2 ms·
You misunderstood my post to mean I'm blind? And you're giving me this little screed to tell me I should wait patiently for 20 years until my turn comes, that I
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
You misunderstood my post to mean I'm blind? And you're giving me this little screed to tell me I should wait patiently for 20 years until my turn comes, that I can finally see like others.
Well, I'm not blind but I'm revolted at the idea that a blind person should wait for a quarter of their life to go by, just so somebody can recoup the costs of research that should have been supported by public funds in the first place.
>> Also, frankly, you yourself have contributed exactly nothing to the development of this drug, so I don't see why you should blame society for not having it available to you immediately.
The people who developed that drug were able to do it because they grew up in a society that allowed them to become scientists, by freely sharing the work contributed by others and the knowledge discovered by others (because science). And that, on top of every other benefit of living in a human society and not having to invent and construct every bit of science, technology and infrastructure from the ground up, on their own.
That is the secret sauce of how societies work: solidarity. If you take this away, you take everything else away with it too, including the benefits of having science and technological progress in the first place.
But, you say- all the technology and science will become free in the long run. Just wait. Well, some people are blind now. Why let them wait, when we can cure them already?
And if the blind men can wait patiently for 20 years to see the light, why can't the sellers of the drug wait their turn also? Let's set up a fund to collect $850k for each blind person who is cured, thanks to this new treatment. And let the creators of the drug get that money in twenty years from now. They can wait patiently too, can't they?
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> You misunderstood my post to mean I'm blind? And you're giving me this little screed to tell me I should wait patiently for 20 years until my turn comes, that I can finally see like others. No, that was the "generic you". > That is the secret sauce of how societies work: solidarity. If you take this away, you take everything else away with it too, including the benefits of having science and technological progress in the first place. No. That's how families work. Sometimes. Society at large works on trade. You don't get your shoes from the shoemaker for free, because he knows you need them and feels solidarity with his fellow human being. You trade money for the shoes, so that he can trade this money with a farmer for food, in order to eat. This same thing scales up to every human need, including developing drugs. Don't get me wrong - I wish societies were built on solidarity. Things would be so much better. But in the real world, they aren't - and this is the world we have to deal with. (INB4 open source - this is an exception which happens because there's essentially no marginal cost to software beyond time, and barriers of entry are low; pretty much nothing else works like this on larger scales.) > But, you say- all the technology and science will become free in the long run. Just wait. Well, some people are blind now. Why let them wait, when we can cure them already? Because we can't cure them yet without breaking other things. It costs too much to do it now, but we have a reasonable expectation that the price will drop, so it makes sense to wait a bit longer. It's kind of like asking why the country won't put 100% of its GDP towards healthcare. It technically could, but it would destroy itself in the process. > Let's set up a fund to collect $850k for each blind person who is cured, thanks to this new treatment. And let the creators of the drug get that money in twenty years from now. They can wait patiently too, can't they? That's... an interesting thought and maybe someone should bring it up with the company. Still, someone will have to bankroll that $850k x number of relevant blind people, and that someone may say it might be worth waiting a year or ten, so that the price is $85k per person. (Also, in a way, this is how credit system works.)
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> No, that was the "generic you". OK. Sorry if I sounded a bit rude, above. >> No. That's how families work. Sometimes. That trade exists and people exchange goods and services for money, does not mean there is no solidarity, or that there can be none. People -in capitalist economies- give to charity. They help each other with personal problems. When there is a natural catastrophe, they help each other. Public money is spent to help those in need, even if they themselves cannot contribut to the communal pot (e.g. with disability allowances and unemployment benefits). Public health and public education are also prime examples of this. I am prefectly aware that these benefits that come with simply being born into a given society are not universal. For example, I know that in the US, neither healthcare nor (higher) education are free. However, these are examples of erosion of solidarity, that have been strongly criticised and should be strongly criticised. >> Because we can't cure them yet without breaking other things. I don't see how this is the case. Where should public money be better spent than in healthcare? Also, btw, I'm really not convinced by the claim that "good things come to those who wait" (in this case anyway). There are plenty of examples of drug firms resisting the release of generic, cheap, alternatives to their proprietary, expensive drugs. There is Martin Shkrelli, who bought Daraprim, first in 1953, and hiked its price from $13.50 to $750 (per tablet). There is the Mylan, who hiked the price of EpiPen from $94, in 2007, to $608, in 2016 (Epinephrine was first approved for marketing in 1987). There are also examples of technologies becoming cheaper, but I'm particularly interested in medical technologies, not computers. I don't care if computer become cheaper and available to everybody. People can live without computers. They can't live without, well, without drugs that keep them alive.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI apologize for my tone in my initial comment as well. > I don't see how this is the case. Where should public money be better spent than in healthcare? R&D to make healthcare cheaper? It's an exploration/exploitation problem. Also, policing, education, administration, infrastructure, defense. Healthcare is a practically infinite money sink, so there have to be limits somewhere. Especially that beyond some point, it becomes cheaper to save an additional life through spending on e.g. policing than healthcare. Don't get me wrong - I'm not saying everything is perfect in the way our society allocates resources - just that it's a bit too much to condemn it entirely for not providing a quality-of-life improvements (blindness is tough, but not life-threatening) for free, to everyone, just as they come out of the lab.