12 ms·
I know I trust Apple[1] and all that but I (tin-foil hats on) don't like the system on a system stuff going on. I don't like closed systems that I have no overs
by gigatexal 9y ago
I know I trust Apple[1] and all that but I (tin-foil hats on) don't like the system on a system stuff going on. I don't like closed systems that I have no oversight into, into what they might be logging, etc. The industry will likely follow Apple here and it's not too much of an issue given how low volume that iMac Pro is going to be but this could trickle down into macbooks and that'd be sketchy. I should just go hide in my bunker and build linux from scratch on a fully GNU open laptop -- alas that's not practical.
[1] more so than Google because Google uses my data and habits to sell me ads and sell that data to their customers, Apple wants to sell me gadgets and songs and movies, if that changes I'll drop Apple
- danielrhodes 9y agoYes after a full source code review. :-P Like it or not, you have to place trust somewhere. Maybe it’s not Apple, but pretending one has full visibility over every system is just going to create cognitive dissonance.
- lisper 9y agoAt least with Linux I can do a code review. Or hire someone I trust to do it for me. With a closed system that is not an option.
- willstrafach 9y agoYou can reverse engineer the firmware files though. I do this very often when new versions of iOS are released.
- jdc0589 9y agoI mean yea, but this is about a processor and related microcode. It sucks, but there literally is no real mainstream opensource audit-able option for the consumer market right now.
- lisper 9y agoThere's this: https://www.sifive.com/products/risc-v-core-ip/ https://www.sifive.com/products/risc-v-core-ip/ Not quite ready for prime-time, but it's a big step in the right direction. At least there's hope for future.
- scarface74 9y agoSo you can do a code review on the entire Linux codebase and you are skilled enough to find any security vulnerability? Can the person you hire do it? Would they have found the Heartbleed issue that was in open source code for at least two years?
- lisper 9y ago> So you can do a code review on the entire Linux codebase and you are skilled enough to find any security vulnerability? My odds there are much better than they are trying to do a similar audit on MacOS. > Can the person you hire do it? There are people out there who are extraordinarily skilled at this sort of thing. Security flaws in, say, iOS are found regularly. That's how jailbreaks work. (And, BTW, the fact that Apple doesn't give me the option of opening up the jail on my own phone means that if I want this freedom I have no choice but to run some black-box binary from some unknown Chinese hackers. That is by far the biggest security risk I face when using Apple products and it is a direct result of their policies.) > Would they have found the Heartbleed issue that was in open source code for at least two years? They did find it, and I didn't even have to pay them. If I had paid someone to look, they might have found it sooner. No system will ever be perfect. But I like my odds on Linux much better than on Apple.
- scarface74 9y agoMy odds there are much better than they are trying to do a similar audit on MacOS. Based on what metrics? Someone skilled in Assembly can and has found many vulnerabilities in closed source software. The chance of you as an individual being able to audit the entire Linux codebase and finding a new vulnerability are nil unless you have some special skills that you haven't mentioned that make you better than some of the top hackers and researchers. There are people out there who are extraordinarily skilled at this sort of thing. Security flaws in, say, iOS are found regularly. Despite the fact that is closed. How does that support your point that "open" software is easier to find vulnerabilities. You said that you could hire someone to audit the code, could you afford them? That's how jailbreaks work Without the code being open... (And, BTW, the fact that Apple doesn't give me the option of opening up the jail on my own phone means that if I want this freedom I have no choice but to run some black-box binary from some unknown Chinese hackers. That is by far the biggest security risk I face when using Apple products and it is a direct result of their policies.) Apple has the source code for all of the chips they use and they had a hand in designing most of them. As opposed to the random Android manufacturer who outsources their chips and the manufacturers give the OEMs binary blob drivers. Even Google said they couldn't upgrade one of their devices because they couldn't get drivers for one of their chips. Do you really run your Android phone with all open source software that you compiled and installed yourself? Including the various drivers? Have you audited all of it? They did find it, and I didn't even have to pay them. If I had paid someone to look, they might have found it sooner. And they've also found bugs in close Software and if you pay someone enough they could find stuff too. No system will ever be perfect. But I like my odds on Linux much better than on Apple. Based on what objective metrics?
- darpa_escapee 9y agoEven with Linux on an open system, you're going to be hard pressed to get access to the source code for all of the controllers in your system.
- valuearb 9y agoHow did you audit your intel CPU the last 10 years?
- lisper 9y agoI didn't because I can't (obviously) and this is a real problem, which I am trying to solve by building my own hardware to act as a root of trust: https://sc4.us/hsm/ https://sc4.us/hsm/
- walterbell 9y agoWebsite mentions fully open hw+sw, is this public?
- lisper 9y agoDepends on what you mean. The code is all open source, and the hardware is all off-the-shelf. But the board design has not been released. If you really want it drop me a line and we can probably work something out.
- criddell 9y agoI've heard the argument before that you are better off reviewing a disassembled binary than the original source code because you are going to be influenced by layout, variable names, and comments which could mislead you.
- specialist 9y agoThe only system I trust is mutual distrust. Where competing beligerents beat the tar out of each other. The US Govt’s Constitutional balance of powers (executive vs legislature vs courts) is based on this principle. It seems to be the best available solution found thus far. Note: I am an Apple fan boy. Source: Am also an election integrity activist, which greatly informs my views on trust, privacy, security, transparency, accountability.
- dkonofalski 9y agoI agree with you entirely, except in the case of Apple. I don't like closed systems either, especially when it comes to security, but, for some reason, I trust that when Apple closes a system, it's for security reasons. Their history with the Secure Enclave on iOS devices has given me a track record of security that I trust and, although it's still a closed system, the fact that they release white papers on every secure system gives me far more confidence than closed systems distributed by other companies. I won't trust the industry when this becomes the norm but, until Apple does something to violate my trust, they've made it a point to earn trust when it comes to privacy and security.
- gigatexal 9y agoI know and that's why I still buy their stuff but as soon as that trust is broken it's a firesale on hardware over at gigatexal's. I mean they are a corporation with a lot of people depending on them for their fortunes, should the era of excess market returns fail or slow what avenues of revenue might they turn to next? I think perhaps it was a huge deposit in terms of trust when they left Google's mapping service for maps to roll their own now that i think about it.
- SkyMarshal 9y agoWhat do you mean by "huge deposit in terms of trust" re rolling their own maps? Am I interpreting correctly that that was a good thing?
- newscracker 9y agoMy guess is that the GP meant “huge deficit in trust” and autocorrect or fast typing made that into “huge deposit in trust”. So GP is saying that Apple ditching Google Maps to roll out its own wasn’t a good idea at that time and eroded trust (on that topic, Apple Maps is still pathetic and comical outside of the U.S. and a few other countries).
- gigatexal 9y ago
- 3triode3 9y ago"I don't like closed systems that I have no oversight into" Whoa there, so you have insight into all those chipsets on your current motherboard? You know, the ones that are outside the CPU, made by third parties and control your audio, communications, video, networking, etc?
- fermienrico 9y agoYup, I don't get the GP's comment. You have two systems: A) T2 SOC B) Multiple chipsets working on its own. In both cases, it is a closed system.
- kogepathic 9y ago> You have two systems: A) T2 SOC B) Multiple chipsets working on its own. In both cases, it is a closed system. Sorry but I have to disagree with that. In the latter case, it's not a closed system because the manufacturers of the chips (Intel, Realtek, etc) have publicly available datasheets describing in detail how to configure and use the chips. This allows people to write their own drivers for the hardware. The article says the T2 is implementing, at a minimum: * RAID * Sound * Storage encryption I have yet to see a public datasheet from Apple describing how a third party OS like Linux can utilize the features of the T2. You can get chipset datasheets from Intel which describe the registers, how to configure them, chipset IO pins, etc. [1] Similarly, you can get datasheets from audio chipset manufacturers that describe their chips in detail. [2] Same goes for many other components in a standard PC system, such as the SuperIO chip, TPM, USB controllers, etc. What Apple is doing is making more and more of their hardware proprietary, and (to my knowledge) not publishing a datasheet for these replacement components. This will actively harm anyone trying to run a non-Apple OS on the hardware. Sure, the component datasheets can't help you verify that the chip isn't doing something nefarious interally, but how is that any different than trusting Apple not to have any bugs or do anything nefarious in the T2? The replacement of components having publicly available datasheets with one that is a black box bothers me. [1] https://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/datasheets/6-chipset-c200-chipset-datasheet.pdf https://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents... [2] http://realtek.info/pdf/ALC888_1-0.pdf http://realtek.info/pdf/ALC888_1-0.pdf
- epmaybe 9y agoHasn't this already been in MacBooks in the form of a T1 chip? For the touch id?
- saagarjha 9y agoYes, but the T2 has much more control over the boot process and hardware. The T1 was relatively isolated, communicating with the rest of the computer only for Touch Bar related stuff, and verifying data in the Secure Enclave.
- Dunedan 9y agoNot entirely true. The T1 also controls the FaceTime camera, TouchID and probably parts of SMC functionality (ambient light sensor), although that last one still has to be confirmed.
- saagarjha 9y agoTouchID is part of the Secure Enclave along with Apple Pay and the keychain. I’d expect the FaceTime camera is wired up to it for security, to prevent access from malicious programs. Is the ambient light sensor used for controlling the brightness of the Touch Bar?
- Dunedan 9y agoWhen using macOS the ambient light sensor is afaik only used for the brightness of the keyboard backlight. The brightness of the TouchBar isn't related to ambient light and just depends on the usage of the MacBook Pro. In use it's simply on with full brightness, after 1 minute of inactivity it dims to a certain level, before shutting off the TouchBar completely 15 seconds later. While macOS doesn't allow to customize these timeouts, the experimental Linux driver [1] does. [1]: https://github.com/roadrunner2/macbook12-spi-driver https://github.com/roadrunner2/macbook12-spi-driver
- epmaybe 9y ago
- m3kw9 9y agoThe risk of getting found out is huge and Apple isn’t gonna do that. I would think any half decent security research can detect if encrypted data is being sent somewhere when they are not supposed to and report it to the public
- fjsolwmv 9y agoGoogle displays Ada for money. It doesn't sell your data, it rents out your eyeballs
- revelation 9y agoThere is an ARM processor in your SSD
- toasterlovin 9y agoMight I suggest that Apple has a sealed off part of the system because they need something they can trust completely and they don't feel like they can trust Intel?
- Shivetya 9y agowell it is sealed off from us and Intel, but do any US security agencies have their hands in there? How would we know?
- reaperducer 9y agoConsidering the number of times US security agencies go to court to force Apple to give them locked up information, fail, and then go to third-parties to extract the information, I'd say we're safe. For now.
- baq 9y agoit's interesting that a default argument vs Intel is very unpopular vs Apple. i don't see any reason what that should be; if anything, both should be under the same scrutiny for doing basically the same thing.
- toasterlovin 9y agoreaperducer said it well: > Considering the number of times US security agencies go to court to force Apple to give them locked up information, fail, and then go to third-parties to extract the information, I'd say we're safe. For now. Apple has earned their reputation the hard way.
- FireBeyond 9y agoAnd when we're not safe, it will be too late, if you want to take that argument to its conclusion.
- b1daly 9y ago
- lucideer 9y ago> I should just go hide in my bunker and build linux from scratch on a fully GNU open laptop -- alas that's not practical. I'm hopeful that this is at least becoming slowly more practical for some (more technical) people. Open hardware is the big blocker, but there at the very least seems to be much more mainstream popular interest in projects like System76's un-ME'd machines and similar initiatives then there was, say, 10 years ago. Baby steps. As for building Linux from scratch, while I have quite happily used Gentoo for a while in the past, I think I'd echo some other commenters here on personally auditing every line of open source code: if you're not doing that, distrusting checksummed precompiled binaries is a somewhat odd distinction. The main differentiator is that the code is "auditable", not necessarily that it's actually been audited (see OpenSSH). If it's auditable, I consider that to be a not-absolute-but-still-significant improvement over closed systems.
- confounded 9y ago> I'm hopeful that this is at least becoming slowly more practical for some (more technical) people. I would say that it is, and not just for the technical. Putting Ubuntu on a laptop more than 6 months old is now trivial, and (given a non-exotic WiFi card) works fine. The problem is people being used certain to proprietary apps (Adobe Creative Suite/Cloud, Excel etc.). The primary problem however, is that for the ordinary user, there’s little benefit to free software, assuming the machine is new enough to be performant, or the user is wealthy enough to replace it. I’ll be interested to see if this changes when all the wonderful TPMs and for-your-own-good black-boxes start to get used for DRM.
- lucideer 9y ago> not just for the technical I was mainly referring to putting Gentoo on a free-hardware* machine, so I don't think that would be recommendable to non-technical users for some time, but otherwise, yeah, agree with all your points. Especially about buying new machines - Linux is very much a real benefit when hardware isn't considered disposable. * which doesn't really exist in full, yet, but there's seems to be some initiatives gaining momentum.
- jmull 9y ago> ...I (tin-foil hats on) don't like the system on a system stuff going on. These inner systems all already exist in modern devices. Here Apple is consolidating them into their T2, but you're going to be trusting all kinds of firmware regardless.
- unethical_ban 9y agoYeah, I don't understand the parent post. We have ASICs all over the computer - network offload, sound, IPC, etc.
- dsacco 9y ago> I don't like closed systems that I have no oversight into, into what they might be logging, etc. I’m going to be generous and assume you’re both diligent and technically competent enough to inspect all the security-relavant open software you run - henceforth I’ll speak more generally of you as an arbitrary person. If we take your view in the abstract, it’s incorrect. In the abstract, you do not have any more oversight over open source software than you do closed source software. You could have that oversight, in the same sense that you could run a 5K everyday, but if we’re being realistic, you do not. In theory this perspective makes sense (“many eyes make all bugs shallow”), but in practice virtually no one actually examines what their open software software does, which means it’s not actually very helpful - you don’t have very many people picking up the slack for you either. This provides a false sense of security in my experience, because we’re talking about the world as we’d like it to be, not as it actually is. What I usually observe is a curve - the modal company’s software is less secure than a large open source project, but once a company’s software has any appreciable fraction of comparable open source software (i.e. the company matures), the curve flips and the commercial software is more secure. From what I can tell this happens for two reasons: 1) once open source software hits a certain critical complexity point, it becomes exceedingly difficult to review effectively, and 2) the best and most qualified people for this work can get paid significant, double-take amounts of money for doing it, and are almost entirely employed by large companies. The result is that software like iMessage is some of the most secure that exists in its category, which essentially no fully open source solution can hope to compete with, because it simply lacks the same organizational direction and experienced talent working on it. I think a small subset of all open source software has something close to idyllic security and organizational direction, typically the software used by sufficiently many people that real talent is drawn to look at it too. Project Zero looks at software like this. Beyond that, there is an extremely long tail of open source software projects (approximately all of them) which are used by a nontrivial number of people but which 1) will never receive a serious security assessment, and 2) will be more insecure in perpetuity than commercial alternatives once those alternatives have had 1 - 2 competent security reviews. Before those reviews, I’d say it’s probably a toss up of two equally suspect options. In any case, the reason I’m responding with all of this is because it’s something I see pretty commonly repeated that I think doesn’t reflect reality. I hate to be so maximally capitalist about this, but if you’re optimizing your software for security, you probably want to use something produced by the resources of a large company. The best of both worlds is obviously a mature open source project officially developed and sponsored by a large company, but when that fails, I would personally choose closed-source solutions most of the time.
- madeofpalk 9y agoWhat’s the difference between this, and all the myriad of component controllers that are on previous computers?
- Tloewald 9y agoRead TFA
- madeofpalk 9y agoI did the first time I commented, and I don’t understand the difference between trusting dozens of vendors of closed, proprietary subsystems, compared to just one. In my mind, it’s ‘better’ to have to trust less people?
- kilon 9y agoOpen source visibility is hugely exaggerated, are you going to read one million lines of code or more ? You think others will do when every open source project struggles to even find contributors to fix small bugs ? Sure its more visible than closed source, no question, but still it's no angel. Apple is no angel either but at least they do not pretend to be ;)
- zcrackerz 9y agoSure, something might fly under the radar for a while, but once there's an accusation of impropriety or a security hole discovered, anyone can look into it.
- fulafel 9y agoOpen source brings transparency when the publisher is not a malicious party, but a flawed basically legitimate actor that doesn't have reason to risk the reputation hit of hidden backdoors. People can then look at what the code does instead of relying on corporate spin.
- qaq 9y agoRight cause if they would have just used an Intel chip there we could sleep better at night
- JohnBooty 9y ago> don't like the system on a system stuff going on This was already the case, right? Previously, there were all these controllers (disk, I/O, cooling, etc) running only-god-knows-what-firmware from only-god-knows-who vendors, and now that's all been rolled up into a single integrated thing. I could see an argument that this is a bit of a security concern: "There is now one God-level firmware unit with multiple possible attack vectors! Own the USB controller, and get access to the disk controller for free because they're on the same chip..." but it's not clear to me that this would be worse than what we already had...
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoYeah, if you looked into it deeper you’d find that this is entirely to make the system more secure, not less. When this thing boots, every stage of the boot is cryptographically verified. Camera, microphone, payments, etc are all routed through the ARM chip and can’t be accessed through the CPU at all. Compiling Linux and not getting any of these features just so you can theoretically “know what’s going on” (as if you’re going to read the source anyway) does not really make much sense.
- pentae 9y agoSeems like a great way to stop the Hackintosh movement once every new Mac has this.
- bsder 9y ago> I know I trust Apple[1] and all that but I (tin-foil hats on) don't like the system on a system stuff going on. This actually isn't that different from what we've been doing for years. This chip is basically just a Southbridge (the standard x86 architecture catch-all chip) with Apple's shiny marketing behind it.
- sigi45 9y agoDon't buy apple if you don't like closed systems.