7 ms·
> It's popular to say things like some government employees are "folks who can't hack it in civilian life," but there's basically no evidence this is true. Hav
by pc86 9y ago
> It's popular to say things like some government employees are "folks who can't hack it in civilian life," but there's basically no evidence this is true.
Have you ever worked for government? I'm a civilian contractor in a software architecture role to a public safety agency in a state government. Half the "senior application developers" haven't written code in 15 years and don't know what a unit test is. There are maybe 2-3 individual contributors for each manager. Not team lead, manager, and is in a $105-110k+/yr position that does annual reviews, on call scheduling, etc.
The floor I'm on has 25-35 developers, DBAs, and BAs, and I can count on one hand the number of people who could get hired into a junior technical position at my employer. There are people who are unironically counting the days they have left until they can retire and draw their pension when they have more than 5 years left.
> Anyone working the counter at your local Post Office could easily work the register at any grocery store in your town.
And they'd take a 60% pay cut to do so, wouldn't they? Anyway, this is about folks in technical roles. Running a register and handing out stamps isn't particularly technical.
> Second, take a look at what happens to people who do leave the government. Very often, their salaries go up in the private sector. This is especially true for specialists like the folks who work at the NSA. Seems like they can hack it.
Well that's sort of tautological, isn't it? "The people who get a civilian job are capable of getting a civilian job." These folks are in the "Patriot, not inept" section of the diagram.
> Firing has little to do with it.
Firing has a lot to do. I've spoken candidly about my colleagues here with higher ups in the agency. They've openly bemoaned their inability to fire anyone, especially the people who they know for a fact do nothing all day. Those people are soaking up hundreds of thousands, even millions a year, in taxpayer dollars, doing little work of substance or value, and preventing their positions from being filled by someone capable.
- fineng123 9y agoThanks for telling it like it is
- zip1234 9y agoPayroll is the number 1 expense for government agencies. Easier firing would make a world of difference. I think the root cause is pensions. When people are tied to pensions for a retirement, firing people becomes a much bigger deal. Just pay a match into a retirement account and then when people can go, they go. Private sector pensions are for the most part long gone. Why should public sector keep them.
- pc86 9y agoPensions just don't make sense mathematically. If they're solvent based on the state's investments, then the employee is getting a raw deal compared to having just invested the money themselves. If they're not, then I as a taxpayer am getting a raw deal by helping to pay for someone's retirement because they worked for a state agency decades ago. My state starts doling out pensions at 5 years. A friend of mine worked for a state senator in the 90s for 6 years. He's got something like $1200/mo guaranteed during his retirement for 6 years of borderline political work ~25 years ago. I know it's a politically charged subject but I don't see why from an economic/mathematical perspective it's any better than moving the same investments to the market. Or at least if you're going to keep the pensions, only give them out for full service (20 years) like the military, and make it easier to fire a government worker for poor performance. I shouldn't be able to sit on my thumbs for a few years and have my mortgage covered by the taxpayers during my retirement.
- dmm 9y agoPensions make a lot of sense mathematically. If I personally fund my retirement I have to save enough for the "worst" case scenario of living many years longer than average. A pension on the other hand only has to invest enough for the average lifespan because the person who dies a week before retirement and collects nothing helps fund the person who lives to be 105. State pensions are in trouble because govt pensions are allowed to assume overly optimistic rates of return.
- maoistinquisitr 9y agoIf you're worried about living too long you can buy an annuity. It makes no sense for employers or the government to make that choice for you.
- majormajor 9y agoMandatory safety net/insurance policies make sense because what we know from experience is that if you don't have a mandated program, some people will blow it off. And as long as we don't have the political will to let them die on the street alone in poverty, it'll be very expensive to try pick up the pieces of the mess once they hit the safety net. Especially if that's something like hitting the ER needing tens of thousands of treatment to stabilize, before just getting kicked back out to the street. Or wasting people's time in the ER without medical need because the ER has heating and a bed and the cold winter street doesn't. Not everybody has family to fall back on in retirement, but we still don't want to let them simply die. So the money has to be given somewhere.
- moocowtruck 9y agoholy shit do you work for usps! you described my work environment almost to the T;
- pc86 9y agoState level public safety agency is about as specific as I'd like to be, sorry :) I'm sure if you trawled through my history you'd be able to piece it together.
- throwaway342a 9y agoYou hit the nail on the head. I've found that people can't grasp that there are a decent amount of federal employees that go to work and actually do nothing. I think some individuals take it as an attack on "big government" instead of a reality. Sure, it does sound a bit absurd if you haven't worked in that environment before, but people aren't exaggerating.
- wefwej2388 9y agoThere are a decent amount of private employees that do that too. Just because someone has a lot of money to "throw at a problem" doesn't mean they've invented anything new that has real human value. It's ego masturbation based solely upon "My culture says this is right." Like all this hodge podge rambling online about things we'll never actually operate on specifically because we don't have the authority to. We're just jerking off our own minds on HN
- Merad 9y agoI work at a Fortune 500 (non-tech) company, and your first two paragraphs are very familiar. I’m not sure why people often act like the government has a monopoly on lazy and incompetent people.
- pc86 9y agoIt's not something special to government, it's just that any place with a lot of red tape, a lot of organization/bureaucratic process, and where one person is a relatively insignificant contributor will have it. The problem is that for many government is the biggest example of that type of organization.
- moduspol 9y agoDo taxpayers pay for your Fortune 500 company's employees' salaries? These things happen everywhere, but in the private sector, that inefficiency only lasts as long as the rest of the company carries it. It's the taxpayer funding and political difficulty in fixing that make the incompetence of government employees more problematic.
- crdoconnor 9y agoThat's such a load of bullshit. If it's an oligopoly or monopoly in a market where the consumer has very little market power, you are just as unable to avoid funding this profligacy. I guess you could give up medical care, internet and having an education, but if you're going to do that why not just 'vote with your wallet' with your taxes too and move abroad.
- moduspol 9y agoThere are edge cases in the private sector where it is similar, but it's very much the norm in government work.
- freedomben 9y agoI don't disagree with your argument, but I do call attention to your opening sentence. > That's such a load of bullshit. Assuming you don't know each other and talk this way IRL, then it seems to me a violation of HN guideline 1: > Be civil. Don't say things you wouldn't say face-to-face. Don't be snarky. Comments should get more civil and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive.
- thinkr42 9y agoDo you think that some of the hiring practices are out of whack as well? I've heard it claimed that sometimes the government treats hiring as welfare employment programs - which adds a whole new spin on this.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I've heard it claimed that sometimes the government treats hiring as welfare employment programs There's two ways this is true in state and/or federal government: (1) hiring into specific programs which are essentially designed as welfare hiring programs (these aren't big today, but there are a few of them still.) (2) special, broadly-applicable civil service hiring preferences (mainly for certain disabilities and military veterans.)
- pc86 9y agoI've never heard it phrased like this specifically but there is absolutely a mindset during interviews that the applicant gets the job unless you can find a specific reason not to give it to them. To @dragonwriter's point the rules surrounding Civil Service are even more extreme. Here is a real world example of CS hiring procedures: 0. CS Commission sets a minimum written score for oral interviews. Score is arbitrary and largely designed to limit number of interviews to an acceptable number (20-30 total per vacancy). 1. Commission asks applicants the same questions, in the same order, asked by the same commissioner. Scores are subjective but on a 1-7 scale. 2. Does the mean score surpass the 60% pass rate? If yes, applicant moves to next step. 3. Does the applicant, in their background investigation or oral interview, admit to any explicitly listed disqualifying acts as listed in the Commission's rules & regulations? If no, applicant moves to next step. 4. The written and oral scores are averaged based on a prescribed weighted formula. This weighted score is 0-100. 5. Is the applicant a veteran? Add a certain number of points. 6. Give the top three names to the hiring body (varies by position). 7. Is a veteran in the top three? Guess what, they get the job no matter what.
- sanderjd 9y agoYou'd be hard pressed to convince me that someone who fought for their country in the military should not be preferred as a civil servant. It seems like a very strong qualification for these jobs.
- southphillyman 9y agoThis is more in line with my experience. A friend of mine purposely sought out a job in government for the job security. He seemed to have had a rough time in the private sector as he was always getting laid off/fired and generally seemed to never like his bosses etc. He explicitly expressed that he wanted a job where he could be comfortable working at his own pace without having to worry about performance based evaluations and such. He's now in government and seems to be doing very well financially.
- mozumder 9y agoWhy are people conflating "government work" with "NSA work"? It's like saying "corporate work" instead of "Google work". State level agencies are obviously going to be low-level dreck. The NSA is completely different, and has some of the smartest people on the planet. It's intellectually lazy (read: dumb) to apply an anecdote to everything, like saying "black guy committed a crime, therefore ALL black guys are criminals". Be smart and more deliberate, instead of being intellectually lazy. I've been in enough situations, both in the corporate and government sides, to know that each situation is unique. I worked at/with large companies (Intel, IBM), medium companies (Cadence, ATI), and several small startups, along with government (NSA/other agencies). They all have their own unique properties, and I can't say "huurr durrr government employees are all lazy" when it's obvious they aren't, just by looking at what the NSA does. It's always fun to see Google introduce a new product that the NSA already made years ago...
- someguydave 9y ago>It's intellectually lazy (read: dumb) to apply an anecdote to everything >State level agencies are obviously going to be low-level dreck. LOL
- Chaebixi 9y ago>> Anyone working the counter at your local Post Office could easily work the register at any grocery store in your town. > And they'd take a 60% pay cut to do so, wouldn't they? I wouldn't say the Post Office worker is overpaid just because of that. Private-sector pay for many such positions is shameful and exploitative.
- jacquesm 9y agoAnd at the same time we are arguing for basic income. It is not all bad, these people at least have an income and they allow you to make your income because of their incompetence. Chances are that if their employer could fire them you would not have your job either.
- snowwrestler 9y agoI have not worked in the government because I haven't been willing to submit myself to that level of inflexibility in my work. However, I know a lot of people who have worked or currently do work in government, up to and including innovation fellows at the federal level. I think you're responding to a point that I didn't make. I never said that government tech workers are top notch; in fact I know they generally are not. My point is that even if you could fire anyone with no process, you would still be stuck with the inflexible structure that government tends to impose on any employee. You would still have trouble recruiting. Why aren't you a government employee? Because it would be too hard to get fired there? No, because it's more enjoyable to work in private industry. Me too. Management basics: you cannot fire your way to success. You have to hire and empower great employees. Firing is about efficiency; but what customers and stakeholders really want is performance. It's like saying "my car is running out of gas--I better take off the roof rack." Cutting does not provide forward momentum. Fundamentally, people want to believe that the reason that government sucks, is because government workers suck. The reality is that government sucks because it imposes structural limits on the empowerment of employees, which harms flexibility and recruiting too. And those structural limits were put in place, because everyone thinks government workers suck! It's a circle of pain. BTW I would not spend too much time feeling superior to government tech workers. Governments waste a shitload of money on contractors too. And the rest of the tech industry tends to look down on government contractors about the same as government employees.
- jcadam 9y ago> And the rest of the tech industry tends to look down on government contractors about the same as government employees. Yes, I'm still a government contractor because after doing this for 10 years, nobody in private industry will touch me. Once you get that .gov stank on you, it seems nobody else wants you (the polite term is "not a cultural fit", which I've heard over and over and over again) :(
- logfromblammo 9y agoFiring has everything to do with it. It takes a herculean effort to fire one direct government employee. Replacing the prime contractor and their hundreds of employees and subcontractors' employees on a work order is much easier. I once heard some "war stories" from someone who had previously worked in a state government office, about the fistfights that broke out between government employees, and the difficulties in keeping malware off the boss-of-the-boss's computer as he routinely visited NSFW sites on state-owned hardware during the workday. That stuff simply doesn't happen in workplaces where people can easily be fired for gross misconduct. There's good money to be made in actually doing the work that government employees don't do. And that's why no one close to the matter makes a great deal of fuss about them not doing it. If the work needs to be done, and there is no way to force those nominally responsible for it to actually get it done, they can throw more budget at the problem and get a contractor. If you know enough about the problem to say why the direct employees can't fix it, you also know enough to do it yourself and get paid.
- JamesBarney 9y agoI worked for a large government organization and fortune 100 organizations that didn't specialize in writing software. And they were comparable, if not the government job was probably a little better done. I think in general large organizations that don't specialize in writing software are often pretty bad at it.
- nebusoft 9y ago> The floor I'm on has 25-35 developers, DBAs, and BAs, and I can count on one hand the number of people who could get hired into a junior technical position at my employer. There are people who are unironically counting the days they have left until they can retire and draw their pension when they have more than 5 years left. This pretty much sounds like the majority of fortune 500s I've worked for. Software Engineers started by being interviewed by non-technical managers, worked there for 20 years becoming 'Senior' or even 'Enterprise Architects', when at most they'd be very junior or intern level developers / engineers at my current employer.
- jcadam 9y agoI've worked onsite at a federal customer as a contractor (software developer). There appears to have been a big push over the last few years to replace contract sysadmins with civil servants (wonder why). So all of the good ones left for better paying jobs elsewhere, while the slugs converted into government employees. At first I thought the sysadmins were deliberately slow-rolling all of my requests, many of which amounted to running a single UNIX command... turns out they honestly didn't know what they were doing (I asked you to fix the permissions on this directory - 6 weeks ago). We've gone from: Me: Can I have sudo privileges so I don't have to bother you? Them: No to Me: Can I have sudo priviliges so I can fix it myself? Them: What's soo dough? I'm actually shocked when I encounter a competent sysadmin these days. "Oh, you made it work. You didn't break something else in the process. Wow." but it makes me sad because I know they won't be around long, as some company willing to pay for competent staff will eventually poach them.