4 ms·
(I can't access this article, so I hope people will excuse this comment that is not informed by the article.) That all depends on how much Person A and Person
by epistasis 9y ago
(I can't access this article, so I hope people will excuse this comment that is not informed by the article.)
That all depends on how much Person A and Person B enjoy watching coprophagia performances, doesn't it? If either Person A or B wanted something more with that $20k, they could have gotten that instead.
The $2k I spend at the opera each year doesn't increase "wealth, prosperity, or productivity" from the view of people that don't enjoy opera, but I certainly feel that it increases my prosperity.
The bigger problem with the GDP is it not counting serious economic activity that does not have an exchange of dollars, such as child care in a family. A stay-at-home parent does not get compensated for their work, but that work definitely has value as evidenced by the cost of day care.
- ecshafer 9y agoThe GP example was more to show that a paid b, and b paid a. So despite the transaction neither are wealthier. They have exactly as much as they began with. Replace eat poop with anything.
- bcheung 9y agoI think it also serves to illustrate that there are things that can be paid for that don't increase quality of life. Likewise, if person A and B buy from each other at the same monetary value, but the subjective value of what they "traded" is valued more by the other party, then each party is wealthier despite no change in pure monetary wealth.
- epistasis 9y agoSo let's say A pays B and B pays A for "nothing," i.e. there's no transaction except for the payment of goods, and neither derives any pleasure out of such a transaction. Such transactions would be meaningless, but they also have very little chance of happening in our economy, don't they? Presumably each would pay some sort of tax on this, and if not, the only way that it would be recorded by GDP is if the Persons are business entities that do not make profit, and don't pay sales tax. If such transactions do happen, they must be used in order to exploit tax loopholes, I would suppose? I wonder what percentage of GDP could be attributed to such transactions.
- smallnamespace 9y ago> they also have very little chance of happening in our economy Not if policymakers are judged based on GDP figures, in which case they will have an incentive to encourage these sorts of transactions to happen.
- PeterisP 9y ago"Replace eat poop with anything" is a good point. Let's suppose A pays B $20 to play a song for them. And then B pays A $20 for a haircut. They have exactly as much money as they began with, but it does increase prosperity, they both are better off, they got something useful that they desired, they each received (and also produced) valuable services worth $20; and thus the total prosperity (and also GDP) grew by $40. If watching someone eat poop isn't worth $20k, then they wouldn't pay each other to do so, and the scenario wouldn't happen; but in general the analogy for exchanging services is quite spot on.
- smallnamespace 9y agoI think the danger is that if you then give both A and B an incentive to increase GDP and tell them that the GDP measures wealth, then they will start paying each other $20, then $40, then $100. In and of itself that isn't harmful, but if you conclude from this that you are getting wealthier and wealthier then you might end up lying to yourself and making bad decisions based on this. As a concrete example, women have slowly moved out of the domestic sphere and into the workplace. At the same time, child care and rearing have become booming industries. Both these things increase GDP. But the question is whether all the increase in GDP is real economic value, or whether a significant portion of it is just recording value that used to have $0 attributed to it (e.g. domestic housework, rearing and educating children, home-cooked meals). And a secondary question is whether continuing to push women to work even if they would rather stay at home is the right approach, because if you are a government policymaker, the latter choice will lower your economy's recorded GDP and might make you look bad/incompetent, even if the real value generated by domestic housework is very high. Problems with metrics create problems with incentives, which eventually may lead to skewed or wrong choices.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I think the danger is that if you then give both A and B an incentive to increase GDP and tell them that the GDP measures wealth, then they will start paying each other $20, then $40, then $100. Prior to the headline of this article, I've never seen the idea that GDP measures wealth as opposed to activity anywhere. And I don't think anyone is going to be convinced that spending more money for no stuff and ending up with no more money in the bank at the end of the day is increasing their wealth, no matter what you tell them about GDP. In fact, I suspect the main outcome of what you suggest would be to convince people that you were wrong that GDP is a wealth measure (although people with a strong pre-existing belief that GDP does measure wealth might incorrectly be convinced that you just don't know what GDP means).
- bcheung 9y agoYou bring up a good point. That being, wealth can't be measured in monetary value only. Yet another case where GDP isn't tied to wealth.
- brownbat 9y agoYeah, the more canonical counterexample/paradox about GDP is different... and you hint at it at the end. Imagine I stay at home watching my kids and you stay at home to watch your kids. Nothing is added to GDP. However, what if I pay you $20 to watch my kids for the night, and you pay me $20 to watch your kids for the night? The same amount of work was done, we each up with the same amount of cash as before, but we've somehow added $40 to GDP. (There are no new performance arts events in this case, everything's literally the same as it was before.) You might think at first this is a quirk of child care... but you can run the hypo with other industries. Imagine two bakers on the same street in friendly competition. Each of their families goes through a loaf a week, one from their own production. What if, one day, each baker wants to check out the competition, buys one of the other bakers' loafs? Each family eats the same amount of bread and each baker produces the same amount of loaves. GDP goes up by the full price of the loaves.
- epistasis 9y agoRight, so in the baker example, there is some value exchanged, checking out the competition. The costs of transactions serve as a check on meaningless loops of transaction. And all transactions have a cost; even if it's not monetary it is a time based one. With the case of parents watching the others' child for the night, now that work has been valued at some amount of money, and presumably the $20 is a better valuation than the $0 that you get for watching your own child. And in this case, the practicality is that since the transaction is under the table, it does not get added to GDP. So yes, GDP can fail this way, but it's the same type of failure as activities that are not captured by GDP: individuals derive value that doesn't match the economic transfer. I would posit that these looped transactions represent a tiny fraction of GDP in practice. Whereas the 0-dollar "transactions" where there is value represent a huge amount of potential potential GDP, if that value were put in dollar terms. There are so many examples of 0-dollar value transactions with value, such as the case of family-based childcare, or just good solid friendship, or getting physically assaulted (negative value, 0 dollar exchange). I don't pay others for friendship, but I do pay for opera. I don't pay people to not get physically assaulted. I think these are far stronger and real examples of how GDP is broken. Transaction loops may be a problem in simplified theory of economics, but in practice I can't see them as being anywhere as big of a problem as the non-dollar values that we have.
- stretchwithme 9y agoYou can get to the article using Google: https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=gdp+measure+financial+times&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=gdp+mea...
- wisty 9y agoAs an alternative, maybe Person A spent $20k convincing Person B to pay $20k to eat poop. I believe the polite name for this is the "service economy"?