5 ms·
I just wonder when will this nonsense ("banks saying no") end and when a financial system at least as free as cash and as quick and convenient as just using deb
by qwerty456127 9y ago
I just wonder when will this nonsense ("banks saying no") end and when a financial system at least as free as cash and as quick and convenient as just using debit cards emerge. It seems that we have came to a point when we need to separate banking from state and police the way church has gotten separated from them earlier. That's a pity BitCoin has failed to do this. Hopefully Monero or something new will succeed once and set the people free...
- dx034 9y agoThe problem is not the banking system, it's that businesses can be legal in states while being illegal under federal law. Any company with business across states is at risk dealing with those companies. Banking is heavily regulated for a reason (terrorist financing, money laundering, fraud) and I doubt many would appreciate if you stop banking regulation altogether. The only solution I see here is to change federal law.
- uiri 9y agoAre local, state-chartered banks with no branches outside of their home state just as squeamish when it comes to marijuana businesses?
- UncleEntity 9y agoFeds don't care, all they have to do is find a single dollar bill printed outside the state and they have jurisdiction.
- asmithmd1 9y agoUntil the interstate banking act of 1994, all banks had branches only in their own state.
- Feniks 9y agoBanks will be blacklisted if they finance drugdealers. The US war on drugs is no joke and it is international. If your bank participates in the global financial system it can't ignore the US.
- qwerty456127 9y ago> businesses can be legal in states while being illegal under federal law It still sounds a way ridiculous for a thing to be legal and illegal at the same time. There ought to be a non-ambiguous mechanism to decide whether a business is legal or not. As long as the feds let the states decide on their own they shouldn't consider something to be a crime as long as it is done in a state where it is legal. E.g. pot money from Colorado should be considered perfectly clean while pot money from Idaho can be treated as criminal. Doesn't this make sense? > Banking is heavily regulated for a reason (terrorist financing Doesn't seem to help much, terrorists still get everything they need.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It still sounds a way ridiculous for a thing to be legal and illegal at the same time. It's not legal and illegal at the same time. It is not prohibited by state law, and prohibited by federal law. It is, therefore, illegal, plain and simple. Much like California's prison policies few years back: they were exactly what state law specified, but violated federal law. They weren't in some weird legal-illegal contradictory state, they were illegal. > As long as the feds let the states decide on their own Federal law does not allow states to decide on their own, in fact, it prohibits them from doing so (OTOH, on state authorized medical marijuana, there is also federal law tied to spending bills for the last several years prohibiting federal enforcement that interferes with the state implementation, but an enforcement moratorium isn't legalization.)
- azernik 9y agoIn a unitary state (i.e. one without a federal system) you don't have this particular source of ambiguity - the central government passes laws, and they define what's legal [1]. The USA, however, has a federal system; the essence of that system is a separate of powers between Federal and state governments, which means you also have conflicts of power between Federal and state governments over whose law applies. Drug policy is a classic example; so was segregation, for example. In this case, the act in question is the Controlled Substances Act, which makes a whole host of drug offenses federal crimes. It was ruled constitutional [2] in the early 2000s, in response to a challenge from California pot growers obeying the local medical marijuana laws who were raided by the DEA. That is supposed to be the mechanism by which to decide these questions; go to the Supreme Court. However, it turns out that even if states don't actively prevent the feds from enforcing drug laws, most of drug enforcement is in fact done by local police. If the SFPD isn't going to arrest you for smoking joints or selling potklava in Dolores Park, what's the federal government going to do? Put DEA agents on patrol on street corners in SF? Which leaves the federal government in the situation of having declared something illegal, but without having anywhere near the resources to enforce those laws - and the states passively encouraging disobedience of those laws. Welcome, young folk, to the USA's first real-life (if small) constitutional crisis since Watergate! [1] Leaving aside the conflict between constitutional law and regular law. [2] Under the Commerce Clause, which I think is a bit of a stretch, but hey, that's the Commerce Clause for ya
- fineline 9y agoI don't see too much problem with state controlling money creation - sovereign currency gives the latitude for deficit spending which provides opportunity to invest in future economic growth. (I have no idea why many "fiscal conservatives" have a problem with debt-fuelled capital investment by government whilst embracing it as normal and indeed good practice in the private sphere.) But separation of finance _industry_ from state - the incredible amount of policy influence that the industry has, to its own benefit and the detriment of just about everyone else except the very rich, to the extent that many politics-industry players, on all sides, are basically representatives of banks - yes, that would be some kind of holy grail.
- cbcoutinho 9y ago> I have no idea why many "fiscal conservatives" have a problem with debt-fuelled capital investment by government whilst embracing it as normal and indeed good practice in the private sphere I'm going to go out on a limb and say financial conservatives would agree there should be a reasonable risk of failure for businesses leveraging debt. That's the risk they take to reap the benefits of future growth. Governments should not be allowed to (can't?) fail in the same way businesses can, so shouldn't be able to take on the same risk.
- fineline 9y agoGovernment checks can't bounce. http://moslereconomics.com/wp-content/powerpoints/7DIF.pdf http://moslereconomics.com/wp-content/powerpoints/7DIF.pdf Unless they give up sovereignty over their own currency of course. A mistake made by European countries - several of which have paid and are continuing to pay the price. I absolutely agree that too much public debt is a bad thing, but not for the normally given reasons. It can lead to inflation, devaluation of the currency in relation to either goods or investment asset prices - indeed we see the latter at the moment in stock and property markets around the world, although that is driven by money creation through private lending. This is more worrying, as private checks can and do bounce, debts default, and we get another financial crisis. Govt debt should be used for capital investment - roads, communications, health, education and security facilities - and if so used can be a true investment with an expectation of future returns. Debt that blows out on operational expenditure, transfer payments, public sector bureaucracy bloat, is not sustainable.
- natecavanaugh 9y agoI actually think having the state involved with banking is a good thing, overall. I think it represents that the economic part of that country is backed by the force of that country (meaning it's people are willing to fight to back up the value, if need be as well as their economic force). I think that aspect alone helps stabilize out the current economy where it could be so much more volatile. However, when I think of the weed industry and banking, that's where I think a cryptocurrency has its best value, and will either find a foothold to dominate the financial industry, or at the very least provide the path of dynamic changes/experiments for those areas like this one where we don't want to risk the stability of all markets by "testing things out", but need to discover a path of progress to match the speed of innovation and technology. I tend to think the latter (the former doesn't seem plausible as the inconveniences outweigh the benefits currently), but I would hope that the government realizes, all else being equal, their views on cannabis as a schedule 1 drug is costing them a ton of money they could be reliably tracking and that business would be happy to pay in taxes to avoid the current nightmare.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- supreme_sublime 9y agoWhile this is true, they have to be weary of setting taxes too high. There is already a lot of infrastructure set up for the black market and you have to makes sure the taxes aren't so high that the legal market can't compete with the black market.
- lawn 9y agoThis is a perfect use case of a peer-to-peer digital currency, as outlined in the Bitcoin whitepaper. Cases like this is why cryptocurrencies even exist. Technically Monero is indeed the closest as it's the only fungible coin, which is an essential property.
- patrickk 9y agoMonero, like most cryptos, is very volatile[1]. If I owned a small business and was looking to accept crypto payments, this price uncertainty would mean I'd only use it if I could quickly cash it out to something stable, most likely using something like BitPay, which then negates the p2p aspect. The prices on the shelves wouldn't be denominated in units of XMR either - they'd be in the local fiat. For crypto payments to be accepted in businesses in the above scenario (and therefore become as mainstream as Visa or Mastercard), a robust stablecoin would be required, like what MakerDAO[2] is trying to achieve. Even though I've invested in them, I'd ultimately give them perhaps 10-20% chance of succeeding. Their product is incredibly hard to wrap your head around. However, if Sai or some other stablecoin can achieve quick, cheap transactions, then it's possible that consumers will use it for everyday spending. Big "if" though. [1] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/monero/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/monero/ [2] https://makerdao.com/ https://makerdao.com/
- lawn 9y agoCryptocurrencies are very volatile because they are very new not because anything fundamentally worse compared to fiat. If they some day will be accepted as a regular currency and you can buy everything you need with them then there is no reason to go back to local fiat. Then the prices on the shelves would indeed be denominated in units of XMR for example. That is indeed a big if though.
- atom-morgan 9y agoThe future is being downvoted on HN of all places.
- beefield 9y ago> That's a pity BitCoin has failed to do this. Hopefully Monero or something new will succeed once and set the people free... I guess the first step on the path to success for a new currency would be to acknowledge and understand the relationship between credit and modern efficient money (the relationship here being equality). Fractional reserve banking was disruption of money much before SV started to use the term. Unfortunately it looks like the cryptocurrencyfolks seem quite stubborn in sticking with the monetary concepts of stone ages, so I am not holding my breath waiting any cryptocurrency to succeed as real world money any time soon.
- rebuilder 9y agoI'm not sure cryptocurrencies can help legal cannabis sellers all that much. Unless they can conduct their whole business in cryptos, they still need to have a bank somewhere. And since these sellers are legit, laundering money via crypto to hide the source of their income from the banks isn't really an option.
- MuncleUscles 9y agoRadix aims to be quick and cheap enough to be a viable option for this https://www.radix.global/ https://www.radix.global/ They can even support off the shelf POS terminals https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMw7hQ6x2f0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pMw7hQ6x2f0 Disclaimer: I have just joined their team, because I think what they're doing is awesome