3 ms·
On an organization's network, protecting resources from the user is a concept that makes sense. On personal devices, protecting anything from the user is a bac
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago
On an organization's network, protecting resources from the user is a concept that makes sense.
On personal devices, protecting anything from the user is a backwards and broken model that doesn't respect reality. It's the user's device, they should be able to use it any way they want. There is no need, or desire, to protect it from the user. What we really want to do, is protect the user's data from malicious actors, and getting in the user's way and annoying the crap out of them doesn't accomplish that at all (case in point: ransomware).
- oarsinsync 9y ago> On personal devices, protecting anything from the user is a backwards and broken model that doesn't respect reality. It's the user's device, they should be able to use it any way they want. I want to be protected from myself. I want my mom to not have to think about how she's using her device in order for her data to be safe. > What we really want to do, is protect the user's data from malicious actors, and getting in the user's way and annoying the crap out of them doesn't accomplish that at all (case in point: ransomware) Ransomware (at the time of writing) doesn't impact locked down platforms like iOS. I'm happy to lose that freedom in exchange for protection!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThen you should be able to get that behavior out of your OS if it is what you want. By all means, give yourself a web kiosk that runs on an overlay fs over a read-only boot media. I've set that up for people. Ransomware isn't a huge problem on iOS because, like Android, the permissions apply to the application, not the user account. That's a model that makes sense.
- acdha 9y ago> It's the user's device, they should be able to use it any way they want. Your mistake is conflating what the user authorizing with what the user wants. Nobody wants to install malware but millions of people manage every day. If blaming the user for mistakes was going to be a successful strategy we’d have evidence of that by now but since the opposite is true it’s no surprise that everyone is doing things which actually help people rather than doubling down on wishful thinking.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago> Your mistake is conflating what the user authorizing with what the user wants. Unless you are arrogant enough to believe that you can read the user's mind to know what they actually want, then the only alternative is that you end up with a system that can only be used for the narrow use case you imagine. This is probably why the Linux Desktop is only really useful as a web kiosk. >If blaming the user for mistakes was going to be a successful strategy we’d have evidence of that by now If user-oriented permissions were going to work we'd have evidence for that. Instead what we have is people being infected by ransomware that never needed a privilege escalation at all, because some idiot was so concerned with protecting the OS from the user they forgot to protect the user's data from malicious actors.
- acdha 9y ago> Unless you are arrogant enough to believe that you can read the user's mind Hint: reading the next sentence will reveal that you are not arguing against a point I made. > because some idiot was so concerned with protecting the OS from the user they forgot to protect the user's data Similarly, this is bizarrely wrong: studying recent OS developments would show a strong trend for protecting user data from malicious unprivileged code — and that every improvement has been met with people arguing that this is taking away users’ freedom. Security experts have been arguing for decades that it’s of little value to protect the kernel but still allow someone’s data to be compromised. The reason why the other work matters is that security depends on layers. If you put in a system which blocks the easy attacks, most attackers aren’t going to give up but will instead switch to more complicated attacks and social engineering has been enduringly effective. Facebook had to add a warning message for the JavaScript console because users were successfully being convinced to copy and paste code which exfiltrated their own session cookies!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoYet in 2017 we only have application level permissions widespread on mobile OSs, and we still bother the user to click "Yes" or run through a sudo prompt to do trivial OS configuration tasks. Not to mention that this entire discussion takes place in the context of a MacOS "feature" that literally makes it impossible for the user to change the OS configuration.