7 ms·
Just how many of his eggs does he need to keep in that one basket? Many executives receive very high total compensation, but structure it in a certain way as
by michaelt 9y ago
Just how many of his eggs does he
need to keep in that one basket?
Many executives receive very high total compensation, but structure it in a certain way as a sort of fig leaf to pretend it's in the shareholder's interests.
For example, instead of being paid $12,000,000 a CEO might pay themselves $2,000,000 in cash and award themselves $10,000,000 in stock. The fig leaf in that case is that it aligns his incentives with those of shareholders. There's totally not a principal-agent problem here, honest!
Selling all $10,000,000 of shares kinda reveals that fig leaf for what it is: giving himself the shares was never about aligning his incentives with shareholders - he just wanted the cash.
If shareholders' interests were represented competently and in good faith, you'd expect a very different incentive structure.
- ericd 9y ago>If shareholders' interests were represented competently and in good faith, you'd expect a very different incentive structure. I'm curious, what is the very different compensation structure you'd propose?
- michaelt 9y agoIf you're curious then you'd enjoy reading "Pay without Performance: The Unfulfilled Promise of Executive Compensation" https://www.amazon.com/Pay-Without-Performance-Unfulfilled-Compensation/dp/0674016653/ https://www.amazon.com/Pay-Without-Performance-Unfulfilled-C...
- ericd 9y agoLooks interesting, thanks! Could you summarize briefly what you were referring to in the parent comment, though? I'm not sure when I'll get a chance to read the book.
- mikestew 9y agoSelling all $10,000,000 of shares kinda reveals that fig leaf for what it is: giving himself the shares was never about aligning his incentives with shareholders - he just wanted the cash. That right there is the money quote for me that invalids my "pieces of flair" metaphor. You're right, the very best thing one might say about flipping the shares for cash is it's a bit crass; at best.
- elihu 9y agoDoesn't the board of directors usually set the CEO's compensation, not the CEO him/herself? Also, I don't think the stock is a "fig leaf" -- it actually is in the shareholder's interests that CEOs hold a lot of stock. I can't think of any other explanation why the compensation of (non-founder) CEOs is so high. I suspect that if a CEO were to refuse to accept stock it would make shareholders uncomfortable. The stock is what incentivizes the CEO to act in the interest of shareholders when those are contrary to the interests of employees or customers.
- mcny 9y ago> Doesn't the board of directors usually set the CEO's compensation, not the CEO him/herself? My understanding is that the board is just other executives and CxO from peer companies. Think Eric Schmidt on the Apple Board or the disgraced Citi CEO John Thank on Uber's board. Neither of them represent our desire to minimize executive pay.
- michaelt 9y agoit actually is in the shareholder's interests that CEOs hold a lot of stock Absolutely. So why do they let him sell it?
- elihu 9y agoBecause stock often makes up most of a CEOs compensation. Most people wouldn't want to have their pay locked up for long periods of time somewhere they can't spend it. So, companies like Intel can set up some agreement that says they can sell some of it as long as they keep some minimum amount.
- ForHackernews 9y ago> I can't think of any other explanation why the compensation of (non-founder) CEOs is so high. Really? Have you tried? As a thought experiment, imagine (just hypothetically, of course) that companies were mostly run by grasping plutocrats, and members of the same group of greedy plutocrats sat on the boards of their friends' companies, and set their compensation.
- yakitori 9y ago> Selling all $10,000,000 of shares kinda reveals that fig leaf for what it is: giving himself the shares was never about aligning his incentives with shareholders - he just wanted the cash. And the low tax burden. The capital gains tax rate on those shares are 20% while if it was income, it would be taxed at 39.6% fed + whatever the state/city taxes are. > If shareholders' interests were represented competently and in good faith, you'd expect a very different incentive structure. The execs interests align with short term shareholders. Not the long term shareholders. It essentially fosters a pump-and-dump environment.