3 ms·
Long story that I’m not fully familiar with short: the phone system suffers from the same trust issues that the internet does. That is, it wasn’t designed with
by falcolas 9y ago
Long story that I’m not fully familiar with short: the phone system suffers from the same trust issues that the internet does. That is, it wasn’t designed with things like adversarial users in mind.
EDIT: Am I incorrect in this statement? I'd love more feedback.
- johansch 9y agoWell, then, fix it.
- falcolas 9y agoSure thing. Let me switch industries, learn a completely new skillset, and rise to a point of power where I can affect such widespread (cross-state and company) changes. Shouldn't take more than a few months. /s
- johansch 9y agoWell, I do agree. I shouldn't take more than a few months to fix this. I don't live in the US, but I get the feeling something is terribly wrong with the way you're handling such a basic thing as a phone call, be it VOIP or not.
- SilasX 9y agoRight but in this case it was unproxied VoIP, right? It should be easy (in the sense of not requiring a forced universal protocol upgrade, I mean) to at least protect against this kind of attack — a caller from an LA IP claiming to be in Kansas.
- johansch 9y agoI agree; it should be technically trival to implement this. All of my comments along the lines of this are wildly downvoted though; I'm not quite sure why. Maybe privacy cowboys?
- falcolas 9y agoThere is another story happening in parallel to this where the Police arrested the wrong person based off the IP in use. IPs are just too ephemeral to trust for any form of location data. Not to mention the caller chose to call a line which would normally not have a lot of need for those protections, in comparison to 911.
- johansch 9y ago"IPs are just too ephemeral to trust for any form of location data" That is just policy decision. It would, for example, be possible to declare that no single IP should be used for more than two customers during a single X hour block.
- falcolas 9y agoA policy decision by whom? Specifically, how do you do this when IP spaces are controlled by various unfriendly countries around the world? Politics aside, the required technical coordination would be a nightmare. We can barely handle BGP without conflicts as-is. IPv4 space is also quite limited, and new devices are popping onto networks all the time. I'm not even sure a IP time window is feasible without a full move to IPv6 - something that policy makers have been trying to push on for years without success.
- johansch 9y ago>A policy decision by whom? By your government? > Specifically, how do you do this when IP spaces are controlled by various unfriendly countries around the world You begin a "911-certified program" that requires your local ISPs to register their IP ranges with some central authority. The rest is a bunch of detailed but solvable details. Your idealism when it comes to making this seem more complicatated that it really is seems misplaced.
- falcolas 9y agoWRT "just get the government to do it" US federal legislation, specifically not that driven by "terrorism" or "protect the children" (and we don't want any legislation under either label) tends to take years to go from initial idea to law. That doesn't count the years which would be added for compliance. Or the charter and formation of the "central authority". If we started today, we might get such a law in action sometime in the mid-2020's, at which point ISPs would have switched to IPv6 just to avoid the legislation. You know, maybe it would be a good idea after all /s My "idealism" is probably better called "pessimism", and is based off a couple of decades watching well-meaning legislation be mangled beyond repair by politicians and corporations, at the city level. People are complicated and irrational. People in politics are even more complicated and seemingly irrational, since even the best politicians have to balance the wants and needs of thousands of people and the businesses who employ those people. Politicians at the federal level are even more complicated, since they have 50 states, a number of territories, and gigantic corporations to consider. Even influencing a completely honest political group to do what everyone agrees is the right thing takes a significant amount of time, money, and effort. And if we're honest, they aren't all completely devoted to their constituents, and won't agree that it's the right thing to do.