7 ms·
Google faces new discrimination charge: paying female teachers less than men
- Houshalter 9y ago>the technology company employed roughly 147 women and three men as pre-school teachers Three men isn't remotely statistically significant. They can't make any kind of statistical claim based on that. Second a gender ration of 1 male to 50 females is obscene. Tech is supposedly incredibly sexist for having a gender ratio of less than 2 to 1.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Second a gender ration of 1 male to 50 females is obscene. Tech is supposedly incredibly sexist for having a gender ratio of less than 2 to 1. Teaching, especially pre-K teaching, has long been held out as an extreme examples as a field extremely effected by unequal social gender roles, and one where that distortion is particularly socially harmful. And Google is pretty much dead average for pre-K teaching with this ratio.
- prepend 9y agoSo there’s some systematic bias in pre-k teachers that even the hiring officials aren’t aware of? What kind of programs can be put in place for gender equality in teaching? Is there some sort of National problem?
- ebikelaw 9y agoNevermind the merits of this case. I'm shocked that a child care that costs what Google charges pays its educators only $20/hour. This isn't a company perk, it's astronomically expensive. Much more expensive than my kids' private grade school, where the teachers are paid far more.
- sudosteph 9y agoThe way that it's presented in the article, I had assumed it was a free service to employees. The fact that it's not makes this even more frustrating!
- whack 9y agoGoogle isn't making a profit on its childcare, so clearly that money is going somewhere else. Better teacher:kid ratio perhaps.
- disfadbish 9y agoWhen I worked there a couple years back it worked out to around 40k/yr and had a very long waitlist.
- sudosteph 9y agoWow. $18 an hour, for someone with 5 years experience and a masters degree in early childhood education. I know she deserved the L2 salary of $21, but even that is terrible! A software intern will make almost double that with barely a data structures class under their belt! Seems like Google is no better than anyone else when it comes to using letting "market rate" limit the income opportunities of workers in "pink collar" jobs like this. Google could easily give a decent 55-60k salary to each skilled education professional that works full-time in their pre-k program. The fact that they would play games with this woman's economic well-being over a petty 3$/hr shows that they've coasted on their reputation as a good place to work for much longer than deserved. Hope they pay out well for this.
- mc32 9y agoUnfortunately that's pretty much the going rate, as I understand it from people who've been in that field. Some of the better ones may go up to 21-ish... Yes, in the bay area with years of experience.
- MollyR 9y agoWow the gender ratio is 1 male to 50 women for teachers! This would be a great chance for google to show the world how its done on equality, and have a google branded push for more males in teaching and more women in tech. It would definitely show the critics of hiring more women in technology, that it really is about equality.
- jdoliner 9y ago> It would definitely show the critics of hiring more women in technology, that it really is about equality. Given that they haven't done this does that mean that critics of hiring more women in tech are right in their conclusion that it isn't about equality?
- MollyR 9y agoI don't think so, because Google is primarily a tech company not a teaching company. However I'd be disappointed in Google if they didn't try to even out the gender ratio of the teachers and hire some more males as well. I can understand it would look like hypocrisy to some.
- goliatone 9y agoIm actually wondering if Google was using the number of employed female teachers to increase their overall male/female ratio... it seems like a 50/1 ratio has to have an explanation behind rather than pure chance
- MollyR 9y agoIt looks like that's a somewhat normal ratio for pre-k teaching. The percentage goes up for male teachers as kids age for some reason. http://www.menteach.org/resources/data_about_men_teachers http://www.menteach.org/resources/data_about_men_teachers
- T2_t2 9y agoThis will not be corrected. In an article about a position in which 1 in 50 employees is a man, the article includes the line "Across Google, women make up only 31% of employees." There are many, many tech jobs where almost all the qualified people are men (think high end security, really low level packet optimisation stuff, pretty much any extreme fringe skill). That means to address the 31% figure company wide, tech giants need to fiddle with the numbers in jobs where it is not mission critical, e.g. you can't get to 50% in security, but you can make sure that 100% of the cleaners are women. Of course, this discriminates against under-skilled men and massively exacerbates the gender pay disparity internally, but that is impossible to fix company wide whilst being defendable on a department by department basis (e.g. employees of position X irrespective of gender are paid equally), whereas the company wide ratio is fixable. Here are some examples of measures that could fix the 31% company wide figure quoted, without touching pay disparity: 1. Hirings in non-essential roles are to approach 100% female - think cleaners, admin staff, low level accountants. 2. Hiring in roles that support the essential roles are to approach 75% female - I'm thinking here of CFO support staff, account managers, project managers, anyone who supports people writing code. Why 75%? Because there will be some really good men that you can't afford to lose. 3. If a role is non-essential but predominantly male to the point an all female hiring policy is tough, just hypothetically here think garbage collection, outsource to another company. This removes these men form the headcount. 4. If a role is outsourced but could be 100% female hires, pre-school teachers is a great example, insource it. 5. Find ways to move more men from employee to contractor. This is a double win because while it massively inflates the unfixable wage disparity in real terms, i.e. what men are women are actually paid, it really changes the wage disparity on paper, while also fixing the 31% figure. 6. Create new divisions in separate entities whose numbers are not counted against Google employee numbers. Contractors on steroids. I predict we will see big tech companies utilise some or all of these measures. Last point on this, there are lots of ways to fix the wage disparity ON PAPER while making things in reality worse, and I fear these are coming as well. Most involve finding ways to better disguise male compensation - by changing it from salary to something else. More options, payments for extraneous things as a non-salary allowance (rent compensation, massive relocation fees, education allowances), pay higher bonus to salary percentages. That will be then end game here, sadly.
- dmurray 9y ago> Lamar, who worked at Google for four years before quitting in 2017, alleged that the technology company employed roughly 147 women and three men as pre-school teachers Sounds like affirmative action is drastically needed. Hire some men to increase diversity in the workforce. It's especially important to ensure men are equally represented in the more senior roles at level 2 and above...right?
- danso 9y agoWhy do you think affirmative action is needed?
- legostormtroopr 9y agoBecause only 2% of their teachers are male. Thats a massive gender inequality. Speaking seriously, if you want to normalise women in roles where they aren't you need to normalise men in roles were they aren't either. If more men go in to teaching, there are more roles for women to take up, or speaking in the inverse - if you exclude men from roles (such as teaching) they need to find jobs elsewhere, and thats usually in positions where men are the majority.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Because only 2% of their teachers are male. To be fair, they are at almost exactly the national pre-K average there. > Speaking seriously, if you want to normalise women in roles where they aren't you need to normalise men in roles were they aren't either. OTOH, given finite demand in each field, getting more women into high-paying professions that currently are disproportionately male should naturally result in more men in low-paying professions that are currently disproportionately female as a natural consequence.
- imustbeevil 9y ago> To be fair, they are at almost exactly the national pre-K average there. And Google's representation of women in software engineering roles is also around the industry average. To your second point, it's not either or. You can both better incentivize women in tech and men in teaching.
- ipsum2 9y ago(Ex)-Googlers, do you know if the daycare center employees are contractors or are hired directly by Google?
- DannyBee 9y agoAll the ones i've met had full time employee badges ;)