3 ms·
This basically turns it into a tax. You are saying that it will make more money for you than it costs to renew the fee. This would cause the vast majority of
by jandrese 9y ago
This basically turns it into a tax. You are saying that it will make more money for you than it costs to renew the fee. This would cause the vast majority of copyright held works to fall into the public domain even if the fee is very small.
I'm in favor of making the fee increase exponential though, just to make sure the things do eventually end up in the public domain. Say the first 20 years are free. Next 10 years are some nominal fee, maybe a couple of hundred bucks, but then you have to renew every 10 years and the fee increases one order of magnitude each time. Would Disney be willing to pay 20 billion dollars to keep Star Wars out of the public domain in 2077? Of course a billion dollars might be pocket change by then, who knows?
- nine_k 9y agoWhy, start with e.g. $1 the first year, and double it each subsequent year. For Star Wars, even after 25 years the sum would still be worth paying; maybe even after 30. For the vast majority of other commercially successful works, the original 20 years would probably be a very reasonable cutoff: few would generate seriously more than $1M in revenue to justify the copyright extension. Same should apply to patents.
- jandrese 9y agoIMHO making the payment every year would start to get onerous. Maybe it's premature optimization but I was thinking that keeping the timeline to once per decade would fall roughly in line with the pace at which Copyright systems normally move. It's also a "big government" idea, but having a central database for copywritten works would be a boon IMHO. It could have the year of creation, author, and a price with a contact/payment system for using the work instead of the huge hodgepodge we have now. I don't think anybody would disagree that finding the actual rights holders and negotiating licenses is anything but a nightmare on older works. It could also keep a copy of the original work for release when the copyright expires, the same way the Library of Congress keeps a copy of every book. Storage requirements would be high, but they could be paid through the fees people pay to keep their stuff in copyright. This would also mean a return to explicitly registering for copyright on a work, but IMHO that's a good thing. If you don't care enough to register why should the government care enough to protect your work? Registration should be dead simple, upload a copy/good description of the work to your copyright account and bam, you're registered. The only requirement on the upload is that the format must not be locked or proprietary, there must be an open/free viewer available. Downside of this system is that it's massive. Just absolutely enormous. Makes healthcare.gov look like a Geocities page. Huge number of man hours to maintain it every year. It ends up being the cultural database of the US very quickly.
- nine_k 9y agoWith a setup like I described, you could pay $2048 outright and forget about it for 10 years. A central database of copyrighted works would be great for preserving it. A lot of copyrighted work is usually published anyway (else you use an NDA, not copyright). Explicit registration, as long as it's indeed just registration, might have some merit, too. But I wonder how would it work for evolving copyrighted works, especially code. E.g. GPL leans heavily on copyright. How often should a GPL'd codebase be re-submitted to registration? I suppose explicit registration could be but an optional extra safety measure.
- jandrese 9y agoI don't think there will be a need to register a copyright unless you plan to make money on something. Maybe there could be a concept of a defensive copyright to prevent someone from downloading your work and submitting it as their own, but if you don't care who copies the work you don't really need protection against other people copying your work. The point about evolving works is a good one. It's kind of silly to have someone register a copyright on a blank page because they plan to add to it every week for a year. I'm also not sure how to handle a case like "We registered Photoshop in 1987, should the copyright expire in 2007 even though the 2007 version is completely different from the 1987 version? But can an artist add 1 microscopic dot to his painting every year and extend the copyright indefinitely for free?" This is where the rubber meets the road with IP law. I do kind of like the idea of very old versions of software entering the public domain even though the current version is still under copyright. If you want to go nuts with this, you could have a link from the big copyright database to Github or any similar repo and have a rolling copyright on the release. Code older than commit X is now public domain... I'd be wary of depending on external sources though, the Internet loses stuff all of the time and through negligence or vindictiveness the external sources would be lost. It's probably too much to ask the government to run govhub.