8 ms·
How does the Clipper Chip compare to more modern technologies like the Intel Management Engine?
by pmoriarty 9y ago
How does the Clipper Chip compare to more modern technologies like the Intel Management Engine?
- schoen 9y agoThey have very little in common. The Clipper Chip was designed by the government to be used in phones in order to give people communications security—but not too much communications security against government entities—and to pre-empt and outcompete other cryptographic voice privacy solutions that people might want to adopt. The IME is designed by Intel to allow remote management of PCs. It creates risks of unauthorized access to those computers, including by increasing the attack surface outside of (one might say "beneath") ordinary operating system security features. I guess the parallel is that both are hardware-implemented device functionality that many users might not want and that could expose their data to risks they don't appreciate.
- excitom 9y ago"Cryptography is the silver bullet by which we can hope to reclaim our privacy. The solution, however, has one drawback: cryptography shields the law abiding and the lawless equally. Law-enforcement and intelligence agencies contend that if strong codes are widely available, their efforts to protect the public would be paralyzed. So they have come up with a compromise, a way to neutralize such encryption. That's the Clipper chip and that compromise is what the war is about." So there it is, a government-mandated encryption device that has a backdoor built in. The IME is a well-intended system management feature that can be turned to nefarious purposes since it can go around all operating system security features, e.g. read or update all of the system's memory.
- jacobush 9y agoThe Clipper Chip was also well intended. It's just that it put the emphasis of trust somewhere most of us are not happy with.
- Nullabillity 9y agoIf the IME was well-intentioned then it would have been easy to disable, and the source code would have been public.
- pjc50 9y agoFirmware is never public, it's just proprietary code. Closedness tells us almost nothing about intent.