2 ms·
>> No, that was the "generic you". OK. Sorry if I sounded a bit rude, above. >> No. That's how families work. Sometimes. That trade exists and people exchang
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> No, that was the "generic you".
OK. Sorry if I sounded a bit rude, above.
>> No. That's how families work. Sometimes.
That trade exists and people exchange goods and services for money, does not
mean there is no solidarity, or that there can be none. People -in capitalist
economies- give to charity. They help each other with personal problems. When
there is a natural catastrophe, they help each other. Public money is spent to
help those in need, even if they themselves cannot contribut to the communal
pot (e.g. with disability allowances and unemployment benefits). Public health
and public education are also prime examples of this.
I am prefectly aware that these benefits that come with simply being born into
a given society are not universal. For example, I know that in the US, neither
healthcare nor (higher) education are free. However, these are examples of
erosion of solidarity, that have been strongly criticised and should be
strongly criticised.
>> Because we can't cure them yet without breaking other things.
I don't see how this is the case. Where should public money be better spent
than in healthcare?
Also, btw, I'm really not convinced by the claim that "good things come to
those who wait" (in this case anyway). There are plenty of examples of drug
firms resisting the release of generic, cheap, alternatives to their
proprietary, expensive drugs. There is Martin Shkrelli, who bought Daraprim,
first in 1953, and hiked its price from $13.50 to $750 (per tablet). There is
the Mylan, who hiked the price of EpiPen from $94, in 2007, to $608, in 2016
(Epinephrine was first approved for marketing in 1987).
There are also examples of technologies becoming cheaper, but I'm particularly
interested in medical technologies, not computers. I don't care if computer
become cheaper and available to everybody. People can live without computers.
They can't live without, well, without drugs that keep them alive.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI apologize for my tone in my initial comment as well. > I don't see how this is the case. Where should public money be better spent than in healthcare? R&D to make healthcare cheaper? It's an exploration/exploitation problem. Also, policing, education, administration, infrastructure, defense. Healthcare is a practically infinite money sink, so there have to be limits somewhere. Especially that beyond some point, it becomes cheaper to save an additional life through spending on e.g. policing than healthcare. Don't get me wrong - I'm not saying everything is perfect in the way our society allocates resources - just that it's a bit too much to condemn it entirely for not providing a quality-of-life improvements (blindness is tough, but not life-threatening) for free, to everyone, just as they come out of the lab.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> R&D to make healthcare cheaper? That would be a start. Public healthcare, in the European model, would be ideal. It's true that it's a huge money sink, but that can be managed somewhat- by cost/benefit calculations, which sounds harsh and inhumane but is I think is justifiable.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI agree and maybe should have stated it more directly - I'm from Europe after all, and I enjoy the European model. Unfortunately, public healthcare doesn't fund drug development itself and, given the costs involved, it would probably be hard to make happen without serious reallocation of budgets in at least member states of EU (which wouldn't be a bad idea, for many reasons, but we both know it's not going to happen).
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoWell, it doesn't fund it directly, but I think, since the public is paying for the drugs, the companies that make them can afford to spend money on them, knowing that they will be able to sell them afterwards, even at a raised price (the public can afford a lot more than individuals can). So there's an indirecty subsidy on drug development, I guess. Which is fine by me, to be perfectly clear. If people can access the drugs they need, then fine, let the companies make a profit, why not. I mean, within limits and all.