4 ms·
“Ready Player One” is the worst thing nerd culture ever produced
- hitekker 9y agoFor those who have seen the trailer, consider this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5Lz14wu1uw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5Lz14wu1uw
- rrauenza 9y agoSite is overloaded ... here's the direct youtube link: https://youtu.be/BcTxIT6RyGc https://youtu.be/BcTxIT6RyGc
- ashark 9y agoBooks that are cringe-worthily bad in every possible way are sometimes, unaccountably, wildly successful and make their authors tons of money. It's frustrating if you're a) an author, and/or b) care about the genre or topic of such a book, but that's the way the world works and it exhibits no signs of changing any time soon. I don't get it either. No amount of pointing out how superbly awful they are ever seems to help.
- eropple 9y agoThe author of this piece isn't saying "this is awful" to tell people who like it that it's awful. (RP1 is awful, though.) The questions he's raising with the book as a springboard have to do with "fandom" in general and how and why it exists as it is. And what's wrong with it. And while I think this author is pretty self-indulgent in the way he writes, too, I think the point at the heart of it is a good one--'cause there is a lot wrong with it.
- Turing_Machine 9y ago> Books that are cringe-worthily bad in every possible way are sometimes, unaccountably, wildly successful Actually, it's quite easy to account for it: not everyone has the same tastes as you.
- ashark 9y agoI don't mean things-I-don't-like—there are lots of things I don't like that aren't bad—I mean books that are the literary equivalent of some of the worst films that make it on MST3K or Best of the Worst succeeding in a field of direct competitors, many of which are in every way superior, and not on the strength of any kind of cult following or reading-ironically or whatever, but for... some unknown and perhaps unknowable reason. It's like Cry Wilderness outperforming ET at the box office, and its fans not seeming to be in on any kind of joke, but sincerely preferring it. Just baffling. Or if Titanic, to deliberately pick a movie that's not gonna win the hearts of many film snobs anyway, had had every single shot nigh-comically misframed, weird scene transitions right in the middle of significant speech or actions, a CG Titanic that occasionally floated above and out of the water for no obvious reason, extras playing all the speaking roles, and so on, had still performed just as well and been popular among ordinary audiences, who betrayed, in interviews, no apparent awareness that the film was totally and obviously messed up in fundamental ways that ruined any kind of story or message it may have been trying to convey. But that actually happens sometimes with books. And then the critics go "wait... what? Did you... actually read it? It's very, very bad. I mean, you did notice that, right?" and the fans say "you just hate fun! Get your head out of the clouds! People like different things!" It's very confusing. Actually, now that I think about it, maybe this happens with books and not with movies because movies—especially those with any hope of popular success—pull you through the story rather by the nose, so it's more jarring when they entirely fail than when a book does. Maybe some people are so much better than me at getting lost in books that they're seamlessly replacing dialog, entire paragraphs of text, whole scenes, plot lines even, with things that don't suck, not even realizing they're doing it. I guess that'd explain it, if they're unconsciously live-fanfictioning the thing in their head to make it better.
- tarboreus 9y agoI meet a lot of people who share this perspective. They're the ones who remember one line from Harry Potter that repeats a word or who think the Da Vinci Code was the worst-written thing that year. I always think that these people must not read very widely, because these books aren't actually poorly written. Were you to read ten randomly published books in any year, you would understand that, actually, there are tiers and tiers of writing that are actually bad. Typically, the books people target for cultural derision have prose that is workmanlike at best but which have met with success due to tight plotting or pacing, which is difficult to construct, or because the subject of the book taps into something in the zeitgeist and expands some conversation society is having with itself (Gone Girl or Fifty Shades). The only NYT bestseller in recent years that comes close to your Titanic analogy is Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, a book that sold on its title alone and which I would not be surprised to learn not a single person has read, including the author. Most successful books of the stripe you're describing are more like a singlecamera situation comedy--they stick to a basic but largely innocuous set of prose conventions that won't win awards but allows the author to focus their efforts on elements their audience cares more about.
- edkennedy 9y agoSomeone forgot to have fun. Yeah, it's trash, but trash can be fun! I think getting out of your head and just enjoying something is important without needing to critically analyze it. It seems this book was pretty polarizing, like The Last Jedi.
- ashark 9y agoThere's plenty of competently-written trash to choose from, though. Most of the better genre fic falls in that category, and there's no shortage of it. Incidentally, I think it's fair to describe The Last Jedi's polarizing effect as having very different causes from something like RP1.
- eropple 9y agoDiametrically opposite causes, even. TLJ is a story about moving on from and getting over the past. RP1 is about obsessing over it and clinging to it.
- AgentME 9y agoWhat I loved about Ready Player One was that it was an unapologetic celebration of obsession and nostalgia. It was a plot contrived to create a setting where those qualities were what was needed to save the world. It's not particularly deep outside of that, and I don't really mind. Geekdom is becoming more popular in popular culture, but RP1 does it in a special way that I can appreciate. The Big Bang Theory does standard sitcom stuff and plays a laugh-track when recognizable "geeky" thing happens like a character having a Nintendo 64 on-screen for a moment. RP1 has an infodump about an easter egg and a glitch in a specific arcade game (... not entirely different than some of the type of nonfiction I like) and then works it into a contrived but fun plot point. It paints a world where many characters are driven by obsession, and that this isn't a spectacularly weird thing they do. (Yes, the book does take it to some amusing extremes.) Maybe it's the likely asperger's syndrome in me talking, but I feel like obsession is a big thing in my life, and it's fun to find a story that actually embraces that. Yes, I know that the way the character often interacts by trivia-dropping is grating outside of scenarios where trivia saves the world, and possibly still a bit grating within those scenarios. I never thought those parts were being portrayed otherwise. Yes, there's common problems with fandoms about gatekeeping and lack of inclusion, and no, I don't think it's unforgivable that RP1 doesn't address these. RP1's popularity is not a dismissal by society of these issues. No, I never thought it would be a good idea for human culture to stop creating new media and cling to 80's stuff, or felt like the book pushed for that at all. Maybe others read it differently, but I figured that the setting was like that just so the book could focus on 80s nostalgia specifically with no other media to get in the way while also having futuristic VR.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI thought the book was a really outstanding trip down nostalgia lane, and a great way to bridge the past with the future. However, that being said, I think the movie (from the trailers at least) appears to push things too futuristic.
- cannonedhamster 9y agoI listened to the audio book. Didn't seem like the worst book ever, seemed like a book made to guarantee a bunch of royalties. Wasn't the worst thing I've heard/read. I've read Ayn Rand which was definitely worse, but is still beloved by many. And here we are. Different people enjoy different things.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe claim in the headline isn't that it is the worst thing ever, just the worst thing produced by nerd culture. The Ayn Rand comparison seems off the mark, because while they may have been embraced by a segment of nerd culture, they are not products of that culture.