5 ms·
I have a power dependent workload that scales horizontally and is currently already dominated by the cost of system calls. This will effectively, directly cause
by dijit 9y ago
I have a power dependent workload that scales horizontally and is currently already dominated by the cost of system calls. This will effectively, directly cause me to buy 30% more compute on a huge infrastructure. (2,000~physical machines. Quite beefy dual socket machines with a lot of memory)
I know I’m not alone.
Then again. Think of microservices, Kubernetes for instance; Network requests are system calls.
- rbanffy 9y agoIf your workload has no code that's untrusted, you can safely skip this patch or disable it on boot. If not, at 2000+ physical machines, it may be worth to move some of that into kernel modules that would collapse a couple syscalls into a single higher level one.
- rogerthis 9y agoBut then you have to release the module as GPL, no?
- KingMachiavelli 9y agoNo kernel modules can be closed source; GPU drivers are a common example of a closed source kernel module.
- lmm 9y agoOnly if you want to do something that would otherwise be a violation of copyright - e.g. distribute the module to other people (assuming it's sufficiently entangled with linux to be a derivative work therof). The GPL only licenses you to do things that you otherwise couldn't do, it doesn't restrict you from doing things that were never a violation of copyright (e.g. privately modifying your own things).
- ufo 9y agoThe VM host will still have the patch applied, won't it?
- rbanffy 9y agoYes, but if it's your metal, you don't need to.
- dijit 9y agoGood idea. But it’s a windows executable and depends quite heavily on windows specifics. (In my case anyway) 30% overhead might be inscentive to revisit the assumption we can’t rewrite it for Linux.
- rbanffy 9y agoYou still can move some functionality to a device driver or something else that runs in the NT kernel space.
- maxander 9y agoWill you be buying Intel-based machines? Or will you be running a hybrid-architecture cluster now? I don’t know very much about computing on that scale, but I wonder if all the people selling off Intel stock are thinking this story through.
- lev99 9y agoAMD server CPUs currently outperform Intel on some multi-threaded benchmarks. This usually isn't a problem for people buying for peak-performance because you can always buy more CPUs to increase parallel programming speeds, but it's harder to make single threads faster. It's possible that the patches applied to fix this bug will cause some single-threaded benchmarks to change from Intel being the fastest to AMD being the fastest.
- myrandomcomment 9y agoSo for what it is worth my company has all Intel kit. We run servers that run docker. In each docker container we do build / test for our product. That is all we use them for. 1RU with 2 blades, each blade is dual socket, 72 total cores, 512GB RAM. We will not apply this patch as none of this is public facing and we do not want the hit to build / test throughput. The one big thing that this has done is we were looking at AMD for new servers and that has now become a higher priority on the to do list. Given our environment we care about the number of containers we can run, period.
- dijit 9y agoIt is overwhelmingly likely that we’ll buy more intel. Power/Watt has always been superior and AMD has to prove itself over time before we’d buy it. Not trying to kill expectations. This decision isn’t mine alone. You know the old saying “nobody got fired for buying Cisco” that applies to Intel too.