4 ms·
Science and technology make the world a better place - for those who can afford it. The rest can go get stuffed. I remember an old psychological test where you
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
Science and technology make the world a better place - for those who can afford it. The rest can go get stuffed.
I remember an old psychological test where you were presented with a scenario where a member of your family is sick and while there exists a drug that can cure them, you cannot afford it. You're given the option to break into the local pharmacy and steal the drug- and asked whether you would do it. The way you answer the question is an indication of your moral development stage. If I remember correctly, the idea is that the most morally developed individuals will decide that stealing the drug is not moral, that if everyone stole what they needed without regard to the interests of the original proprietor, there would be anarchy and society would collapse. So on the whole, the moral decision is to not steal the drug, even when your relative needs it.
Well, if society allows a life-saving drug (or, indeed, a blindness-curing treatment) to be unaffordable to those who need it, then that's already a society that is not serving its members' interests. What the hell do I care if society can support science advanced enough that it can cure blindness, if it won't cure my blindness? I'm expected to do the moral thing and sit nicely and not rock the boat- but others are not expected to help me, in my need? Bugger that for a game of soldiers!
A society that leaves people blind when it can cure them is just as useless as one that burns. So let it burn.
I'd steal that drug in a heartbeat.
Oh btw- in another article about this miracle cure, I read the ridiculous claim that blindness will cost a person about $1million in their lifetime, so the $850k price tag is justified. I don't see this claim in this article, but it just goes to show what some may consider "fairness": "blindness robbed you of $1million, now we're gonna take another".
- greenpresident 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heinz_dilemma https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heinz_dilemma The Heinz Dilemma is not evaluated based on your decision but (as you correctly note in passing) based on your reasoning.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoCheers. I was misremembering something about a Hans.
- astrodev 9y agoThe trick is to be among the first who steal it.
- dominotw 9y agoThat's what they said about indoor plumbing, air conditioning ect. Yea new technology is expensive to start. Should people not work on anything that cannot be made available cheaply from the get go.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoAs mentioned above, such therapies cost a few dollars to create and deliver. The price is artificial.
- dominotw 9y ago> The price is artificial. Isn't this a given?. Which product are you buying that costs the same as cost " to create and deliver"
- TeMPOraL 9y agoMarginal costs may be small, but the initial costs are large. Once the initial costs get repaid, and as third parties reverse-engineer the process, the price of the treatment will drop.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoIn a free-market R&D ecosystem, sure. The issue is, do we want that to be how it works. And its debatable how much of the initial cost should be loaded onto this cure, as the work builds on other work, and the technique will produce more interesting results in future. And in this case, does it boil do to publishing the dna fragment? Is this another 'patenting a number' discussion?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI don't feel we want that to be how it works, but I also have no good ideas of how it could work differently, while retaining the speed of discoveries.
- Amygaz 9y ago
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> Science and technology make the world a better place - for those who can afford it. The rest can go get stuffed. It's always like this and it's perfectly natural part of the process. You will not get the benefit of the newest invention today. But you, and many others like you, are interested, and so people will work to bring the costs down, and in 5, 10, 20 years, suddenly you can afford it. As heartless as it may sound - suck it up, wait for your turn. It will come. > Well, if society allows a life-saving drug (or, indeed, a blindness-curing treatment) to be unaffordable to those who need it, then that's already a society that is not serving its members' interests. What the hell do I care if society can support science advanced enough that it can cure blindness, if it won't cure my blindness? I'm expected to do the moral thing and sit nicely and not rock the boat- but others are not expected to help me, in my need? Bugger that for a game of soldiers! It's a fucking fresh discovery. Have a little patience! Stealing a drug in your example is not a moral thing to do because if everyone did that, there would be no drug, and no pharmacies. Unfortunately, in this world we're constrained by limits of physics and economics (i.e. basically how good individuals are at coordinating to do something together on large scales). Things take time. Also, frankly, you yourself have contributed exactly nothing to the development of this drug, so I don't see why you should blame society for not having it available to you immediately. Blame God, if you believe in one, for creating a shitty universe in which blindness and death are a thing, and in which we're left alone to solve them to the best of our capacity. And then be thankful for the good people who will make sure this drug will, eventually, get to you.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoYou misunderstood my post to mean I'm blind? And you're giving me this little screed to tell me I should wait patiently for 20 years until my turn comes, that I can finally see like others. Well, I'm not blind but I'm revolted at the idea that a blind person should wait for a quarter of their life to go by, just so somebody can recoup the costs of research that should have been supported by public funds in the first place. >> Also, frankly, you yourself have contributed exactly nothing to the development of this drug, so I don't see why you should blame society for not having it available to you immediately. The people who developed that drug were able to do it because they grew up in a society that allowed them to become scientists, by freely sharing the work contributed by others and the knowledge discovered by others (because science). And that, on top of every other benefit of living in a human society and not having to invent and construct every bit of science, technology and infrastructure from the ground up, on their own. That is the secret sauce of how societies work: solidarity. If you take this away, you take everything else away with it too, including the benefits of having science and technological progress in the first place. But, you say- all the technology and science will become free in the long run. Just wait. Well, some people are blind now. Why let them wait, when we can cure them already? And if the blind men can wait patiently for 20 years to see the light, why can't the sellers of the drug wait their turn also? Let's set up a fund to collect $850k for each blind person who is cured, thanks to this new treatment. And let the creators of the drug get that money in twenty years from now. They can wait patiently too, can't they?
- crusso 9y agoThe mistake you're making is in ignoring the consequences of the decisions you imply. for those who can afford it. The rest can go get stuffed. Originally, computers were huge, laughably simple, and could only be afforded by governments. Thanks to the investments of those governments, then rich corporations - computers improved exponentially while costs decreased exponentially. The rest weren't getting "stuffed". The rest are the beneficiaries of progress predicated by those initial computers. So on the whole, the moral decision is to not steal the drug, even when your relative needs it. This is a good example of where you have the ethical lesson at your fingertips. then that's already a society that is not serving its members' interests But then in the next sentence you throw that lesson away without solving the problem that the reasoning solved in the first place. The lesson is that you can't view the ethics of a situation in isolation. You have to consider the wider consequences of destroying the incentive for some to use their free time to research drugs and create inventions.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> You have to consider the wider consequences of destroying the incentive for some to use their free time to research drugs and create inventions. I'm sorry, but the incentive is right there: curing a person's blindness. Curing cancer. Curing HIV. Helping people live longer, healthier, happier, more productive lives. These are worthy goals and most scientists will at the very least recognise them as such. Most anyone will recognise them as such. But you're talking about monetary incentives. And that's the higher moral ground, is it?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoCuring someone's blindness, or cancer, or HIV, won't pay one's bills (unless the patient fronts you the $850k, that is). And by "one's bills", I mean the bills of the research team, the lab technicians, the doctors, people on the distribution pipeline, people who design, build and sell advanced machines and material that is used at every stage of drug's research and development, and people who test it all and independently ensure the new drug doesn't hurt instead of helping. The price tag isn't so high because someone wants to get really rich off other people's suffering. It's so high, because to develop a drug, we need to employ ridiculous amounts of resources of our civilization, in labour, knowledge and material. Until we hit post-scarcity, where all the basic needs can be fulfilled pretty much for free, money will be driving things. Those are the constraints under which we work today.