9 ms·
World Leaders on Twitter
- nathantotten 9y agoTLDR: @realDonaldTrump can post whatever he wants and we won't do anything about it. Also, we claim that he doesn't impact our growth.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aphextron 9y agoWhat a joke.
- PascLeRasc 9y agoIf they'll single out political leaders and give them special protection from being blocked, the leaders should lose their ability to block others. Twitter is admitting that they are a "town hall" here and they need to let everyone speak their mind to their politicians.
- maxerickson 9y agoCelebrities aren't using twitter in a way that they read replies so it only matters in a box checking sort of way.
- kylnew 9y agodoesn't blocking someone on twitter also block others from seeing the replies too? If so, it's a lot more impactful than that
- maxerickson 9y agoThat's a good point, the block stops them from replying altogether (or quote tweeting).
- Grue3 9y agoI think the fundamental property of a block feature should be complete undetectability that the user has been blocked by the user in question. For example Usenet killfile: you never know if you're in somebody's killfile unless they tell you so. Twitter's block function obviously fails this test, which makes it completely useless: once you realize you're blocked, just create another account to continue harassing the user who blocked you.
- maxerickson 9y agoMute does that.
- Grue3 9y agoSo you're saying Twitter already has a block function that actually works? Then it's all the more baffling they also have one that doesn't work, and yet is somehow more well known.
- maxerickson 9y agoThey have 2 different functions with different names that do different things. They call the method of blocking you prefer "mute".
- Grue3 9y agoMy point is that "mute" is strictly better than "block", so there's no reason to have "block" in the first place. Even if somebody likes the misfeature of the blockee knowing they're blocked, you can always tweet "I just muted @theannoyingperson", so that @theannoyingperson knows they're muted.
- connorelsea 9y agoI feel like this effectively makes Twitter an avenue for propaganda dissemination, giving world leaders who frequently blur the line near facism a "no-rules" platform to give out (mis)information. I mean, trump just denied climate change on Twitter and then threatened to bomb a country that has millions of people (aka killing millions of civilians). I can't be the only person who, at the very least, is a little freaked out by trump's presence on Twitter and this announcement
- bmmayer1 9y agoIsn't Twitter much more akin to something like a bulletin board or a printing press? Certainly the platform on which speech is disseminated should be viewed independently from the speaker?
- connorelsea 9y agoTwitter frequently removes and censors users at the request of governments and due to rule breaking, etc. They aren't a bastion of free speech
- tb303 9y agoI don't know why you're getting downvoted and I completely agree. Twitter as a platform continues to give voice to mis-(dis-?)information.
- weirdwitch 9y agoHow do racist slurs and threatening to murder millions of people "advance the global, public conversation"?
- advisedwang 9y agoIt advances the global, public conversation to a racist and war-filled future.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoI feel as if I am missing some background that this blog post is responding to. Can HNers fill in the blanks a little?
- connorelsea 9y agoA large number of twitter users frequently advocate for the removal of donald trump, twitter ignored it until now but basically just officially responded "no"
- ceejayoz 9y agoPeople have been suspended from Twitter and required to delete posts for pretty mild, joking stuff like "we should get rid of men", but Trump has not. @jack has stated a few times that Trump gets exempted from the rules because of the "newsworthiness" of his tweets - this just makes that official. Example: @Popehat got suspended for posting screenshots of someone abusing him: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170803/16341437919/twitter-suspends-popehat-writing-about-violent-threats-he-received-another-twitter-user.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20170803/16341437919/twitt... Example: This guy got suspended for killing a mosquito: http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-trending-41097947 http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-trending-41097947
- nailer 9y agoPopehat got suspended for doxxing. See the screenshot in your link. The person is abusing him, and should also be banned, but doxxing is bad. Mosquito ban sounds like a natural language mistake - only a human would understand the subject he's threatening to kill is the mosquito pictured, and your link confirms Twitter said it was a mistake. Obviously Twitter should enforce rules for sex and racial discrimination. Joking doesn't make those things OK. Trump is a military leader - making threats, like any military and police person, is part of their job. Would you support banning Barack Obama for threatening Assad?
- adrianratnapala 9y agoIf I am reading that right, somone threatened Popehat, and Popehat blogged about the threat. And you are calling that "doxing"???
- jwtadvice 9y agoExcept that they block world leaders (and other globally important actors) as requested by the US security/power community. PR. No thanks.
- lloeki 9y agoIOW not silencing obviously stupid, downright heinous, or otherwise extremely dangerous speech from a certain political leader or three serves as public display of their outrageous opinion, hopefully serving as self-public shaming or something. Honestly I'm still baffled by the situation as a whole (i.e how such despicable people came to be in power and stay in the office), which I feel is kind of unprecedented.
- cgore 9y agoOr, you know, we could actually have freedom of speech for everybody. Crazy talk included, whatever your definition of crazy happens to be.
- uoaei 9y agoTwitter is not a governmental organization (at least, not officially...) and so the question of free speech has no bearing on their operations.
- ac2u 9y agoIt seems that every time someone mentions the dreaded three word phrase "freedom of speech", someone else pipes up with this thoughtless pre-canned response: "It's not government!! It's not government!!" (or that XKCD comic) Has it ever occurred to anyone parroting this that you can discuss the actual concept of freedom of speech outside of the sphere of influence the government has on it?
- AcerbicZero 9y agoIt does seem to have become a bit of a meme, someone says free speech and a line of replies show up with variations of "That only applies to blah blah". It would be nice if instead there was a discussion about the intrinsic value of free speech in society, and how the open marketplace of ideas has a pretty impressive track record.
- 9y ago
- skj 9y agoAre there really people here suggesting that Twitter block the POTUS? Look, he's a madman, but he's also the president. It's not up to Twitter to try and alter the national dialogue.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Are there really people here suggesting that Twitter block the POTUS? There are people seriously suggesting that Donald J. Trump be held to the same standards with regard to content as other Twitter users, rather than Twitter being a biased, pro-Administration propaganda organ. Twitter has clearly decided against that (that's been clear for some time, but now it's official.) > Look, he's a madman, but he's also the president. And that's why reporting about him is valuable and ought to be protected, and it certainly a reason that he has disproportionate power of government tools of communication. It's not a reason for a private entity to grant him preferential liberties in a discussion forum that are not granted to others, particularly his domestic political opponents.
- liquidise 9y agoAllowing accounts of world leaders does not make twitter "a biased, pro-Administration propaganda organ". It makes twitter a place where world leaders are given a generally unfiltered communication tool. This has nothing to do with bias. If anything it is arguably the absence of bias.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Allowing accounts of world leaders does not make twitter "a biased, pro-Administration propaganda organ" Allowing accounts of “world leaders” (so designated by Twitter) does not. Allowing such accounts freedom from content and participation standards that are applied as a bases for restricting or banning other participants, OTOH, does.
- username223 9y ago"Pro-Administration propaganda organ?" Before the election, it was a useful propaganda organ. A decade from now, I think it will be seen as a record of the thoughts of a senile old man who somehow became the leader of a large and powerful nation.
- LeoPanthera 9y agoI could almost understand this if they had a policy of not blocking anyone else who posted similarly hate-filled speech, but they don't. If you're not in the white house you're going to have a bad time. So the policy is, "We don't allow hate speech unless you are extremely famous and well-known and then hate speech is totally fine". Which is, IMHO, total bullshit.
- minimaxir 9y agoIt's worth noting that in this post, Twitter does not explicitly define what a world leader is.
- connorelsea 9y agobecause the whole post is PR speak for "we are going to continue letting donald trump deny climate change and threaten to kill millions of civilians on twitter" under the facade of free-speech protection
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tw1010 9y agoAlso weird that they chose to use the phrase "world leader" instead of president or country leader or something like that. There aren't really that many world leaders around. So Twitter can still prevent the leader of some other country from having their say?
- girvo 9y agoI mean, while I agree that Twitter is mincing words here, “world leader” is a super standard phrase.
- chasing 9y agoTrump using Twitter isn't the problem. In fact, it actually gives us a weirdly detailed bit of oversight into his actions and thoughts (such as they are). I actually think this is helpful when dealing with someone so erratic and uninformed. Everyone in their right mind sees his tweets for what they mostly are: Frustrated bloviations and childish temper-tantrums. The problem is electing someone as President who would use Twitter the way Trump does. We should never have done that in the first place and, thankfully, that's an error We The People can correct. Addendum: I do, though, think that Twitter's response is inadequate. They have a community. Their community is being turned toxic by this man and his ilk. His use of Twitter as President isn't the problem, but Twitter needs to address the effect of people like him on their platform and the world in general. And that way more complicated than just banning a warmonger President. Sadly, I'm not sure Twitter has shown themselves to be up to the challenge.
- ProAm 9y agoTwitter will never ban Trump's tweets because he alone saved the company from coming to an end. Twitter is giving leaders free reign to tweet as they deem fit while everyone else needs to adhere to their code of conduct. It's a bit two-faced but from the perspective of running a business I see why twitter did this.
- chasing 9y agoThe simple fact of the matter is that the President of the United States -- no matter who they are -- occupies a special place in our society. So, yes, Twitter is right to treat him differently than, say, Milo. And, yes: I'm sure this is all very good for Twitter's business...
- connorelsea 9y agoIn Twitter's position, I'd be concerned that my platform would be used for evil in a society where the population is particularly susceptible to propaganda. I wouldn't want to help a modern day Hitler get his message out "on my dollar." Twitter isn't trying to maintain free speech on their platform with this ruling on world leaders, as they have removed and censored plenty of users before at the request of governments or because of rule/TOS violations, etc. They're probably just keeping trump because it puts them in the spotlight and gets them a ton of money, thinking its for "free speech" is extremely idealistic imo
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 9y agoTwitter is here to serve and help advance the global, public conversation. Twitter is there to make money for its shareholders by showing ads to regular users in exchange for cash money. Elected world leaders play a critical role in that conversation because of their outsized impact on our society. World leaders are a cash cow for Twitter, who doesn't give a hoot about how they came to power. I doubt they'd deny an account to a Saudi prince, for example. Blocking a world leader from Twitter or removing their controversial Tweets, would hide important information people should be able to see and debate. It would also not silence that leader, but it would certainly hamper necessary discussion around their words and actions. These two statements are mutually exclusive; if leaders are dependent on Twitter to get information out (they're not) then it ought to be run as a public utility in a truly open fashion. Meanwhile, someone being on or off Twitter would seem to have little impact on other people's ability to discuss their doings on Twitter. But if we're to accept Twitter's stance, then political leaders ought not to be able to delete their tweets, since the purported necessity of seeing and debating them is undermined if they can retroactively edit the record of their own public statements. We review Tweets by leaders within the political context that defines them, and enforce our rules accordingly. Twitter is absolutely not going to mess with anyone who could seize any of staff or assets by force, but would like to retain a shred of dignity. No one person's account drives Twitter’s growth, or influences these decisions. We work hard to remain unbiased with the public interest in mind. Please think of Twitter as a public utility even though it is actually a for-profit business with a PR problem. We are working to make Twitter the best place to see and freely discuss everything that matters. We believe that’s the best way to help our society make progress. NYSE: TWTR has been in a 2 year trough since falling to ~1/3 of its 2014 high and would really like to like to have and eat its cake simultaneously, pretty please.
- l_t 9y agoThanks for this, seems appropriately cutting. The whole situation has put Twitter in a weird place, and I can understand why they don't want to cut Donald off, but it's clear that this post is just "We don't want to", but with a few paragraphs of spin. I wish they would be more honest about it. Personally, I don't think it should be Twitter's responsibility to censor Trump. He has a way of shoehorning himself into public consciousness, and I think the public (especially the mainstream media) needs to self-censor and stop paying him so much attention. I wouldn't care if Donald tweeted whatever he wants, except that it always seems to end up in the news.
- danso 9y agoThis decision to treat public officials as a different class makes sense to me, especially in light of Twitter's (eventual) decision to let Politwoops continue operating despite violating the TOS for API usage: https://www.wired.com/2016/01/twitter-reverses-itself-on-politicians-deleted-tweets/ https://www.wired.com/2016/01/twitter-reverses-itself-on-pol...
- dreta 9y agoThat's a very roundabout way of saying they won't ban Donald Trump because he's keeping Twitter relevant.
- onion2k 9y agoI blocked Trump on Twitter a long time ago for my own sanity. It's understandable that Twitter won't ban him, but that doesn't mean we have to read what he tweets.
- _kst_ 9y ago"Blocking a world leader from Twitter or removing their controversial Tweets, would hide important information people should be able to see and debate." I actually agree with this. "We review Tweets by leaders within the political context that defines them, and enforce our rules accordingly." Certain world leaders have sometimes posted tweets that would likely get anyone else banned. I would prefer Twitter to be more explicit about what they're doing -- namely not enforcing rules against hateful and abusive content when exposing such content is seen a net benefit. If Random Q. Person posts something that's abusive enough to violate Twitter's rules, there's no particular benefit in allowing that content to remain. If Powerful Famous Person posts the same thing, there's arguably substantial benefit in letting it be exposed. On the other hand, applying the same rules to both would also be a valid policy. I merely suggest being a bit clearer about what those rules are and how they're enforced.
- NelsonMinar 9y agoContent aside I wish Twitter could have at least gotten the English grammar correct on their post. Whoever wrote it doesn't know how to use commas.
- aceoflala 9y agoBlocking a user from Twitter or removing their controversial Tweets would hide important information people should be able to see and debate. It would also not silence that user, but it would certainly hamper necessary discussion around their words and actions.
- tb303 9y agoExcept that it's only newsworthy in a recursive way. They give him a platform to break their own rules and be controversial. The simple fact is they want him to be controversial on their platform, not someone else's. This is a dangerous game.
- nanodano 9y agoI think it is hilarious when people argue with Trump on Twitter, because I realize he is 71 years old. He's literally someone's old grandpa on Twitter. How many 71 year olds do you know on Twitter? How many people do you know would argue and talk shit with a 71 year old grandpa on Twitter? I understand he's not just _any_ 71 year old grandpa, but it's so funny to think about it that way.
- imhelpingu 9y agoI'd love to see an example of a tweet he actually deserves to get banned for. Note that "expressing support for Donald Trump" doesn't count.
- tb303 9y agoYou mean like threatening nuclear action against another nation? "Examples of what we do not tolerate includes, but is not limited to behavior that harasses individuals or groups of people with: violent threats; wishes for the physical harm, death, or disease of individuals or groups;"
- nailer 9y agoWould you support banning all police and (non Trump) military from Twitter?
- sschueller 9y agoSo is Twitter going to filter fake news on one end and let world leaders spew their crap on the other? What happens if Donald tweets a nude photo or a member of the Saudi royal family posts a video of a state beheading? Are those going to get deleted?