13 ms·
Motel 6 routinely gave guests' information to immigration officials
- poulsbohemian 9y agoI'm glad we have Bob Ferguson here in the great state of Washington standing up to the Feds. Apart from this case, will also be interesting watching what he does in relation to Session's revocation of the Cole memo.
- reaperducer 9y agoIs he also going to stand up to his local sheriff and police departments? Because there isn't a hotel in America that doesn't hand over its guest register to the local LEOs on request.
- damikiova 9y agoBtw. Exactly same what facebook does also. Is this really news to anybody?
- tzahola 9y agoBut Facebook are the good guys. They’ve even had that pride-flag avatar thing, don’t you remember?
- fishcolorbrick 9y ago> Exactly same what facebook does also. My google-fu is weak - I can't find any source for Facebook providing information to ICE. Would you please help me out with some more information on this?
- indubitable 9y agoWhat exactly is supposed to have been "unlawful" here? Companies regularly sell your information to anybody willing to pay for it. In this case that selling actually had some overlap with improving lawfulness in an area. As for 'selling', this article omits the information that desk clerks were receiving a 'bounty' of $x per illegal immigrant caught. I'd certainly understand some outrage if we lived in a nation where there was any value whatsoever put on strong individual privacy protections, but we live in one that's rather the opposite - and so I'm not seeing the issue.
- aroch 9y agoWell it's a violation of their own privacy policy, which is why the Wa. state AG is suing them: From: https://www.motel6.com/en/faq.html | https://web.archive.org/web/20171124044157/https://www.motel6.com/en/faq.html What we will and will not do with Guest Information 1. We will not sell trade or rent Guest Information to parties outside the Company, our franchisees and affiliates, or permit our affiliates to sell such information to parties outside of our group of companies, franchisees and affiliates.
- indubitable 9y agoWell you're being rather disingenuous. Those exact terms [1] also include: Compliance with Law This is a United States Site and is subject to the laws of the United States. We may disclose Guest Information to law enforcement agencies, or may be required to disclose it during the discovery process in litigation, pursuant to a court order, or in compliance with any applicable law, regulation, rule or ordinance. [1] - https://www.motel6.com/en/faq.html https://www.motel6.com/en/faq.html
- aroch 9y agoThis is about them voluntarily giving guest information to ICE without informing the guests. Which caused actual harm to at least 6 residents in the state of Washington. There's no federal law saying that hotels must provide detailed guest info (name, DOB, drivers license, car license plate, room number, and other info) and the hotel. So my plain reading of their terms would suggest that data should only be shared "during the discovery process in litigation [or] pursuant to a court order" Washington state however has a statute that protects consumers from such data sharing. (Also, I added a link to the terms in an edit that also fixed formatting. Wasn't my intention to be deceptive by omitting it)
- DannyBee 9y ago"So my plain reading of their terms would suggest that data should only be shared "during the discovery process in litigation [or] pursuant to a court order"" Uh? "We may disclose Guest Information to law enforcement agencies, or may be required to disclose it during the discovery process in litigation ..." A court is going to say these are two different sentences talking about two different things. One where they voluntarily may do it whenever they want, and one where they may be required to do it anyway by court order.
- AlgorithmicTime 9y agoI... don't really see the problem with this?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ballenf 9y agoReplacing "undocumented immigrant" with "jew" or "same-sex couple" or "interracial couple" or "movie torrent pirate"... surely one of those substitutions triggers a reaction in even the most law-and-order out there. edit: And most of those categories have been illegal in some states in the US's history.
- aceoflala 9y agoAre jews illegal per se? Are illegal immigrants illegal per se?
- Cyberdog 9y ago> Are illegal immigrants illegal per se? Sure. So how do we determine who is an illegal immigrant? By looking at an illegally-obtained list of names and picking out the Hispanic ones for background checks?
- stillhere 9y ago> So how do we determine who is an illegal immigrant? Good question. It must be hard for law enforcement to do this considering the laws protecting probable ones.
- chrismeller 9y agoThe majority of European (and other) countries require everyone staying at a hotel be reported, so it doesn’t become the hotel’s job to determine illegal vs legal, it just becomes a huge privacy issue for everyone because the government knows everywhere you stay.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- avn2109 9y agoHate to be the bearer of bad news, but nearly every hotel/motel shares information with some subset of law enforcement themed agencies, regardless of what their "privacy policy" says on paper. e.g. Why do you have to write down your car's plate number, by law, if you pay cash for a hotel room? So the law can find you when you're on the run and therefore not using a credit card, of course. This is law enforcement 101, one of the oldest tricks in the book. It's not just ICE, there must be literally dozens of three letter agencies privy to the same information from Motel 6 and its competitors.
- kstrauser 9y agoI worked as a night auditor in a couple of hotels while in college, and I’ve never even heard a rumor of what you’re talking about. We never gave a scrap of information to a LEO unless it was directly related to a crime under active investigation (as in “we chased someone into room 204 and arrested them. Do you have their registration info?”). As others have said, license plates were purely so that we didn’t accidentally tow guests’ vehicles and we could call someone who was blocking the fire lane.
- JorgeGT 9y agoAt least in my country, Spain, guest data must be sent to the police database within 24h of his/her check-in.
- talmand 9y agoThis is common in many countries; whether official or not.
- chrismeller 9y agoNot just Spain. If you’ve ever traveled you’ll know that the first question you’re asked at a hotel upon checkin is “Can I see your passport?” I knew Estonia did, so I used that as a basis for a search. Apparently they requested basically an RFC from other EU countries on whether they do [1]. Of the respondents, the following require registration: Belgium, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and Norway. That’s non-exhaustive, I know from other sources that at least within the EU Italy does as well, not to mention countless other countries around the world. 1: http://emn.ee/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/466_emn_ad-hoc_query_on_registration_of_visitorsider_dissemination_en.pdf http://emn.ee/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/466_emn_ad-hoc_quer...
- horsecaptin 9y agoDo you have to provide your ID to Motel 6 if you were paying in cash?
- ghaff 9y agoYou may well have to. A couple months ago I managed to lose my driver's license (but not my whole wallet) on the way to the airport. Somewhat to my surprise, I didn't have a real issue with TSA. They gave me a very thorough screening but it wasn't really an issue. However, when I got to the Travelodge at SFO, they REALLY didn't want to check me in even though I had a reservation in their system. The only way I could persuade them was to pay cash plus a security deposit and to let them make a copy of my work badge with photo. Had I not had that with me, I don't think they'd have let me check in.
- talmand 9y agoMakes you wonder exactly what they think they are covering themselves from.
- ghaff 9y agoI doubt anyone could tell you besides "It's what our processes require." It's certainly not universal. I check into lots of hotel (probably the majority) which don't ask to see an ID. I do know if, as a business, you handle this sort of situation much worse than the TSA does, you're probably doing something wrong.
- vijayr 9y agoMy experience is similar to your parent comment - I've never been able to check into a hotel without showing photo ID (I never paid cash btw, always credit card, always in advance and in many cases had the print out of the booking). Same for hip boutique hotels and motels. There was a free street concert - even for that the road was blocked on both sides and only those with valid IDs could get in. So yeah, maybe not universal but it happens enough to be a hassle.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoWouldn't adhering to the privacy policy potentially make them guilty of conspiracy (in harboring people in the U.S. illegally), in cases where they suspected it was happening? (I'm a bit sketchy regarding what aspects of being in the U.S. without a valid visa are considered violations of criminal law, and if/when that distinction even matters.)
- Cyberdog 9y agoIf ICE agents suspect criminal activity, they can get a damned warrant like they're supposed to.
- talmand 9y agoSo then they just need a judge to grant a daily warrant and a fed walks up to the front desk every day to request the list.
- FireBeyond 9y agoNo, instead we should all be required to report our interactions to three letter agencies, just so they have a "helping hand" with locating (suspected) criminals...?
- talmand 9y agoThat's already required in many places whether people realize it or not.
- rsynnott 9y agoWill a judge grant a warrant for what's basically a fishing expedition (it's not like they're looking for a named person), for thousands of hotels, every day? I'd be very surprised.
- talmand 9y agoAlmost all search warrants are fishing expeditions in one way or another. If they knew for a fact that whatever the search is for is at the location, such as visual identification, then most likely probable cause would cover it. Doesn't have to be thousands of hotels, just the hotels commonly identified as popular with illegals. Once that well dries up you find a new one. Would it happen? Probably not, but would depend on the local situation.
- ryanianian 9y agoShame on Motel 6 for not being transparent. But as a counter-point to how much hotels will cooprate with agencies, most hotels will also cooprate with their guests. You would be surprised what you can "get away with" if you're polite to front-desk staff. I've never given my license plate to hotels despite it being on many forms - I always just ask if I can leave it blank - sometimes they say it's their policy to ask for it, and I always ask if I can leave it blank, and a smile later and it's still blank. (Similarly, you can almost always get a suite upgrade by being nice to the front desk agent checking you in and by slipping a $20 when you first walk up. This also works for rental cars - I got a $30/day mustang once by giving the guy a $20. Saved like $1,000.) People with questionable immigration status may not be quite so daring or wish to raise suspicion by asking for exceptions, but it also kinda goes without saying that leaving any sort of paper-trail if you're proverbially on the lam is probably best avoided. edit: I realize this isn't about license-plates and neglecting to give an ID to a hotel may be harder, but my point is that you may be surprised at how lenient most policies are.
- eli 9y agoSending ICE a list of people with "Latino sounding" names is a much bigger problem than just a lack of transparency
- ryanianian 9y agoYou're right - shame on Motel 6 for being dirtbags and for not being transparent about being dirtbags.
- gnu8 9y agoI wonder if there would be a way to DoS them by sending phony lists with tens of thousands of machine generated latino sounding names.
- talmand 9y agoI'm sure there would be if you're willing to be on the hook for a series of potential felonies.
- tomc1985 9y agoThis was old news a dozen years ago if you've worked hospitality nearby a place that does this
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoI guess we now know who they were really leaving the light on for.
- a3n 9y agoWe'll leave the jail house light on for you.
- supermatt 9y agoWhat an absolute shitter the legal system is over there. Share information requested by legal officials, get sued by the government. Don't share information requested by legal officials, get detained. Maybe it should be the officials asking for this information who should be getting prosecuted. Edit: This is how it looks to an outsider, I guess its more nuanced than that - but it should be black and white.
- rayiner 9y agoThere are two different independent governments involved. One is conservative and wants aggressive illegal immigration enforcement. The other is liberal and wants to prevent such enforcement from affecting legal immigrants and citizens. Each is sovereign and independent to a degree. It's the same thing with marijuana. Legal in many states, but illegal under federal law.
- supermatt 9y agoThanks for the explanation. It sounds like the legal equivalent of doublethink, How confusing :(
- lerie82 9y agoAwesome, I guess. I really don't see a problem with this.
- kstrauser 9y agoLittle Joey Sanchez was born in Iowa to 3rd generation native-born American citizens. Why should Joey be subject to any more scrutiny than his neighbor, Tom Smith, just because his last name is less Anglo? I’d be livid if I got hassled everywhere I went simply because German last names are out of vogue this year. You can bet Joey feels the same.
- fishcolorbrick 9y agoThe problem is that mixing business and law enforcement, so that quotidian commercial transactions become opportunities for criminal investigation, can and historically has lead to unintended consequences. Quoting from a below comment: > Replacing "undocumented immigrant" with "jew" or "same-sex couple" or "interracial couple" or "movie torrent pirate"... surely one of those substitutions triggers a reaction in even the most law-and-order out there. > And most of those categories have been illegal in some states in the US's history.