10 ms·
Yeah, that's why I bought Equifax call options a little bit after the breach was announced. Made good money on those options, and it pisses me off. It pisses me
by mikestew 9y ago
Yeah, that's why I bought Equifax call options a little bit after the breach was announced. Made good money on those options, and it pisses me off. It pisses me off that after an event that should bankrupt a company such as Equifax, I lay hard-earned on the table knowing that I have an extremely good chance of a healthy ROI simply because of vested interests and status quo.
Like other political hot topics, this is one of those things that causes me to ask, "okay, then, how bad does it have to get before populist outrage brings about change?" Something worse happens, and this is the time, right? Nope. And so on from one event to the next.
OTOH, in this case maybe the invalidation of vast amounts of data will alone bring about changes out of necessity. There will probably be a rough patch of lawsuits, debate, and perhaps a new law or two, but perhaps it will eventually shake out something better.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> how bad does it have to get before populist outrage brings about change? We had a bill in the New York State Senate after the Equifax breach [1]. It was dead on arrival. Practically nobody called in to offer support. It was apparent that nobody's political career would be made nor broken by this bill. When it died, there was no press; nobody noticed nor cared. [1] https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2017/s1104/amendment/a https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2017/s1104/amendm...
- mehrdadn 9y agoI'm guessing most people didn't know about it to offer support? Seems like a failure of the press if they didn't monitor bills and bring awareness... That said, I'm not sure how much of a fix timely disclosure is. Maybe people thought it wouldn't go even remotely far enough to help a significant number of people and hence wouldn't be worth it. (I could even see it being harmful if it makes it less likely to get more serious legislation passed.)
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> I'm guessing most people didn't know about it to offer support? A bit of this, a bit of that. I was excited about the bill and offered to help. When it came to selling it, however, people were more animated by Trump, affordable housing and the MTA. Despite our obsession with privacy on Hacker News, it hasn't been properly sold to the public. > I'm not sure how much of a fix timely disclosure is It was to allow the Attorney General to investigate these crimes. Right now, there is no disclosure requirement. Unless the company reports its breach and co-operates with state Attorneys General, they basically can't be held accountable at the state level. So, naturally, they refuse to co-operate.
- gt_ 9y agoIs it the job of the press to notify state senators of bills on their own floor? I don’t want to undermine the value of public awareness and activism, but I think blaming this one on the press is a stretch.
- coderdude 9y agoI think he's just illustrating the extent to which no one cared rather than assert that the press is to blame.
- pslam 9y agoAs far as anyone can tell, the data from the breach hasn't been used yet. When that happens, it'll probably be the largest identify theft fraud ever, and if it's traced to Equifax, we may see an "adjustment". I'm still betting (small) on that happening.
- g051051 9y agoNot a chance. There have been too many other breaches, I don't see how there would be any way to tie a particular instance of potential identity theft back to a particular breach. And besides, how many more breaches will the be in the next 6 months? 12 months? Take a look at this: https://www.identityforce.com/blog/2017-data-breaches https://www.identityforce.com/blog/2017-data-breaches. That was last year...you think 2018 will be any better?
- coliveira 9y agoThere is no way to trace identity fraud directly to Equifax, especially since there are so many data breaches that this becomes just another one.
- g051051 9y ago> an event that should bankrupt a company such as Equifax That's a ludicrous thought. They were the victims of a crime, not the criminals. Should Target have been bankrupted? Or Home Depot?
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThe Target and HD breaches were of customer data. You can choose not to shop at those stores and be safe. You can't keep Equifax from handling your data without disconnecting from society.
- coldcode 9y agoNot mention I just saw yet another commercial where Equifax was selling a service to protect your data "on the dark web". Which they allowed go there. It's like a bank losing your money and then for a fee offering to keep other people from using it.
- g051051 9y agoAre you sure that wasn't Experian? I can't find anything from Equifax advertising that service.
- mplewis 9y agoEquifax is government-mandated extortion.
- mikestew 9y agoThat's a ludicrous thought. They were the victims of a crime, not the criminals. This is in no way similar to Target or HD, other than data were taken. The whole system upon which Equifax was built relied on a semi-secret number that cannot be changed. Those numbers, or at least the majority of them, are out in the open. There was a certain degree of trust that the person sitting across from you at the auto dealer finance desk was who they say they were, and that the report stating that they're good for a loan was accurate. That was not 100% true for a number of years, and it's potentially wildly inaccurate now. IOW, Equifax's sloppy work resulted in a broken system from where I sit. If you're thinking I'm wishing bankruptcy upon Equifax, well, I didn't write that, sorry. But if the shaky foundation upon which your business model rests collapses, I would expect severe financial penalties. But, hell, Moody's is still in business.
- cloakandswagger 9y agoI bought EFX after the incident and made a bundle on it too, but I don't share your outrage. Does the breach call for some punitive response? Definitely. Does it justify destroying a $14B company? No. That's an overly emotional, witch-hunting type of response. HN of all places should be sympathetic to what happened to Equifax; they neglected to update a framework which had a vulnerability granting full remote code execution. That's game over from an info sec standpoint, and how many developers here can state, with 100% confidence, that every library and every framework and piece of application code in their own work is totally bulletproof and will never fall victim to something similar? The breach should be used by everyone as a lesson, and as I stated earlier Equifax should receive some punitive action (arguably already delivered by the hit to their stock price and the public floggings from the congressional hearings). But saying that Equifax should be bankrupted by it, or that the executives or developers should be thrown in jail? Be careful what you wish for. Today Equifax, tomorrow you.
- rectang 9y agoEquifax should not exist because the credit system causes so much harm spread out over many individuals. That problem existed before the breach, and it is just as much a problem with Equifax's competitors as with Equifax. The breach only serves to highlight what malignant parasites the credit agencies are.
- cwkoss 9y agoI think the key part of the outrage against Equifax, and part of why it is more outrageous than most breaches, is not only was customer data revealed, but also data about people who want nothing to do with Equifax. There is no action victims could have taken to avoid this breach. In most serious breaches, there is a certain amount of "well, you have to be careful who you give your information to..." even though it's not the victims fault. This factor is not present in the Equifax situation. Equifax is allowed to hold and market a product based on data of individuals who never gave consent, but has no responsibility to protect that data or repercussions when they fail. Arguably this breach has put the final nail in the coffin for using SSN's as secure identifiers. Granted, it was a horrible and mostly-already-broken system to begin with. But I think that this flawed system was still worth in excess of $14B - and Equifax's negligence effectively destroyed that value. I agree bankrupting Equifax would be heavy-handed, but it would be nice to at least see some punitive action that would discourage such negligence in the future and provide an economic disincentive to possessing vast quantities of private data.
- lefstathiou 9y agoI believe people have a very rational reason not to support this because of the extremely dangerous slippery slope precedent it would cause. This would dramatically increase costs on consumers (they will have to pay for the risk of total anhilation of a company by being online), hamper innovation, create incentives for rogue nations to cripple our legal system by targeting large companies and watching them get fed to the American public. Who wants that?
- ubernostrum 9y agoConsumers already pay a huge cost. They just don't pay it up front -- they pay it later after the breach. And worse, the people who pay in many cases are people who were victims of the breached entity, but not customers of it (see Equifax, whose customers are other businesses, not the people whose data they gathered). Pricing this into the service from the beginning might well cause disruption to a number of industries, but that isn't automatically a bad thing. And "innovation" that consists of involuntarily inflicting risk and suffering and ruin on third parties is perhaps not the kind of "innovation" we need -- one might just as easily argue that laws against involuntary human medical experimentation "hamper innovation".
- platz 9y agoI'm guessing you got in on BP too?
- mikestew 9y agoMissed BP, but I did grab some United at the right time.
- grigjd3 9y agoPartisanship. There are no electoral consequences to moving on. So long as corporate interests have us focused on voting eligibility and who can have sex with whom, and whether there can be an abortion afterwards, no one is gonna vote based on this.