9 ms·
But the condition of poverty often entails one or more of these realities: a lack of income (joblessness); a lack of preparedness (education); and a dependency
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
But the condition of poverty often entails one or more of these realities: a lack of income (joblessness); a lack of preparedness (education); and a dependency on government services (welfare). A.I. can address all three.
Wow, and not in a good way. Reading that makes me apoplectic. My first instinct is to write something full of swear words and insults that wouldn't meet HN guidelines.
First, poverty is gendered. One of the things that drives poverty for women is the cultural expectation that we provide caregiving to our own children and other relatives essentially for free and that society owes us nothing for this imposition on our time and energy. There are other factors, but that's a big one.
The next thing that drives poverty is various intractable personal problems, such as health issues, learning disabilities and mental health issues. One thing society can do to reduce the degree to which such issues separate the Haves from the Have Nots is to provide universal health care.
Dependency on government services is driven in part by poor design of services such that getting on them actively cripples your ability to get off of them. This entire article sounds like a snide way to blame poor people for their problems rather than look for actual solutions.
I can't believe they say in the same article that a) jobs are outright going away and b) the solution for unemployed people is superior job matching services. If there are no jobs to get, you don't have a matching problem.
This is such utter drivel. Wow.
- Kamshak 9y agoHad a very similar reaction to this.
- dwaltrip 9y agoFriendly heads up: HN norms are that you simply upvote, instead of replying with a comment that basically boils down to "I agree" and no other info.
- justonepost 9y agoThese are fair comments, however I think it's reasonable to say that we need more automation in the home and personal care. Health Care, IMHO, should be solved by AI and Big Data. I'm a free market person and I believe if the government tried to legislate this, it would screw it up. Rather it should try to open the way for the private industry to create AI based health care solutions. I'd also like to see character based communities with minimal basic income. Ie, your economic output is not relevant, but rather your character. How kind you are to others, how passionate you are about your talents, how independent you are about looking after yourself. I think this is the real solution to poverty in a world of increased automation. I know some people want UBI without strings attached, but my feeling is that without some kind of purpose (even a non economic one) mental health issues will increase.
- randcraw 9y agoI have a little exposure to this space (healthcare), and I'm nowhere as optimistic as you that AI or big data will cure what ails us, especially on the small scale (each patient). Datamining is likely to help detect and clarify negative patterns in large groups (like when stents don't actually reduce angina). But doing the same to find positive patterns to shape policy seems to be much harder due to the wild variation inherent in individual patient response to each therapy. Existing therapy is refined via specific experiments which are not amenable to aggregation into large groups that can be 'mined' using AI or DM, thereby adding further value. It's not clear to me what AI can add to existing stat/prob methods here. Inversely, when trying to characterize patients using their raw data, I've found individual patient data to be so horribly noisy and so often mislabeled as to be useless for more than trivial purposes of individual trend summary. This becomes especially woeful when aggregating digital health records, and is likely to remain so for decades to come (given their current glacial rate of improvement). When it comes to the prospect of mining medical data to improve treatment, I can only say, "GIGO".
- king07828 9y ago>if the government tried to legislate this, it would screw it up Agreed. >Rather, [the government] should try to open the way for the private industry ... Disagree, at least in part. One source of personal frustration is the perception that rich techies who made their fortunes by writing programs without explicit government approval/legislation seem to spend a lot of time begging for government solutions (like UBI) or approvals for these problems without first attempting to use their money, brains, and tech with a little creativity to generate extra-governmental solutions.
- 111_1_111 9y agoIf you had a kid you couldn't afford to provide for, that's pretty clear evidence of a lack of preparedness. > The next thing that drives poverty is various intractable personal problems, such as health issues, learning disabilities and mental health issues. One thing society can do to reduce the degree to which such issues separate the Haves from the Have Nots is to provide universal health care. "One way we can reduce poverty is to steal from people who aren't in poverty and give it to those who are." Genius idea. I see a Nobel Prize in your future.
- GhostVII 9y ago> One of the things that drives poverty for women is the cultural expectation that we provide caregiving to our own children and other relatives essentially for free and that society owes us nothing for this imposition on our time and energy. There are other factors, but that's a big one. You have a source for that? I would think that the wage gap would be a much more significant factor than cultural expectations. And I would hope that people would provide caregiving to their own children for free.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThere are many sources. Off the top of my head, you can look for books, articles etc about the feminization of poverty, pink collar ghetto and the second shift. I have read far too many books (articles etc) over the course of decades to remember them all. And I would hope that people would provide caregiving to their own children for free. So would I. But why is it only women are expected to provide such care and are classified as gold digging whores if they think the father should provide for them while they do so and also provide some compensation into the future for the lost career building opportunities it costs them? Parents should both be responsible for the product of having gotten jiggy together, not just mothers.
- justonepost 9y agoThis is true, to some extent, and false to some extent as well. There are plenty of fathers who split primary care giving. Also, once children reach school age, primary care giving responsibilities decrease and can be split between parents more easily.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe stats I have seen suggest that full time moms do 60 hours of women's work per week. Working moms still do 40. To make up for the loss of 20 hours of women's work, men began doing an extra 10 minutes per day, or 1 hour and 10 minutes per week. Those stats are not current. Given the reactions I got from working women at a Fortune 500 company over the detail that my sons took over the cooking and cleaning, I have zero reason to believe we are anywhere near achieving parity.
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoEh. It would definitely help to have better tech that could point people in the right direction in their job searches. But I agree with you that when the real problem is a rising fundamental scarcity, a better breadcrumb detector is not the ultimate solution.
- mlcrypto 9y agoI bet in the western world more men are in poverty than women Wow such a chore seeing your own kin grow and learn
- rayiner 9y agoPoverty rates for women are 30% higher than men, and in the Key child bearing years its 50% higher.
- gowld 9y agoAnd social services / welfare are correspondingly higher for women.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoI don't see why you're getting down-voted. As the Nth level parent comment mentioned (n = too lazy to count, social services often form a positive feedback loop that traps their recipients at that level so it would follow that if you give women and children more social services you'll trap more of them at that level.
- rayiner 9y agoDepends on how you define "social services." Services directed at veterans, job retraining for manufacturing workers, support for small businesses, etc., overwhelmingly benefits men.
- __s 9y agoYou lose your bet
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dang 9y agoThis comment breaks the site guidelines. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and post civilly and substantively, or not at all.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throw47555 9y ago>we provide caregiving to our own children and other relatives essentially for free and that society owes us nothing for this imposition on our time and energy At least historically, what society gave in return was keeping women (for the most part) out of harms way when it came to wars.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoTrue. But the reason for this is because if you lose 90 percent of your men to war, you can enact polygyny and rapidly repopulate. But no matter how many men a woman sleeps with, it takes 9 months to complete a pregnancy. Whereas a man can father children on multiple women at the same time. Not does that alone justify keeping them in poverty.
- throw47555 9y agoTrue -- except maybe for the "at the same time" part; with a few minutes break in between I'll agree :) But yes, I agree also that it doesn't justify poverty. I think partly due to the inherent assymetries (like the biological one you mention), historically we have had a mix of advantages and disadvantages for the two genders. As the situation changes, maybe the "deal" becomes more favorable for one, less for the other. (e.g. Women are expected to work now, also to take care of children, whereas a chivalrous behavior towards them is worth much less in 21th century). The mainstream opinion today seems to be that the current "mix" is less favorable to women (I happen to disagree with this), but I think it is a good basis for a civil discussion, more so than the insistence on equality at all levels which seems unattainable to me. (EDIT: last few words added)
- neaden 9y agoHistorically wars frequently involved one side razing the others city and murdering and enslaving all of their non-combatants. Not exactly out of harms way.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe death rate for men in wars is far, far, far higher than for women.
- darepublic 9y agoIf you take one of the article ideas in isolation, i.e. using AI to match impoverished people with good, unfilled middle class jobs... do you object to this idea by itself, or just to the idea it would be a cure-all, oblivious to other social factors?
- rdiddly 9y agoYeah I kinda saw it coming with just the headline. The only thing needed, and missing, to wage "war" on poverty (inappropriate metaphor for 53 years but I'll go along with it) is the will. Not more data.
- isoskeles 9y agoFirst, poverty is gendered. One of the things that drives poverty for women is the cultural expectation that we provide caregiving to our own children and other relatives essentially for free and that society owes us nothing for this imposition on our time and energy. Where does the fact that more homeless in the U.S. are men than women fit into this for you?
- andonisus 9y agoI believe they meant that poverty is experienced differently by gender, not that it only happens to one gender.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThat's really complicated. One thing that drives higher rates of homelessness for men is that it is safer for them. Homeless women are at high risk of being raped. Women often put up with things men will not tolerate in order to avoid the street because it is the lesser evil. Of course, that isn't something most people want to hear. I am a woman and I spent 5.7 years homeless. It helped me solve some of my intractable personal problems. I am newly off the street and recently applied for my dream job. I hope to soon have the life I always wanted and could not arrange. I got it in part by taking the whole deal involved in exercising agency like a man, a luxury many women lack. But commenting on such things tends to not be well received. Men want to play their own victim card when it comes to that statistic and it is never acceptable to point out that there is an element of choice involved and the greater degree of agency generally exercised by men is a driving factor in higher rates of male homelessness. It sounds like victim blaming to a lot of people.
- ThomPete 9y agoIn more or less all western societies men are found in the top and in the bottom of society. I am perfectly fine with accepting that there is an element of choice involved if that also explains why men are found in the top of society. My experience is that many women will not agree on that but instead point to (if they are really stereotype feminists) patriarchal structures in society benefitting men.
- anonemouse145 9y ago"Vast majority of homeless are men, women most affected, news at 9."
- bbctol 9y agovast majority of poor people are not homeless, the world is complicated
- wetpaws 9y agoPoverty is gendered, but it is not female gender. If you walk any major US city in the evening, you can clearly see what gender it actually is.
- thephyber 9y agoHomelessness is not the only form of poverty. I would argue that long-term homelessness is only a small slice of the pie. Furthermore, women are probably more likely to get an offer (and accept an offer) for welfare assistance than men. Parents with children are probably far more likely to receive assistance than individuals.
- wetpaws 9y ago>more likely for welfare assistance than men I don't see how it cancels my argument other than highlighting even bigger wealth distribution imbalance in favor of women.
- ams6110 9y agoThe biggest predictor of poverty for women is marital status. Families headed by a single female have a poverty rate over five times higher than married couple families. http://federalsafetynet.com/us-poverty-statistics.html http://federalsafetynet.com/us-poverty-statistics.html
- c22 9y agoAnd, according to that data, twice that of single dads, which seems like a more apt comparison.
- throwaway30yo 9y agoNot that simple though, Courts favour giving custody to Women. The men who do get custody generally have to have more of their affairs in order (job, housing, stability). So its not surprise when a man gets custody he is in a better financial position.
- SpliffnCola 9y agoExactly. My mother cheated on my father; she got custody of us and had to be both mother and father while also growing up in poverty. She also demonized him to us as if it was his fault for leaving her. Her cheating also made a head while she was both dating my current step-dad and another man who could also have ended up as my step-dad. Needless to say, I have a hard time with relationships because my mother's have been extremely out of the norm.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoNeedless to say, I have a hard time with relationships because my mother's have been extremely out of the norm. I am very sorry for what you suffered. For some years, I read as much scholarly info as I could on infidelity. In a nutshell: Infidelity doesn't destroy a relationship. Instead, it grows out of serious problems within the relationship. I hope you find a means to heal.
- whiddershins 9y agoJust so we can start with a more precise base statement: 2 minutes of googling seems to show that adult women’s poverty rate is around 20-30% higher than men’s.
- WhitneyLand 9y agoGlad to find others here who had a negative impression of the article. Wasn’t sure what comments to expect given its association with two influential organizations. My objections vary somewhat from others, but overall I felt it was at risk of drifting into Not Even Wrong territory. The author suggests hard working middle class people are missing out on millions unfilled job openings ripe for the picking, because we don’t have good enough matching algorithms. One insult is suggesting desperate out of work people may not already be taking the extraordinary measures necessary to find the best positions they can get. I question even the validity of the claim, that “matching” is alone is keeping any significant number people out of work. Another insult is not mentioning a lot of these jobs may not be filled simply because the salary and opportunity for career development are not that great. Other topics like improving the educational system are grossly oversimplified given the competing interests of students, teachers, politics, and government. The biggest problem has been explained here on HN previously: Education doesn’t lack good ideas or innovation as much as it lacks funding to develop and implement the good ideas. Other points about how AI will remove concerns of bias seem naive, or at least not in tune with recent work like that from Facebook, that has faced an uphill battle trying to convince people its easy to create objective policy systems. I can see the benefit of articles that look at the current practical challenges of AI, and also more speculative articles that look at what the future may bring. This argument seems to be stuck in the middle, while not doing particularly well at either.
- wickawic 9y agoIt is both frustrating and enlighening to see that almost all replies to your comments and comment chains therein are grappling with your note that poor women may possibly have it harder than men. HN is not a good place to discuss issues relating to marginalized people; as a whole this is the least marginalized forum I could think of.
- zo1 9y agoThat's most likely due to the fact that this article/topic was non-gendered, or gender-neutral. And that the poster decided to inject it into the conversation. It may be a pertinent matter to discuss, or not, but it acted as a focal point in that comment. To be fair, I stopped reading that post at that point and moved on to the discussion chains. Only afterwards did I come back to it.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI actually think the discussion is going really well overall.
- wickawic 9y agoI agree with you because it is civil and good points are being made. As a general point though notice that assertions about women are met with requests for sources, but assertions about men are assumed true.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI hadn't really noticed, so I will just assume you are correct. But: It is an overwhelmingly male forum. So not surprising that men generally are more aware of male reality than of female reality. There have also been rebuttals of the worst and most inaccurate pro male comments. Most people here seem to genuinely be interested in understanding and not merely looking to shoot me down. It used to be a great deal more onesided and challenging, to the point where you couldn't say anything about the reality of women's lives without it being a flamewar or beatdown.
- EGreg 9y agoI have my own concerns, but not because of gender. Still what I want to comment on is the gendered poverty argument you made. I have been saying something similar for a long time! The wage gap, in my opinion, is a result of choices made by women in a society that expects them to be primary caregivers. I think that people should be paid to be caregivers for their own families. In fact, many new programs do exactly this. Still it is not reliably spread throughout the US federation. However, my concern is that subsidizing child care actually leads to overpopulation. I am worried about the Malthusian trap. http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=286 http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=286
- andrewprock 9y agoThe title of this post should really include "OpEd" or "Opinion" to make it clear that this isn't journalism, but punditry.
- andrewprock 9y agoThe most tragic aspect to the responses here is the strangely monochromatic assertion that only homeless people count as poor. Utterly bizarre.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoPeople tend to focus on their biggest fears. It is an overwhelmingly male forum. It's not really rational, but pointing to statistics about homelessness and gender as a way to dismiss other points about the feminization of poverty is really common. It probably comes from a place of fear and suggests to me that men are saying "It isn't like my life is just peachy. And if I can't hack it, then fuck me. Society won't do shit all for me." And that's not a crazy thing to be wrapped around the axle about, though it doesn't generally make for good debate.