4 ms·
If I make a perfectly identical clone of you, and then shoot you dead, will you resume your consciousness in that clone? Why? Alternatively, if I shoot the cl
by vkou 9y ago
If I make a perfectly identical clone of you, and then shoot you dead, will you resume your consciousness in that clone?
Why?
Alternatively, if I shoot the clone, will the clone resume its consciousness in you? By what process?
- arebop 9y agoI wasn't attempting to realize the top commenter's fear of > unproductive debate about what consciousness is or is not I'm just addressing the question of why you'd say yes: you might be ready to be put of your misery, and at that point, why would you say "no"? The resumption of "you" gets an afterlife, and nothing gets worse for the you that's about to die either way.
- theothermkn 9y agoThe strange places this leads arrive almost immediately. Are you the same person after you take a nap? Doesn't your consciousness basically dissolve and then reconstitute itself when "you" wake? What about from second to second, between moments of inattention? Are we relying on the "stability" of your constituent atoms? On some "arrangement" of them? On a particular locus of sensation (the goo in your brain pan)? What if we "clone" you by copying every other atom into a "left" clone, leaving the original in the right, and doing the reverse on the alternating atoms? Which resulting "clone" is you? This way lies madness. Possibly twice.
- nwah1 9y agoLook into open individualism as one possible resolution.
- henrikschroder 9y ago> Are you the same person after you take a nap? Yes. > Doesn't your consciousness basically dissolve and then reconstitute itself when "you" wake? Yes. > What about from second to second, between moments of inattention? Yes. > Are we relying on the "stability" of your constituent atoms? Yes. > On some "arrangement" of them? Yes. > On a particular locus of sensation (the goo in your brain pan)? Yes. > What if we "clone" you by copying every other atom into a "left" clone, leaving the original in the right, and doing the reverse on the alternating atoms? Which resulting "clone" is you? My father replaced the handle, and I replaced the blade, but it's still my grandfather's axe? Neither. You ripped my brain in half, I am dead.
- szemet 9y agoIf you wake up from deep sleep in the morning your consciousness from yesterday is resumed? What makes it the same consciousness as the yesterday one, if not all your memories, and past experiences? If my pure consciousness wakes up tomorrow in your body, with all your memories, will it be your consciousness then?
- chr1 9y agoThe question in this case is "what is a perfectly identical clone" and what is time. If the thing works like a computer, that is clone is truly identical, and time is just a counter, then there is nothing to resume the clone won't know that it was cloned, and the whole thing won't be much different from the normal passage of time, (except for seeing yourself killed won't be pleasant). But if there is something else that you can't clone, like quantum state being impossible to clone perfectly, or a soul, then the clone is not you but that's because the assumption of a `perfectly identical clone` is wrong