3 ms·
> I always thought it was possible for a collective resignation of an editorial board but I've never seen it realized. As can be seen in the Elsevier Wikipedia
by FabHK 9y ago
> I always thought it was possible for a collective resignation of an editorial board but I've never seen it realized.
As can be seen in the Elsevier Wikipedia page, it has happened several times (not often enough). The Journal of Algorithms case is instructive [1]. Any individual researcher that "fights" the publisher will lose out, but collectively in a concerted move one can be successful.
I think Don Knuth provided enough credibility to transfer the prestige of the journal, and enough of a towering figure to give everyone the impetus to go ahead with the defection collectively.
It would be very interesting to examine cases where this worked successfully and where it failed (or wasn't attempted) and see what differentiates them. I'm pretty sure Elsevier is examining these cases very carefully...
[1] http://www.cs.colorado.edu/%7Ehal/jalg.html http://www.cs.colorado.edu/%7Ehal/jalg.html