3 ms·
Is eating poop supposed to be the analog of government expenditures? Something that is not really wanted by the market but bought and paid for anyway? Many crit
by hammock 9y ago
Is eating poop supposed to be the analog of government expenditures? Something that is not really wanted by the market but bought and paid for anyway? Many critiques of GDP I've seen lament the fact that (taxes) government spending is included.
*Note to the downvoters, I'm ignoring the more obvious interpretation that three other commenters have already mentioned, that someone actually wanted to watch someone else eat poop. For the sake of interestingness I'm proposing a different meaning.
- tdb7893 9y agoWouldn't not including government expenditures make GDP a worse metric? They are the largest spender in every country and I don't see why it should matter who is buying something for GDP purposes
- hammock 9y agoThe argument typically goes that "because most government services are not sold in markets, they have no market-determined prices to be used in calculating their total value to those who benefit from them." In fact "some government services have negative value: given a choice, the people victimized by these 'services' would be willing to pay to be rid of them." Read more: http://www.independent.org/pdf/tir/tir_18_01_10_higgs.pdf http://www.independent.org/pdf/tir/tir_18_01_10_higgs.pdf
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tdb7893 9y agoWouldn't the value be calculated as whatever the government payed for them just like the rest of GDP? Maybe I'm misunderstanding how government spending is added to GDP but the fact that the amount spent on something doesn't always correlate to the value doesn't seem to be a problem unique to the government and hardly seems a reason to ignore what is in the US up to a few trillion in spending
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]