9 ms·
Can Washington Be Automated?
- moonbug22 9y agoAnother win for Betteridge.
- baxtr 9y agoI’m somehow skeptical whenever I see a CEO holding a pen on a glass wall with random math formulas on it
- noobermin 9y agoEven better, the first two lines are like fundamental laws that illuminate nothing. I'm guessing on the second but it looks like just expanding what looks like a probability using a complete set. Can't really make out the rest of it.
- wildflowero 9y agoYou would be surprised at how useful Einstein's field equations are when deciding how many people to cutoff tomorrow.
- cwzwarich 9y agoEspecially when he's copying them from something on his phone.
- cs702 9y agoEspecially when the first line is a mangled version of Bayes Formula -- the p(y) and p(x) are in the wrong places!
- SubiculumCode 9y agoShould it be automated is the better question.
- randcraw 9y agoAnd should it be transparent? All measure of sins and inefficiencies cannot survive unblinking illumination.
- CM30 9y agoCan it be? Probably. Should it be? Hell no, lobbying is bad enough with humans doing it, let alone algorithms. Hopefully no Silicon Valley startups think this is the next multi billion dollar industry to 'disrupt'.
- thelittleone 9y agoWouldn't those concerns be resolved by being open source? Could run the new automated system in parallel for some years first, like a second umpire in sports.
- landryraccoon 9y agoHow does open source make policy decisions more transparent to the majority of people? Are you assuming that everyone in the country can read and understand the code? I get why programmers and readers of Hacker News could be enchanted by this idea: government by code shifts the power from one set of elites (the wealthy/connected) to another (programmers with a specialized skill set that can read the code). But I'm unclear on how that benefits the nation as a whole.
- thelittleone 9y agoWhy would you need everyone in the country to read and understand the code? You just need a sufficiently large group of academics, programmers, developers etc to identify issues.
- landryraccoon 9y ago> You just need a sufficiently large group of academics, programmers, developers etc to identify issues. I don't attribute any sort of sainthood or trustability to academics over other segments of society. It's certainly not clear that programmers are especially qualified to craft public policy. Again, instead of one group of elites that can understand what's going on you're substituting another. Look, with Open Source software, programmers are mostly the consumers of that open source software. The customers of that software can more or less switch and aren't forced to use it at the barrel of a gun (and in the cases where big companies DO have monopoly power, the fact that they use Open Source software doesn't really stop them from exercising it in ways that are clearly for their benefit but less clearly for the benefit of their users). But if you're saying that software is now going to determine who can be arrested and who can go free, how long prison sentences will be or who can go on welfare or receive public money, there is HUGE incentive to game the system. Right now I might find Academics trustworthy because they don't get a huge financial benefit depending on the outcome of their research. But if public policy is controlled by software the incentives to cheat are huge. Now you can say they'll patrol each other, but that just means the incentive will be to collude collectively, as an entire group, for their own benefit against society at large.
- ikeboy 9y ago>A couple more clicks after that, and we’re looking at a summarized version of a bill tackling cybersecurity that the software has considered and rendered a judgment on, when it comes to the probability that it will become law. We’re not talking a rough estimate. There’s a decimal: 78.1 percent. No way in hell is it producing probabilities calibrated to 3 significant digits. If some kind of testing of calibration produces proof it's even within 1 percent calibrated I will be shocked.
- rayiner 9y agoIt's spitting out 3 digits for sure. The reporter is just too ignorant to realize that they're not 3 significant digits.
- ikeboy 9y agoObviously. It's both a concerning detail about the company (why are they displaying probabilities to a level of accuracy they can't possibly claim) and an indication the reporter didn't do due diligence. They actually use it to claim the company must have sophisticated software to get that kind of accuracy!
- eadmund 9y ago> Already, clients are signing on to the idea: Toyota and the National Institutes of Health, to name a couple. Toyota I can understand & accept, but is it appropriate for a branch of the executive to hire lobbyists to lobby the legislature? Just feels a bit unseemly to me. > Quorum says its system also powers one well-known late-night comedy show—it won’t reveal which one—helping staffers scan YouTube to pull together almost instantly a selection of footage about topics they might use on that night’s show. Says Wirth, “They’re like, ‘What kinds of Roy Moore clips do we have?’” The software has already machine-read heaps of video footage, turning them into tagged transcripts, and sends off exactly the correct clip to that evening’s show. Millions of Americans, without knowing it, are getting their political news curated for them in part by a Quorum bot. Sounds a bit like Last Week Tonight. In the cases of lobbying & clip-selection alike, what I worry about is how we'll groom the higher-level people without running them through their lower-level paces (since the lower levels will all be automated). What I mean is that a lower-level job has at least two purposes: one is to perform a job, and the other is to audition for the next higher job. The former is what AI excels at. It's really, really easy to automate the job of an 18-year-old who answers phones and hands them to the next person. It's not so easy to automate the job of a 24-year-old who answers phones and hands them to the right person. It's really, really difficult to automate the job of a 36-year-old who answers phones and decides whether the topic is important enough to hand to his boss. It's really supremely difficult to automate the job of a 48-year-old who answers phones and makes decisions. The problem is that every 18-year-old answering phones isn't just answering phones; he's also auditioning to be that 24-year-old finding the right person (experience he gets from the job itself). Likewise, every experienced 24-year=old is auditioning for the job of the very experience 36-year-old. And all those 36-year-olds are auditioning for the few slots as decision-making 48-year-olds. We can really easily automate those lower levels away. But what will be our 'farm team'? Where will we grow the talent and depth of experience necessary for the higher levels?
- pm90 9y agoThis isn't really surprising, nor is it new. Remember the days when one needed to know how OS's really worked to write code? Or when code was in assembly? All of today's code does compile down to that, but I'm willing to bet a large majority of programmers can't grok assembly (nor do they need to). Historically, we've seen the more tedious jobs get automated away to create better jobs that require more "human" skills. This is a good thing.
- GuiA 9y agoA big problem with the current incarnation of democracy is that there is no accountability over time of the various goals that officials claim to pursue. If someone running for office says that they will make sure the local firehouse gets an X% increase in budget and that unemployment in the district will go down by Y%, there should be an unambiguous way of tracking, over time, how they are doing on their promises. This "goal verification" seems like an important first step if one wishes to introduce meaningful computational processes in Washington. Ideally, over time, we would have a system against which we can run such promises: "The ministry of health says increasing the budget of X will lead to outcome Y, and our model agrees with this decision with a confidence of 90%". Eventually, this system might even build excellent models of what happens in various parts of society when various parameters are modified. It could predict where new schools need to be opened based on the natality data provided by hospitals and local employment rates, what the plausible long ranging effects of lowering or raising corporate tax by x% would be, whether the opening of a certain factory requires increasing the budget of the firehouse in the neighboring district because the district is now over a certain threshold for fire risks, and so on.
- comicjk 9y agoAny analysis of the promise "unemployment in the district will go down by Y%" will be worse than useless, because politicians have little control over the unemployment rate. You would be judging them based on a coin flip. You have to include the quality of the initial promises. As for modeling the effect of policy on the real world, lots of people already try to do this, and their results do not agree. It's a very hard problem, perhaps impossible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dboreham 9y agoBah. I was hoping this article was about automating away the politicians, not just the analysis of their neural network state :(
- forapurpose 9y agoUnlike in business, the question in politics and policy is not primarily efficiency and profit, but justice (including liberty and democracy) and human welfare. The relationship between automation and efficiency & profit is relatively clear, but the relationship between automation and justice & welfare is not. I think the questions are: 1. Automation can reduce transparency, by moving open discussions and reasoning into obscure, sometimes proprietary computer code. Effectively, the person writing the code, or the person who controls the coder, decides the policy. For example, some courts now use software to determine prison sentences; what was once decided based on established principles and transparently detailed by the judge is now decided in some cubicals by developers and written in C (which is often prioprietary). Why are you going to jail? The software (i.e., the developer) said so. Also, remember that code is mysterious and obscure to most people outside HN; they have no understanding of what it is, of its significance, what it can do, etc. Many can't define the word "algorithm" or even "web browser"; even open source code provides no transparency for them (and doesn't for us, unless someone makes the extraordinary effort to review the code). 2. To whom will automation shift power? The lobbyists with the best algorithm? The people developing the technology and solutions (see #1)? Will automation democratize power or further restrict it? Note that the developers of one solution in the article went to Harvard. Sounds to me like the same people running Washington, and the same gateways to power. 3. Lobbyists who have more data about constituents in general and about major players in particular will have an advantage. It could increase competition to erode privacy in its most important context - politics. 4. Will it result in better policy - more justice and better welfare - or just more power for the few with the data and algorithms? If I were devious and wanted to change judicial policy nationwide, for example, I'd buy the companies making software for courts. I'd be surprised if I was the first to think of that.
- noobermin 9y agoThe entire thing is that those who want this sort of thing are not interested in justice and welfare, they see politics as a way to enrich themselves.
- forapurpose 9y agoI think that's always the major issue in politics. IMHO: It's an issue of individuals: People are neither completely altruistic nor completely greedy. A very important factor is, where are the elite on that continuum? My humble hypothesis is that that's the main difference between a banana republic and first-world civilization and society. IMHO, the elite in the U.S. have swung far toward greed; the tax bill is a good example: There is no policy reason for it, not even a figleaf discussion of economics, and even the principles of conservatives (deficit reduction) are thrown by the wayside: They just want more money. It's also an issue of systems: How do we design a system that marries power, on one hand, to justice and welfare on the other? Then those who seek power also seek justice & welfare, intentionally or not. Democracy is an (incomplete) solution to that problem: Power flows from making the people happy. Despite the problems, the U.S. and other major democracies work and have worked for generations, and they work better than any other system of government. Somehow, I'm not sure how, that happens.
- adenadel 9y ago
- platz 9y agoTLDR: backoffice work in Washington can be automated just like backoffce work in corporations. FiscalNote wants to advertise the message that anything involving capturing backoffice data flows is actually "A.I", which means the career of every politician is in jeopardy, without FiscalNote.
- yazaddaruvala 9y agoTangentially related: I'm not sure if automated decisions are a good idea. But it would be really cool to improve productivity of politicians. How can we expect our politicians, let alone our lay people, to understand all of the law's in a country? There is just too much text to grok. Software developers build abstractions, write tests, refactor and simplify older code, yet no such trend seems to be occurring for law. Why not? Politicians already do use references and bucketization, i.e. write a law for schedule one drugs, then add or remove entities from the schedule one bucket. Can't we abstract even more? Recently I've been wondering if it is feasible to create a syntax for lawyers. Like a law language with a compiler, package manager and similar tooling to compile laws rather than write them from scratch. Anyone familiar with such research?
- whatshisface 9y agoI think what you're describing is fundamentally against the incentives of lawmakers. Complex laws make it possible to decouple legislative goals from public-image goals: when was the last time you saw something that actually had to be explained come up in a televised debate?
- arthurcolle 9y agounfortunately while cynical i do believe this comment captures the reality of the situation. whatshisface, what do you think can be done to take back US society and make it a little closer to what our seemingly more critically-thinking predecessors had lived through?
- yazaddaruvala 9y agoI agree this is a reality. Just like the cynical reality that C/C++ programers don't want to encourage package managers. The higher the barriers to entry the more you're talents are worth. The reality is, regardless of any one groups desire, the productivity wins of package managers are too great and the momentum of the larger software development community is moving towards package managers for every language and will one day include C/C++. Similarly, lawmakers are a select few of a larger community of domestic but more importantly international lawyers. You give the larger community a 10x productivity win, and just sit back and watch the domino effect work.
- bkohlmann 9y agoPrivate Wealth Management and Real Estate are two industries I once believed would easily be automated. And there have been a number of moves in each space to do so [Wealthfront and Betterment, Zillow etc]. But I've come to understand these industries are NOT built on rational, dispassionate decision making. The reason they only have a foothold in automation is because at their core, they are deeply relational industries. Even for incredibly sophisticated, "rational" individuals. People simply want a person to talk to and walk them through things - even when they have all the facts generated from sophisticated algorithms giving them an unequivocal "correct" answer. It seems like lobbying is the same. There is an important role for automation. But I believe it will simply augment the existing offering rather than completely supplant it. Politics is the most relational of professions. Rational policymaking is an idealists dream - and I say this as a metric-driven, lover of numbers who once believed in that dream.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoA better replacement for Wealthfront is merely buying the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%26P_500_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%26P_500_Index . I bet we could create an automated version of the S&P but at this time its just not beneficial due to financial laws and also just talking to a person. We need to think of automation as more of a cybernetics concept than just a program on a computer. In the front line you will have humans doing the Sales and that probably won't go away. In the back you will have computers which make decisions and in the middle you will have engineer(s) working on the interface. Once we can replace the sales experience thats when we will get there.
- johnnyb9 9y agoI think the idea is that you don’t want to be holding 100% US large cap equities when you’re in retirement.
- nostrademons 9y agoVanguard, Fidelity, and other funds all offer "Target Retirement date" funds which basically shift your asset allocation from stocks to bonds as you get closer to retirement. The individual mix is generally held in typical total-market index funds, mixed foreign/domestic based on the relative size of their economies. As long as you're okay with exactly-average investment performance (which is what index funds always give you), that's a good alternative, and the expense ratio is super low - 0.05% for Vanguard's offering. Actually, I just looked, and Wealthfront and Vanguard invest in the exact same funds (Vanguard's VTI and foreign equivalents), but Wealthfront's expense ratio was around 0.12% vs. 0.05% for Vanguard.
- stretchwithme 9y agoAutomation is about doing more with less. Washington strives to less with more.
- fogzen 9y agoYes, but automated for the people and not corporate lobbyists: https://united.vote https://united.vote
- snarfy 9y agoI'm not sure it can be but I certainly want it to be. My representative is a poor representation of me. I'd rather answer a questionnaire and feed the data into a virtual representative script that voted on laws on my behalf instead of a human.
- zanny 9y agoOn the flip-side, I don't want to live in a country where law is purely decided based on popular opinion. It is probably impossible to have a nation of purely rational, informed, soundly-minded voters for that kind of system. We are certainly very far away from that dream today.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 9y agoIsn't this just building a guide to Congressmen based on their stats, and selling it to lobbyists? I don't mean to say "just" to minimize it, it sounds like a valuable product, but if you tripled or quadrupled that 160 headcount, I'd bet you could build this guide to the same quality and usefulness without using computers. It doesn't threaten lobbyists, it's a product for lobbyists.
- cmroanirgo 9y agoIf you can elect a dog as a mayor[1], I think the answer is yes... even without reading the article. [1] https://roadtrippers.com/trips/16260761?lat=40.80972&lng=-96.67528&z=5 https://roadtrippers.com/trips/16260761?lat=40.80972&lng=-96...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- erikb 9y agoIf Washington=Government probably 99.9% can be replaced easily. Maybe even more easily than most factory jobs. The idea that their jobs would be more complex is an illusion. The only stressful thing they do is fighting each other for more power. However I bet it's one of the last places that actually gets automated. The value of the government is to give people reason to believe that everything is fine, that someone will deal with the big problems, etc. This story cannot be sold equally well if it's done by robots/AI. So even if we are really governed by AI some day these jobs will probably still exist. The show must go on.
- eurticket 9y agoI would say it should have been the first thing automated.