4 ms·
Being descended from royalty is less about genetics and more about the rules that govern inheritance amongst european houses. What matters to European royals i
by sandworm101 9y ago
Being descended from royalty is less about genetics and more about the rules that govern inheritance amongst european houses. What matters to European royals is first son to first son. Drop all the bastard lines (Fitzroys). Then drop all but a few female lines. Those with no sons can stay (ie the current QoE). Don't try to democratize an elitist and unfair system by suggesting we are all participants. Something like half of Asia is genetically related to Genghis Kan. That doesn't mean he would have ever considered them family. But given the genetic car crash that is european monarchy (google "Hapsburg chin" or Haemophilia in the UK royals) I don't want to be related to any of them.
>> You are of Viking descent, because everyone is.
No. The real vikings (not the TV ones) were almost universally blond or red-headed. If you are black, your ancestors were not vikings any more than my ancestors were Zulu warriors. The genetic lines merge further back than the existence of these named groups, making us at best related to them, not descended from.
- rev_bird 9y ago>If you are black, your ancestors were not vikings any more than my ancestors were Zulu warriors. This seems to be disproving a statement the author didn't make. He was specifically talking about people of European descent.
- mjmahone17 9y ago> No. The real vikings (not the TV ones) were almost universally blond or red-headed. If you are black, your ancestors were not vikings any more than my ancestors were Zulu warriors. I'm confused why you think "blond or red-headed" has anything to do with whether you have any viking ancestry. Just because my father is blonde does not mean I am. And the point of the article is that our lines merge much sooner than we intuitively believe. If you are black in any society that has had a mix of European and African ancestry more than ~200 years ago, you are almost certainly partially of European descent. Unless somehow all of your 200+ descendents avoided any sexual contact with any colonial. If you're of Western European descent, you are almost certainly of Viking (i.e. Danish/Norse) descent: they spent centuries pillaging and colonizing different areas of Europe (including England). Therefore, if you're black in the Americas, you're almost certainly descended from both Vikings and the ancestors of the Zulu (considering the Zulu were a kingdom from the 19th century, so you're right, it's unlikely everyone with European ancestors, or even everyone with African ancestors, is). If you're from any country that was a European colony more than 300 years ago, this is likely true, too. And remember, cross-continental trade is old. People from the African continent have been having children with people from the European continent for thousands of years.
- sandworm101 9y agoBlond/red hair doesnt make you viking. But being black or asian does make it extreemly unlikely, just as being blond makes it extreemly unlikely that your paternal great-grandfather was an african king. With the viking thing, mapping blond hair in the uk, along with family/place names, creates a diagram of the 1066 invasion.
- canoebuilder 9y agoAnd remember, cross-continental trade is old. People from the African continent have been having children with people from the European continent for thousands of years. One of these in no way implies the other. Do you have a shag with the baker every time you stop by the corner shop? You've been indoctrinated with the multikulti propaganda, try to extract the poison, there are people who can help. Asians and Europeans have admixtures with non-Sapiens human species, Neanderthals and Denisovans. Africans also have non-Sapiens admixtures, but different species. No Africans have Neanderthal admixture, and no Asians or Europeans have the African admixtures? Why? How does this jive with your thinly sourced theories? Whatever theoretical breeding patterns of this sort you want to propose, it is in practice entirely negligible. And like I said, I know it's not really you who is thinking and proposing it. You're just parroting your indoctrination. You can do better. We're here to help.
- dang 9y agosctb is right, of course, that your comment broke the site guidelines egregiously. If you do that again we will ban you. But I need to address a different issue about your comments. We've banned you for race war in the past and you're still posting such comments to HN, as well as using HN for ideological battle in general. If you keep doing this we're going to ban you again. It is an abuse of the site which destroys its core purpose. Neither we nor the overwhelming majority of the community want to see it here. Therefore, no more of this, please.
- sctb 9y agoPlease read the guidelines, which ask us to post civilly, and stop the condescension. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- TheCoelacanth 9y ago> If you are black, your ancestors were not vikings That is far too strong a statement. Virtually all black Americans have some verifiable level of European descent, so they would definitely have Viking ancestors. For actual Africans, it's less certain, but it's at least plausible that an African would have some Viking ancestors. The Byzantines recruited Norse soldiers starting in the 9th century. They would almost certainly have all had Viking ancestry since that was about two hundred years into the Viking age. There were some pretty significant Scandinavian settlements there by the 11th century. Even by the 9th century, the Byzantines had a lot of trade with North Africa and North Africa had a lot of trade with sub-Saharan Africa. If even a bit of interbreeding happened and spread some Viking genes to sub-Saharan Africa that would be plenty of time for them to spread to most of the population. Obviously, Zulu descent is much less common because the Zulu didn't show up until about a thousand years after the Vikings.