3 ms·
Unfortunately, it seems like these comments are only visible to Librarian's users, which doesn't make it much different from Hypothes.is [1] other than being li
by Vinnl 9y ago
Unfortunately, it seems like these comments are only visible to Librarian's users, which doesn't make it much different from Hypothes.is [1] other than being limited to arXiv, and makes comments less discoverable. arXiv should really add such a feature itself/have open sourced its code so they could've added it there.
[1] http://hypothes.is/ http://hypothes.is/
- horsecaptin 9y agoIt's tricky. Many (most?) researchers would rather have a closed discussion with other researchers with domain expertise than an open one where they have to deal with public comments.
- hyperpape 9y agoI've always thought stack overflow could be the start of a model for an academic archive.
- throwawayaway12 9y agoI think this is certainly true. Research papers are typically written so that a person with training in the field can understand and replicate the work. Note that the general population is not the intended audience. Mediums like news articles and blog posts are a more effective way of explaining the background and significance of a certain piece of research to the masses.
- Vinnl 9y agoYes, but that's still hard if half of those other researchers are on Librarian, and half of them are on Hypothes.is.