2 ms·
That's fair, but it still entails additional trust in the host. On, e.g. Matrix, I can run my own homeserver, so if something evil happens on another homeserver
by nerdponx 9y ago
That's fair, but it still entails additional trust in the host. On, e.g. Matrix, I can run my own homeserver, so if something evil happens on another homeserver it's not really a big deal for me, unless there's a protocol vulnerability that allows them to mess with my own homeserver. Whereas on Signal, I might not even know if the centralized host has been compromised, and then as a casual user I have to wait around until a non-compromised host has appeared.
I get it, but I don't really get it. The argument that "federation does freeze protocols in time" doens't make a ton of sense to me. Just look at Bitcoin: people want to keep participating, so they upgrade. It's probably easier to get a bunch of scattered servers to upgrade than a few centralized ones.
- theptip 9y agoAbsolutely, it's a trade-off, and is probably strictly worse for power users. As a counterpoint to Bitcoin (which is still quite a young and under-adopted protocol), consider how hard it has proven to upgrade the IP protocol from version 4 to 6 (20 years and still not complete?)
- im3w1l 9y agoIp works at a much deeper level which is why it's harder to change. Everything uses ip, including hardware and software that's no longer getting updated but is still in use.
- theptip 9y agoWhich supports my point -- the quote "federation does freeze protocols in time" was being questioned, and IPv4 is the textbook example of a federated protocol that was frozen in time.
- xwvvvvwx 9y agoConsidering how the block size debate played out over the last few years, I'm not sure Bitcoin is such a great example of easy protocol upgrades.