3 ms·
> businesses can be legal in states while being illegal under federal law It still sounds a way ridiculous for a thing to be legal and illegal at the same time
by qwerty456127 9y ago
> businesses can be legal in states while being illegal under federal law
It still sounds a way ridiculous for a thing to be legal and illegal at the same time. There ought to be a non-ambiguous mechanism to decide whether a business is legal or not. As long as the feds let the states decide on their own they shouldn't consider something to be a crime as long as it is done in a state where it is legal. E.g. pot money from Colorado should be considered perfectly clean while pot money from Idaho can be treated as criminal. Doesn't this make sense?
> Banking is heavily regulated for a reason (terrorist financing
Doesn't seem to help much, terrorists still get everything they need.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It still sounds a way ridiculous for a thing to be legal and illegal at the same time. It's not legal and illegal at the same time. It is not prohibited by state law, and prohibited by federal law. It is, therefore, illegal, plain and simple. Much like California's prison policies few years back: they were exactly what state law specified, but violated federal law. They weren't in some weird legal-illegal contradictory state, they were illegal. > As long as the feds let the states decide on their own Federal law does not allow states to decide on their own, in fact, it prohibits them from doing so (OTOH, on state authorized medical marijuana, there is also federal law tied to spending bills for the last several years prohibiting federal enforcement that interferes with the state implementation, but an enforcement moratorium isn't legalization.)
- azernik 9y agoIn a unitary state (i.e. one without a federal system) you don't have this particular source of ambiguity - the central government passes laws, and they define what's legal [1]. The USA, however, has a federal system; the essence of that system is a separate of powers between Federal and state governments, which means you also have conflicts of power between Federal and state governments over whose law applies. Drug policy is a classic example; so was segregation, for example. In this case, the act in question is the Controlled Substances Act, which makes a whole host of drug offenses federal crimes. It was ruled constitutional [2] in the early 2000s, in response to a challenge from California pot growers obeying the local medical marijuana laws who were raided by the DEA. That is supposed to be the mechanism by which to decide these questions; go to the Supreme Court. However, it turns out that even if states don't actively prevent the feds from enforcing drug laws, most of drug enforcement is in fact done by local police. If the SFPD isn't going to arrest you for smoking joints or selling potklava in Dolores Park, what's the federal government going to do? Put DEA agents on patrol on street corners in SF? Which leaves the federal government in the situation of having declared something illegal, but without having anywhere near the resources to enforce those laws - and the states passively encouraging disobedience of those laws. Welcome, young folk, to the USA's first real-life (if small) constitutional crisis since Watergate! [1] Leaving aside the conflict between constitutional law and regular law. [2] Under the Commerce Clause, which I think is a bit of a stretch, but hey, that's the Commerce Clause for ya
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Welcome, young folk, to the USA's first real-life (if small) constitutional crisis since Watergate! Not even close. For one thing, it's no more of a Constitutional crisis than the structurally similar sanctuary city movement, which is considerably older.
- azernik 9y agoI think the scale of this is in practice substantially larger than the sanctuary city movement, as is the centrality of local cooperation to enforcement.
- gadders 9y ago>> If the SFPD isn't going to arrest you for smoking joints or selling potklava in Dolores Park, what's the federal government going to do? I would guess they would target the growers/large suppliers.
- UncleEntity 9y ago> Under the Commerce Clause, which I think is a bit of a stretch, but hey, that's the Commerce Clause for ya My favorite bit of the federal drug policy: magic mushrooms grew wild on my college campus since...forever. There was in no way, by any stretch of the imagination, 'interstate commerce' involved in any part of their life cycle yet it was a federal crime to pick them. How's that work?
- lawlessquestion 9y agoBecause you picking said mushrooms affects interstate commerce, which after dude's new deal would fall under the control of the commerce clause. Prior to fdr only people and things in interstate commerce could be controlled
- azernik 9y agoBingo! In fact, the specific precedent cited by the Supreme Court for convicting marijuana growers in CA was the price controls on agricultural produce during the New Deal era.