I think Matt's point wasn't that facebook was worthless, just that it's nothing special. There are definitely services besides facebook that will let you do al

I think Matt's point wasn't that facebook was worthless, just that it's nothing special. There are definitely services besides facebook that will let you do all of the things you mentioned (looking up a birthday, pictures from the bar, contacting a friend of a friend). In fact, you can do those things on pretty much every social networking site. Facebook just happens to be the popular one right now. When it first became popular, Google was a one of a kind. The other search engines have since caught up, but initially they didn't even compare. I think that's what makes a website really special, and that's kind of what I think facebook is lacking. There's nothing inherently special about fb other than the large number of people that use it.