3 ms·
Java was always a restricted platform. Sun's lawsuit with Microsoft established that. How? Even RMS/FSF don't think so http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/java-trap
by pvg 16y ago
Java was always a restricted platform. Sun's lawsuit with Microsoft established that.
How? Even RMS/FSF don't think so
http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/java-trap.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/java-trap.html
and if we went by their stringent definitions, most of us shouldn't be (ethically, by their terms) using computers.
Both the Microsoft and Oracle lawsuits and associated ickiness are about implementing things you call Java or run Java. I can't think of a case of anyone running into a legal restriction merely for using one of the many Java implementations however they please. I do remember the JDK license telling you not to use Java to control a nuclear reactor, is that what you have in mind?
- bad_user 16y ago> How? OpenJDK appeared in November 2006, 11 years after its introduction. Not an ISO standard. The JCP is really a closed process, and OpenJDK is just a bone thrown to the community ... if you want to get anything in Java, Sun has to agree with it, and because the trademark is owned by them you're not allowed to create a fork and still call it Java. Also having a certified open-source Java implementation that is not derived from OpenJDK is not possible, leaving projects like Apache Harmony in the dust: http://www.apache.org/jcp/sunopenletter.html http://www.apache.org/jcp/sunopenletter.html > Both the Microsoft and Oracle lawsuits and associated ickiness are about implementing things you call Java or run Java No, the Microsoft lawsuit was for a breach of contract. Google never said Dalvik is a JVM implementation. They did their own VM with a very distinct architecture + a compiler that converts JVM bytecode to Dalvik. Are you going to tell me that compilers that convert source-code from one platform to another are illegal under any license or law? Then projects like ikvm.net (jvm to .net translator), or Cobol2Java, or Mainsoft (which allows running .net projects on top of Java), or in fact any compiler that converts source-code to C, or why not the Scala compiler (it's not a JSR) ... should also be illegal?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pvg 16y agoNot an ISO standard. Oh come on. Are you going to tell me that compilers that convert source-code from one platform to another are illegal under any license or law? I neither did nor am going to tell you that. The Oracle lawsuit is obviously a screeching horror of patent law gone wrong. I don't think it or previous lawsuits really make Java a 'restricted platform' for the 98.703% case of its use.