6 ms·
Judges question challenge to voting machines, but case could change state law
- rhcom2 9y agoFrom an actual source: http://www.kansas.com/news/politics-government/article174144281.html http://www.kansas.com/news/politics-government/article174144...
- sctb 9y agoThanks, we've updated the link from http://bloomsmag.com/a-mathematician-may-have-uncovered-widespread-election-fraud-and-kansas-is-trying-to-silence-her/ http://bloomsmag.com/a-mathematician-may-have-uncovered-wide....
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yazan94 9y agoCan someone explain why the machines themselves would be subject to inaccuracy? Can her discrepancies be explained by voter turnout or varying degrees of candidate charisma/competency?
- cjslep 9y agoWhen people vote, the machines they use record votes electronically and on tape. However, when summing up the votes, only the electronic portion is tallied up by removing a physical memory device and plugging them in to another special machine that does the summation. This woman wants access to the actual physical tapes which have been stored, in order to do a statistical sampling of them in order to say how statistically likely the electronic tally was. (Physically counting the tapes by hand is not practical) The courts are considering barring her again from access to the tapes. If the electronic portion was highly statistically unlikely, then there are a lot of places the vote could have been tampered: tallying machines, individual voting machines, memory cartridges, physical transport of memory cartridges, even the paper tapes themselves, etc. For a documentary I recommend watching Hacking Democracy.
- yazan94 9y agoThank you very much for explaining it. In my jurisdiction, we fill in our choices on paper ballots and insert them to a machine. I thought this single machine did its thing on its own and without additional machines. Thank you for explaining the process and the various points of suspicion in the process
- kthejoker2 9y agoThis is literally a non-story, in that no evidence is provided one way or the other, and it appears to be turning extremely traditional political posturing - forcing allegations of misdeeds to go through lawsuits and exhibit things like standing, harm, etc. - Anyway, that being said, the stock picture they used for the header is pure unadulterated gold. It's straight out of The Colbert Report.
- ethbro 9y agoGive the entire case is about access to evidence (which Kansas denied previous request for), I'm not sure how the story could have been written any other way. If election tampering were occurring, how would one discover that? How would one confirm it? If the answer to the above questions is "Trust us, vote tampering isn't happening," then election laws in that state probably need to be changed.
- smsm42 9y agoAt least it could describe some evidence in why there is a reasonable suspicion exists that something is wrong. Saying "well, some woman thinks something's wrong and because she happens to be a statistician she must be onto a government conspiracy" is not very informative. The only thing the article gives is: > Clarkson has said her statistical analyses of elections over several years have shown discrepancies indicating vote tampering. What kind of discrepancies? Indicating how? What kind of tampering? No idea.
- unclebucknasty 9y ago>At least it could describe some evidence in why there is a reasonable suspicion exists that something is wrong. The burden should be on the state to demonstrate that voting is secure and accurate, especially given that they control the data and the processes, thereby making it more difficult for someone to present evidence. As it is, the state's position is circular: "we won't give you access to the information you need to prove something was amiss until you prove that something was amiss". But, even in the absence of someone questioning, the state should be able to show why there is no cause for concern in ways that allow the public and outside experts to verify for themselves. However, on the contrary, many precincts refuse to allow a paper trail/receipts and they continue to use machines that have demonstrated vulnerabilities, further obscuring the issue. It looks like this case may be prompting legislation that is moving in exactly this direction. That would be a positive outcome.
- jonbarker 9y agoThis seems to augment Tim Snyder's argument for a return to paper ballots (not paper tapes which have a software layer between them and the machines).