5 ms·
What's wrong is that copyright doesn't work that way: "must have been created independently and contain a sufficient amount of creativity" from : https://www.
by dboreham 9y ago
What's wrong is that copyright doesn't work that way:
"must have been created independently and contain a sufficient amount of creativity"
from : https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ33.pdf https://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ33.pdf
US copyright of course, ymmv but I doubt other countries are going to be more likely to allow white noise / PN sequences.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- taneq 9y agoHow do they define "creativity"? Because surely, a specific sample of properly random white noise would have maximum density of unique information (useful or not - but then is a song "useful"? Where's the line?)
- wilun 9y agoYou are confusing different things.
- gh02t 9y agoIt's not a precise standard, the exact boundaries of "creativity" would be left up to a judge to decide in a case where it was truly ambiguous. I'm pretty sure that this specific case would count as a minor modification to a work in the public domain, which does not qualify. https://copyright.uslegal.com/enumerated-categories-of-copyrightable-works/creativity-requirement/ https://copyright.uslegal.com/enumerated-categories-of-copyr...
- taneq 9y agoYeah, that was kind of my point. Including non-precise words in a legal document is like saying "a wizard did it".
- xg15 9y agoUsing deliberately undefined or "non-precise" words is a core concept in legal documents. It provides leeway and "escape hatches" where humans can decide if a law actually makes sense in a specific case. This is why we are talking about "spirit" vs "letter" of the law.
- oxguy3 9y agoThe information does have to be useful or original. If there was something innovative or original about the way the random information was created, then that might be copyrightable, but if it's just arbitrary randomness, there's no reasonable claim.
- theoh 9y agoIf we're talking about creative work, the state doesn't really have any authority in deciding what's adequately creative. A aiff file full of random or nearly random data sounds like a plausible form for a creative work to take to me.
- mywittyname 9y agoSure they do, by virtue of creating the laws that they then adjudicate and enforce, the state has the authority to legally determine what is creative, at least in the legal sense. It's likely that your "creative work" will need to be similar to other forms of creative work in order to enjoy that status. Either that, or you need to earn a reputation within a creative community as a person how pushes the conventional boundaries. In other words, randomly generated sounds are not widely considered to be creative in the conventional sense. So, unless you become the next deadmau5, it's unlikely that a court would rule that your random noise is considered art.
- alanh 9y agoThose with no knowledge of the law constantly spouting off as if they do is easily one of the worst features of HN.