4 ms·
Observation that corporations are already AIs and one of the worst kind (multiple, warring, environment altering, driven by survival) is interesting. I'd say t
by scotty79 9y ago
Observation that corporations are already AIs and one of the worst kind (multiple, warring, environment altering, driven by survival) is interesting.
I'd say that there is whole another kingdom of AIs that are apex predators. Armies. Corporations have nothing on them. Corp AIs politely pay taxes to armies and they use the resources to develop and restrict access to most dangerous tech.
We already had two top tier AI wars. And one cold AI war that almost ended everything. What saved us was apex AI survival instinct.
What corporations do is second tier stuff. They are herbivores of this ecosystem.
We are the plants.
Op's fear about corporations feasting on our attention falls flat on me.
I'm more afraid to become useless to corporations and by proxy to armies that being something they need for their survival.
If facebook needs me despite the fact I don't work for it and don't buy any of it's products is wonderful news for me, because it means I'll survive longer.
- wwweston 9y ago> I'd say that there is whole another kingdom of AIs that are apex predators. Armies. States, more explicitly. The insight that human organizations can be seen as superorganisms (and perhaps superintelligences) is right, and applies to states, businesses, municipalities, churches, etc. But the whole point of the insight isn't to be generally suspicious of these semi-alien systems that are generally more powerful than individual humans. It's to think more carefully about how to program and limit them, just like with AIs. One of the nice thing about at least one of the two state AIs in that cold war you were talking about is that people did/do think about this and we've ended up with a system fairly-well designed to operate with broad user input. It's possible it could use some improvement but it's probably better than a broad segment of constituent humans is prepared to take advantage of. Business AIs are generally pretty good at taking advantage of that, though. In fact, there's a credible argument they're exploiting features of the system to heavily influence the first tier.
- hyperion2010 9y agoThomas Hobbes Leviathan is the definitive work on this [0]. Modern nation states are living gods. For better or for worse, they are largely unconscious in their actions and relatively slow to move. When a state level actor achieves agency on timescales similar to individual humans, I think all we can do is hope that whatever process brought it into being has endowed it with a love of all living beings and a propensity to let the living expire at their natural time. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_(book)
- scotty79 9y ago> States, more explicitly. Not quite. States are just facades for armies. When state fails to collect taxes for the army it is simply replaced. I'm not so sure that peace between top AIs comes from user input. IIWW made armies realise they can't win a fight and they suffer trying. Thanks to that expeirience cold war was won by waiting opponent out. Humans in all of this were just cogs not the users.
- WorldMaker 9y agoI feel like Stross' observation applies here though: Stross maintains that before the advent of the corporation (AI) armies weren't so strongly self-regulating. The wars to which you are referring are after the corporations started to eat governments (and thus governments became corporations, to one extent or another, mostly by being built by and from corporations). From that perspective the Eisenhower Warning was at least a half-century or so too late; the military-industrial process built the modern army (not vice versa) in its AI paperclip-maximizing.