5 ms·
> Every bit of data stored on an iMac Pro’s SSD is encrypted on the fly by the T2, so that if a nefarious person tried to pull out the storage chips and read th
by mschuster91 9y ago
> Every bit of data stored on an iMac Pro’s SSD is encrypted on the fly by the T2, so that if a nefarious person tried to pull out the storage chips and read them later, they’d be out of luck.
What. The. Fuck. How am I supposed to recover my data e.g. if the mainboard gets fried or the machine has to go to service?! With a SATA or NVMe SSD I can plug them into another computer and either keep going (for Linux and macOS, only Windows is a different beast...) or dump the data to somehere safe. With this, Apple forces me to rely on TimeMachine working - which is not a bad idea in itself, but not cool that this is not widely announced on the product page: "BACK UP THE DATA YOURSELF OR IT WILL GET LOST IF ANYTHING GETS SCREWED UP".
There's already FileVault for encryption (or LUKS, VeraCrypt and Bitlocker), and in addition some SSDs (and iirc also some expensive HDDs) implement native on disk encryption via standardized SATA commands so one has encrypted storage but still portability (and for native disk encryption, no loss due to CPU-level encryption!).
Another reason to not buy anything modern from Apple. If one single problem happens to your modern work machine you're straight out f...ed.
- Waterluvian 9y agoI agree that one cannot say, "backing up is good practice, if you don't do it, it's your own fault." Because the real world simply doesn't always work that way. But I like having the option of that feature. For years now my local disks are effectively just local caches. They never have more than a days worth of non-backed-up data. Apple needs to work on making it as automatic and invisible as possible for this to happen to everyone's machine even if they're tech illiterate. All I've seen so far are disparate backup stories that leave me unconfident about any of them.
- ghaff 9y ago>Apple needs to work on making it as automatic and invisible as possible for this to happen to everyone's machine even if they're tech illiterate. I suppose there's some degree of tech literacy required just to know that you should have a backup. But, honestly, Time Machine is probably the easiest backup system I'm aware of and I run all three major operating systems including running a cloud backup on my desktop Mac. If I were to point a finger at anyone, it would be Microsoft. (I don't really expect Linux to be drop-dead simple.) On Windows 10, it's still not really "just works" out of the box.
- briandear 9y agoStore everything on iCloud Drive and it does backup "automatic" and invisibly.
- willstrafach 9y agoWhat part of the hardware exactly is failing in your scenario? It looks like iMac Pro still supports Target Disk Mode to access disk contents if your computer is damaged (You'd need the password to decrypt, of course): https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201462 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201462
- joombaga 9y agoHe says "mainboard", so it's fair to assume the computer would not be bootable in this scenario, which precludes the use of Target Disk Mode.
- mschuster91 9y agoExactly. Or if the power supply is broken... or the CPU, or the RAM, or anything that requires the iMac sent off to servicing. Also, I'd need another Mac to access the data, whereas with a USB-SATA enclosure I could use anything that runs Linux (as there are HFS+ drivers for it). For the new breed of cr.p Apple has forced upon us I'd need a Mac AND a Thunderbolt Cable AND the luck that the source system is still bootable.
- joombaga 9y agoIf you're using HFS+ then you can put the system in target disk mode and access it from any machine with an HFS+ driver. Not sure if there's APFS support in linux yet.
- mschuster91 9y agoHow to put a machine that does not boot (any combo of fried CPU/motherboard/RAM/PSU) into target disk mode? Or, when the machine boots but you don't have a Thunderbolt link cable? That's the core question. Apple needlessly deviates from any standard.
- jonknee 9y agoWhat is your plan to access storage if your phone's motherboard gets fried?
- mschuster91 9y agoI actually would be fine as long as the SIM card is not fried - yeah I would lose some game progress data but that's it. My calendar, phonebook and mails are in the cloud, Whatsapp has regular backups to the SD card, as are the images.
- jonknee 9y agoSounds like a similar strategy would work fine with the iMac Pro...
- ansible 9y agoI, personally love and hate the disappearance of micro-SD cards with phones. Love, because many SD cards are crap, and will lose your data without much notice. Hate, because then there is no recovery option other than "travel back in time to backup your data", if you haven't already backed up your data. I sort of give phones a pass these days because they are size and weight constrained. Desktop PCs though????? I disagree with the decision not to use a NVMe SSD card slot on this product.
- scarface74 9y agoBacking up your iPhone to iCloud is turned on by default.
- AlphaSite 9y agoSo is backing up most of your Mac.
- jandrese 9y agoUse your backup. IMHO, backups are even more necessary on Mac. Apple has has the fussiest file systems in my experience and of all of the backups I keep in my house my wife's Mac backups are the only ones I've ever had to really use. Three times now over the past 10 or so years. Just one day she opens the lid and gets a grey screen with a sad Mac and I know that just like last time the repair options won't do squat.
- djrogers 9y agoWhat is your plan to access data on a drive if the SSD controller chip gets fried? Self encrypting disks are not new.
- mschuster91 9y ago> What is your plan to access data on a drive if the SSD controller chip gets fried? I have yet to see a failed controller chip - motherboard or PSU failures due to coffee, cats, dogs or any combination of these three however I have seen multiple times in my social circle.
- rsynnott 9y ago> What. The. Fuck. How am I supposed to recover my data e.g. if the mainboard gets fried or the machine has to go to service?! Either switch off the feature or use backups.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Either switch off the feature This does not help, as the modules are non-standard and can only be read in another iMac (if the encryption is actually disable-able in the first place).
- rsynnott 9y agoSo, read them with another Mac? That's been the case with Apple PCIe SSDs for the past few years, anyway. I mean, at least they're not soldered, I suppose... And yes, the encryption can be disabled. You can choose to have either the new encryption system, FileVault, both (recommended), or neither.