 9y agoSynology has its own backdoor as well [1]. Luckily the backdoor is only active when the OS crashed and the device is in recovery mode. They also have some very odd practices, like hard-coding specific users and the shell to be used inside OpenSSH binary [2]. This was 2012; haven't checked if the code improved since then. [1] https://wrgms.com/synologys-secret-telnet-password/ https://wrgms.com/synologys-secret-telnet-password/ [2] https://serverfault.com/questions/458553/cant-log-in-via-ssh-to-any-accounts-using-bin-bash-shell-on-synology-nas https://serverfault.com/questions/458553/cant-log-in-via-ssh...