2 ms·
Right, so in the baker example, there is some value exchanged, checking out the competition. The costs of transactions serve as a check on meaningless loops of
by epistasis 9y ago
Right, so in the baker example, there is some value exchanged, checking out the competition.
The costs of transactions serve as a check on meaningless loops of transaction. And all transactions have a cost; even if it's not monetary it is a time based one.
With the case of parents watching the others' child for the night, now that work has been valued at some amount of money, and presumably the $20 is a better valuation than the $0 that you get for watching your own child. And in this case, the practicality is that since the transaction is under the table, it does not get added to GDP.
So yes, GDP can fail this way, but it's the same type of failure as activities that are not captured by GDP: individuals derive value that doesn't match the economic transfer.
I would posit that these looped transactions represent a tiny fraction of GDP in practice. Whereas the 0-dollar "transactions" where there is value represent a huge amount of potential potential GDP, if that value were put in dollar terms. There are so many examples of 0-dollar value transactions with value, such as the case of family-based childcare, or just good solid friendship, or getting physically assaulted (negative value, 0 dollar exchange). I don't pay others for friendship, but I do pay for opera. I don't pay people to not get physically assaulted. I think these are far stronger and real examples of how GDP is broken. Transaction loops may be a problem in simplified theory of economics, but in practice I can't see them as being anywhere as big of a problem as the non-dollar values that we have.
- brownbat 9y ago> Transaction loops may be a problem in simplified theory of economics I think if you generalize it, it's not the loops per se as the failure to baseline against opportunity cost or counterfactuals, which could have a small impact on the value of almost all transactions. I'm not sure though, will have to think more about it...