3 ms·
Well, ISPs did not build their systems with equal upload and download in mind. There is no pure technical reason they couldn't have, but it was what they did. T
by cortesoft 9y ago
Well, ISPs did not build their systems with equal upload and download in mind. There is no pure technical reason they couldn't have, but it was what they did. To replace all of that would be difficult, and the large players in the existing system will have economic motivations for fighting any change.
There is a pretty good write up here: http://www.hyperorg.com/blogger/2009/10/03/why-up-is-slower-than-down/ http://www.hyperorg.com/blogger/2009/10/03/why-up-is-slower-...
- thomastjeffery 9y ago> To replace all of that would be difficult Not particularly. Symmetry is totally arbitrary. It's having the same amount down as before, while having more up that is the problem. > and the large players in the existing system -will- have economic motivations for fighting any change. That's the real problem. The solution is to give them an economic incentive to change. Average users wanting more bandwidth/symmetry is an effective way to do that.
- toast0 9y agoSymmetry isn't totally arbitrary. In many deployed access technologies, scaling head end send speed is easier than scaling user end send speed; sometimes there are settings to increase upload speed at the expense of download speed (ex annex M for adsl2), but sometimes it's an inherently asymmetric system.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoEven so, it would be a good thing for ISPs to change that infrastructure. That won't happen until there is a fiscal incentive for them to do so, so let's not be afraid to give them one.